Your votes please 6,5,4,3,2,1 …

6. Clarry

5. May

4. Spargo

3. Tmac

2. Kozzie

1. Umpires

Didn't see any of the game so can't vote, but this was Luke Ball's assessment on ABC Radio.

3.  Clayton Oliver (clear B.O.G.)

2.  Jake Lever

1.  Christian Petracca

6. Oliver

5. Petracca

4. May

3. Sparrow

2. Fritsch

1. McDonald

6, Oliver

5. Pickett

4. MacDonald

3. Spargo

2. Jackson

1. Petracca 

6. Oliver

5. Lever

4. May

3. McDonald

2. Pickett

1. Spargo

6. Mr Claztastic Clayton Oliver

5. Christian Petracca

4. Jake Lever

3. Tom Sparrow

2. Tom McDonald

1. Kozzie Pickett 

Clarrie

Trac

Sparrow

Lever

Spargo

Jordon

 

Oliver is the best player in my lifetime watching Melbourne. Sorry Robbie.

6 Clarry by a mile thank god for him

5 Petracca

4 Sparrow

3 Jordon

2 Fritsch

1 McDonald

6 Clayton Oliver

5 Christian Petracca

4 Tom Sparrow

3 Jake Lever

2 Steven May

1 Bayley Fritsch

Honourable mentions;

Max Gawn 

Luke Jackson

Alex Neal-Bullen

Trent Rivers

Tom McDonald

Kysaiah Pickett

Adjudication;

Couldn’t complain those who made the play got rewarded.

TV broadcast;

Jason Dunstall and Nick Riewoldt tend to make sense. Whoever was responsible for gratuitous comment about Ed Langdon tackle being ‘acceptable’ go to straight to dunce’s corner with the appropriate hat. 

Overall comment;

Opponents provided a contest with plenty of old fashioned physicality. Demons challenged but too classy in the wash up.

 

 

 

 

 

Edited May 21, 20223 yr by Tarax Club
Saint Nick’s halo is askew

6- Oliver 

 

 

daylight 

 

 

5 - Lever 

4- Trac 

daylight 

3- Gawn 

2- Fritsch 

1- Sparrow 

apologies. Rivers and Spargo

6. OIiver

5. Lever

4. May

3. Sparrow

2. TMac

1. Trac

Carry

Lever 

Spargo

May

Tmac

Pickett

 

6. Clarry

5.Lever

4. May

3. Trac

2. Koz

1. Spargo

42 minutes ago, Wrecker46 said:

Oliver is the best player in my lifetime watching Melbourne. Sorry Robbie.

Sorry had to reply.  Robbie was just an amazing player. His courage, his skill, his pace, his marking, his goalkicking, his weaving. All were elite.  
 

Clarry is a legend. A bull.  Wins more contested footy than anyone I can think of. He accumulates.  He wills himself to each contest. But his skills and goalkicking is not elite.  In my view Clarry is and will be one of our greatest BUT he doesn’t pass Robbie for pure footy and an all around elite game.  

6 - Clarry - (magnificent dragged us over the line)

5 - Lever (playing himself back in)

4 - May - (flew the flag)

3 - Tracc (made things happen)

2 - Sparrow ( tried his guts out)

1 - TMac (plays better when angry)

1000 votes and the Brownlow medal to Clarry, the contested Beast!

No Doubt he is our superstar

6. Oliver

5. May

4. Spargo

3. TMac

2. Sparrow

1. Lever

 

38 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

6- Oliver 

 

 

daylight 

 

 

5 - Lever 

4- Trac 

daylight 

3- Gawn 

2- Fritsch 

1- Sparrow 

apologies. Rivers and Spargo

Max wasn't good today.

6: oliver
5: lever
4: petracca
3: spargo
2: fritsch
1: pickett

6 Clarry

5 Trac

4 May

3 T Mac

2  lever

1 Sparrow and Spargs

Edited May 21, 20223 yr by CYB

6.  Clarry boy you star!!!!

 

5.  Lever

4.  Tracc

3.  Sparrow

2.  Plugga Mac

1.  May

Apologies Dogga, SparGOAT, Fritsch & Kozz

 

Edited May 21, 20223 yr by Demon Dynasty

6. Oliver

5. Petracca 

4. Lever

3. May

2. McDonald

1. Fritsch

Oliver

Petracca

May

Lever

Spargo

Sparrow