6. Oliver

5. Petracca

4. Langdon

3. Gawn

2. Lever

1. ANB

1 hour ago, Billy said:

Oliver 

✌

6 Oliver

5 Gawn - kept us in it in the first half

4 Trac

3 lever

2 Langdon 

1 Harmes

Gawn is getting to stage of being criminally underrated by his own supporters 

6 Oliver

Daylight

5 Petracca 

4 Langdon

3 Lever

2 Harmes

1 Max

I gotta say that from 5-1 they just more did good things but were still sloppy. Max did enough but cost us goals with dropped marks, bad taps, and being painfully slow at the end.

Oliver should get the 10 coaches votes tonight.  

4 minutes ago, DubDee said:

Gawn is getting to stage of being criminally underrated by his own supporters 

I think he would be the first to admit he had an off night, he did some very uncharacteristic mistakes. 

1 hour ago, goodoil said:

6. Clayton Oliver

5. Christian Petracca

4. Max Gwn

3. Jake Lever

2. Ed Langdon

1. James Harmes

I am going with good oil tonight, mammoth second half by Clayton our Fwds non existent.

6.  Oliver

5.  Petracca

4.  Langdon

3.  Lever

2.  Gawn

1.  Jackson

4 minutes ago, Pates said:

I think he would be the first to admit he had an off night, he did some very uncharacteristic mistakes. 

I must have watched a different game. It was his best game for weeks. 5 contested marks. Taps very good

6 Oliver

5 Petracca

4 Langdon

3 Lever

2 Jackson

1 Gawn

6 Oliver (I haven't seen a Demon throw the side on their back like that in a long time)

5 Lever

4 Gawn

3 Petracca

2 Langdon

1 Jackson

43 minutes ago, Pates said:

I think he would be the first to admit he had an off night, he did some very uncharacteristic mistakes. 

A couple of mistakes doesn't cancel out a player's influence. 20 possessions, 10 marks and a goal.

2 hours ago, deemonic666 said:

6. Oliver

5. Petracca

4. Langdon

3. Lever

2. Jackson

1. Gawn

I cannot go past these votes

21. Oliver

6 Oliver

5 Gawn

4 Petracca

3 Langdon 

2 Lever

1 Brayshaw

6. Oliver

5. Petracca

4. Langdon

3. Jackson

2. Gawn

1. Lever

 

I thought a lot of our players stunk up the joint tonight. 

6. Oliver

5. Petracca

4. Langdon

3. Gawn

2. Lever

1. Jackson

 

Give them all to Oliver please. Rest just average.

6 Oliver

5 Petracca

4 Langdon

3 Gawn

2 Lever

1 Harmes

6. Oliver

5. Petracca

4. Langdon

3. Lever

2. ANB

1. Jackson

I cannot fathom giving votes to Gawn. He was up against one of the worst Ruckman in the league today. His game was all stats no product and to top it off, he made 2-3 mistakes that led directly to goals for the crows. Not good enough for the votes.

Edited May 22, 20214 yr by MurDoc516

7 hours ago, Swooper1987 said:

The first point can sometimes be overcome by a team mate running past for an easy handball receive. It did happen once or twice tonight.

The second - he took 10 and dropped 2.

If you are talking about first option then I'd be lining up Petracca, Harmes and most of the rest of the team before Max.

Can't say that I've noticed the spoiling of team mates as a significant problem.  As probably the best contested mark in the game maybe they should be providing coverage for him so he doesn't get bashed from pillar to post every game, or get out of his way.

The final one was a disgraceful flat footed effort by both Hibberd (Rowe's man) and Oliver.  As pointed out on the commentary there was nothing wrong with the tap.  It went exactly where it was supposed to.  Hibberd was supposed to check Rowe - he didn't; and Oliver didn't move (he should have).  The whole clearance thing is an inexact science with multiple variables.  Being on the move is one of the non-negotiables.

So my point stands - Max's errors did not contribute any more substantially to the loss than most of the others that were made tonight.

The final one was on Hibberd IMO, he got in Oliver’s way

3 hours ago, MurDoc516 said:

 

I cannot fathom giving votes to Gawn. He was up against one of the worst Ruckman in the league today. His game was all stats no product and to top it off, he made 2-3 mistakes that led directly to goals for the crows. Not good enough for the votes.

A bit harsh on Gawn. Reality is we only had 2 good players. Oliver had a blinder and Petracca was good even though his fumble cost us the game. The rest you could have given votes to anybody no one was really worthy of votes. To only go down by a point and it should have at least been a draw due to that home town deliberate decision not being paid was a good effort.

6. Clayton Oliver 

5. Christian Petracca 

4. Ed Langdon 

3. Max Gawn 

2. Jake Lever 

1.  Luke Jackson

11 hours ago, Pates said:

6 Oliver

Daylight

5 Petracca 

4 Langdon

3 Lever

2 Harmes

1 Max

I gotta say that from 5-1 they just more did good things but were still sloppy. Max did enough but cost us goals with dropped marks, bad taps, and being painfully slow at the end.

Oliver should get the 10 coaches votes tonight.  

Nailed it 

7 hours ago, MurDoc516 said:

6. Oliver

5. Petracca

4. Langdon

3. Lever

2. ANB

1. Jackson

I cannot fathom giving votes to Gawn. He was up against one of the worst Ruckman in the league today. His game was all stats no product and to top it off, he made 2-3 mistakes that led directly to goals for the crows. Not good enough for the votes.

Have a look at the Crows Coach presser. You might form a different view. Yet you include Petracca who made many more errors than Gawn, and Jackson because of?