VOTES: Rd 22 vs Carlton

[loges 6,767]

10 hours ago, Clint Bizkit said:

In a time when we can’t buy goals, Melksham kicks four and he isn’t top vote getter for everyone?

I love Petty but come on, people.

Was the difference 

[Deeoldfart 8,162]

6.  Melksham

5.  Brayshaw

4.  Petty

3.  Oliver

2.  Gawn

1.  Hunt

The next two:  Viney, May

Edited August 14, 2022 by Deeoldfart

[La Dee-vina Comedia 17,071]

6. Brayshaw

5. Melksham

4. Petty

3. Hunt

2. Salem

1. Gawn

Any of the following could have been given the last vote: May, Oliver, Patracca and Viney

[Roger Mellie 4,179]

13 hours ago, Maldonboy38 said:

6. Brayshaw

5. Melksham

4. Petty

3. Oliver

2. Hunt

1. Gawn

+ 1

[Travy14 2,120]

5 - Melksham

4 - Oliver

3 - Gawn

2 - Petty

1 - Brayshaw 

[bluey 1,118]

6 Brayshaw

5 Salem

4 Melsham

3 Oliver

2 Petracca

1 Gawn

 

 

[Jibroni 5,048]

6. Brayshaw

5. Melksham

4. Petty

3. VIney

2. Hunt

1. Gawn

[CityDee 738]

6 .  Viney

5 .  Petty

4.  Melksham

3. Hunt

2 . May 

1 . Kozzie!!!’ 

[Flower Magic 776]

14 hours ago, Redlagged said:

Bit mystified by the praise heaped on Petty. May was much better. And I thought Gawn was outstanding. Brayshaw had a heap of disposals, but many of them were terrible.

 

I watched the replay this morning because I thought I must have missed something about Petty's game watching from the lower level of seating last night. But no, nothing changed. I saw a serviceable game, nothing more. Petty gave away three unnecessary free kicks (a quarter of Carlton's total received). He has a bad habit of pushing his opponent in the back when caught behind (see the Pies' crucial last goal last week). Yes, he saved a couple of goals, but isn't that a defender's role? Agree that May's game was far superior. Curnow's lack of influence had more to do with Carlton's delivery (or lack thereof) to him. It seems to me that many people casting votes here are influenced by the TV commentary rather than using their own eyes..

Edited August 14, 2022 by Flower Magic

[Demonland 73,834]

Clayton Oliver almost has it in the bag.

229. Clayton Oliver

171. Christian Petracca

145. Angus Brayshaw 

128. Jack Viney

105. Max Gawn

80. Steven May

71. Ed Langdon

52. James Jordon

44. Kysaiah Pickett 

32. Jake Lever

31. Luke Jackson Harry Petty 

29. Bayley Fritsch

26. James Harmes

22. Jake Bowey Michael Hibberd Tom Sparrow

18. Ben Brown 

17. Jake Melksham 

11. Alex Neal-Bullen

8. Tom McDonald Sam Weideman

5. Jayden Hunt Charlie Spargo

4. Christian Salem

3. Joel Smith

[Fanatique Demon 2,695]

3 hours ago, Demonland said:

Clayton Oliver almost has it in the bag.

And rightly so! Go Clarry!

[Tarax Club 4,123]

19 hours ago, Tarax Club said:

6 Angus Brayshaw

5 Jake Melksham

4 Max Gawn

3 Clayton Oliver

2 Jack Viney

1 Jayden Hunt

Honourable mentions;

Kysaiah Pickett

Christian Salem

Adjudication;

Despite the disparity of free kicks. forward fifty free kicks favoured the Blues. These are 'gold tickets' in close games. Fortunately Carlton's forwards couldn't  deliver.

Broadcasters;

Back to plan B contenders triumph pretenders sent packing.

Overall Comment;

Cathartic and season defining

 

 

Erratum:

Honourable mentions;

Harrison Petty

Steven May

Ben Brown

[Boots and all 1,000]

6. Brayshaw

5. Oliver

4. Melk

3. Max

2. Petty

1. Hunt

[DubDee 26,385]

8 hours ago, Flower Magic said:

I watched the replay this morning because I thought I must have missed something about Petty's game watching from the lower level of seating last night. But no, nothing changed. I saw a serviceable game, nothing more. Petty gave away three unnecessary free kicks (a quarter of Carlton's total received). He has a bad habit of pushing his opponent in the back when caught behind (see the Pies' crucial last goal last week). Yes, he saved a couple of goals, but isn't that a defender's role? Agree that May's game was far superior. Curnow's lack of influence had more to do with Carlton's delivery (or lack thereof) to him. It seems to me that many people casting votes here are influenced by the TV commentary rather than using their own eyes..

Agree. Petty played a good quality game. He is a favourite on here though. May was better imo

6 milkshake

5 May

4 Brayshaw

3 Gawn

2 Petty

1 Oliver 

hunt stiff

[Wizard of Koz 1,173]

7 hours ago, Fanatique Demon said:

And rightly so! Go Clarry!

He is well and truly down the track of being one of if not the MFC's greatest ever. No-one, not even Robbie or Barrassi, were as consistently superb as Clayton. Thats my opinion anyway. 

[layzie 34,374]

19 hours ago, Flower Magic said:

I watched the replay this morning because I thought I must have missed something about Petty's game watching from the lower level of seating last night. But no, nothing changed. I saw a serviceable game, nothing more. Petty gave away three unnecessary free kicks (a quarter of Carlton's total received). He has a bad habit of pushing his opponent in the back when caught behind (see the Pies' crucial last goal last week). Yes, he saved a couple of goals, but isn't that a defender's role? Agree that May's game was far superior. Curnow's lack of influence had more to do with Carlton's delivery (or lack thereof) to him. It seems to me that many people casting votes here are influenced by the TV commentary rather than using their own eyes..

A fair take. I hadn’t heard the TV commentary when I did my votes and maybe had him a little high but I had really liked the way he played Curnow on the night. I watched it again and agree disposal to him wasn’t flash but Petty had the aerobic capacity to go with Curnow and to hold a guy leading the Coleman to 1 goal and 1 inside 50 mark wasn’t a bad effort. 

Thought some of the frees that went against him were brutal as well. 
 

[Maluski 24]

6 Milkshake

5 Petty

4 Hunt

3 Salem

2 Brayshaw 

1 Gawn

 

 

[spirit of norm smith 16,651]

1 Clayton Oliver

2 Christian Petracca

3 Angus Brayshaw 

4 Jack Viney

5 Max Gawn
 

Confident that this will be the finishing order in our B&F 

though Max missing games may drop him down 

May might get #5 which would be a good reward for another very good year imv 

[picket fence 18,062]

6 Jayden Hunt

5 Clarry Choo Choo

4 Gus

3 Milkshake

2 Max

1 May

[old55 23,847]

Can I give all 21 to Melky. He actually kicked 5 goals if the BB out of bounds wasn't called and he made the tackle on Silvagni at the death which should have been holding the ball, and was every time against us in the same part of the ground the week before. Should have been 6 goals including the sealer.

Edited August 18, 2022 by old55

[Guest]

1 hour ago, old55 said:

Can I give all 21 to Melky. He actually kicked 5 goals if the BB out of bounds wasn't called and he made the tackle on Silvagni at the death which should have been holding the ball, and was every time against us in the same part of the ground the week before. Should have been 6 goals including the sealer.

… and we shouldn’t forget who fed the ball out to Kozzy which resulted in THAT goal. 👍🏽

[Gawndy the Great 9,011]

On 8/14/2022 at 3:36 PM, Demonland said:

Clayton Oliver almost has it in the bag.

229. Clayton Oliver

171. Christian Petracca

145. Angus Brayshaw 

128. Jack Viney

105. Max Gawn

80. Steven May

71. Ed Langdon

52. James Jordon

44. Kysaiah Pickett 

32. Jake Lever

31. Luke Jackson Harry Petty 

29. Bayley Fritsch

26. James Harmes

22. Jake Bowey Michael Hibberd Tom Sparrow

18. Ben Brown 

17. Jake Melksham 

11. Alex Neal-Bullen

8. Tom McDonald Sam Weideman

5. Jayden Hunt Charlie Spargo

4. Christian Salem

3. Joel Smith

4 votes for Salem is a big standout here. And before everyone reminds me of his injury and missing games, 4 votes is still a massively understanding for a man of his capability. Hoping he can find some late form. 

[leave it to deever 17,598]

Off topic here.

 

But wasn't Saids tackle and dumping of Kozzie holding the man?

Kozzie no longerchad tge ball and he was rag dolled to the ground 20 seconds later.

[Willmoy1947 4,218]

Melksham.Backmen especially big awkward ones don't like a bloke who keeps on putting hips into their soft, sore parts when they're not ready/ looking