Here is the current players win % in the red and blue as of round 5 2021

No. Player	Games for the Dees	Wins	Losses	Draw	Win %
23. James Jordon	5	5	0		100.00
6. Luke Jackson	11	9	2		81.82
24. Trent Rivers	14	10	4		71.43
20. Adam Tomlinson	18	12	6		66.67
32. Tom Sparrow	12	8	4		66.67
38. Mitch Brown	6	4	2		66.67
9. Charlie Spargo	39	25	14		64.10
15. Ed Langdon	22	14	8		63.64
36. Kysaiah Pickett	19	12	7		63.16
18. Jake Melksham	74	41	33		55.41
8. Jake Lever	41	22	19		53.66
26. Sam Weideman	44	23	21		52.27
13. Clayton Oliver	104	54	50		51.92
30. Alex Neal-Bullen	85	44	41		51.76
1. Steven May	29	15	14		51.72
22. Aaron Vandenberg	47	24	23		51.06
31. Bayley Fritsch	65	33	32		50.77
37. Kade Chandler	2	1	1		50.00
5. Christian Petracca	107	53	54		49.53
14. Michael Hibberd	73	36	37		49.32
10. Angus Brayshaw	99	47	52		47.47
29. Jayden Hunt	79	37	42		46.84
4. James Harmes	105	49	56		46.67
3. Christian Salem	111	51	60		45.95
44. Joel Smith	18	8	10		44.44
11. Max Gawn	139	58	81		41.73
39. Neville Jetta	156	61	95	2	39.10
25. Tom McDonald	175	68	107		38.86
7. Jack Viney	139	52	87		37.41
41. Jay Lockhart	22	8	14		36.36
34. Marty Hore	14	5	9		35.71
2. Nathan Jones	299	98	198	3	32.78
33. Oscar Baker	13	4	9		30.77
35. Harrison Petty	12	3	9		25.00
12. Toby Bedford	2	0	2		0.00

 

Where is Werridee? We need a team based on the 22 winningest players.

Very interesting. Spargs had to be loving life. It kind of reminds you how very few games we’ve won in the past decade. Even Trac and Brayshaw aren’t on positive terms. 

Jordon at 100% and Jones at 32%; timing is everything.....

Good to see the younger blokes experiencing the winning feeling regularly. Great for confidence and belief

1 hour ago, FritschyBusiness said:

Here is the current players win % in the red and blue as of round 5 2021

No. Player	Games for the Dees	Wins	Losses	Draw	Win %
23. James Jordon	5	5	0		100.00
6. Luke Jackson	11	9	2		81.82
24. Trent Rivers	14	10	4		71.43
20. Adam Tomlinson	18	12	6		66.67
32. Tom Sparrow	12	8	4		66.67
38. Mitch Brown	6	4	2		66.67
9. Charlie Spargo	39	25	14		64.10
15. Ed Langdon	22	14	8		63.64
36. Kysaiah Pickett	19	12	7		63.16
18. Jake Melksham	74	41	33		55.41
8. Jake Lever	41	22	19		53.66
26. Sam Weideman	44	23	21		52.27
13. Clayton Oliver	104	54	50		51.92
30. Alex Neal-Bullen	85	44	41		51.76
1. Steven May	29	15	14		51.72
22. Aaron Vandenberg	47	24	23		51.06
31. Bayley Fritsch	65	33	32		50.77
37. Kade Chandler	2	1	1		50.00
5. Christian Petracca	107	53	54		49.53
14. Michael Hibberd	73	36	37		49.32
10. Angus Brayshaw	99	47	52		47.47
29. Jayden Hunt	79	37	42		46.84
4. James Harmes	105	49	56		46.67
3. Christian Salem	111	51	60		45.95
44. Joel Smith	18	8	10		44.44
11. Max Gawn	139	58	81		41.73
39. Neville Jetta	156	61	95	2	39.10
25. Tom McDonald	175	68	107		38.86
7. Jack Viney	139	52	87		37.41
41. Jay Lockhart	22	8	14		36.36
34. Marty Hore	14	5	9		35.71
2. Nathan Jones	299	98	198	3	32.78
33. Oscar Baker	13	4	9		30.77
35. Harrison Petty	12	3	9		25.00
12. Toby Bedford	2	0	2		0.00

 

So basically scrap all players from Tracc down and we'll go undefeated for the entire season.

How does this compare to Cam Pedersen's percentage? I feel like we won every game he played for us there for a while.

1 hour ago, Chook said:

How does this compare to Cam Pedersen's percentage? I feel like we won every game he played for us there for a while.

Cam Pedersen for Melbourne

Games                                     W.                    L                                      %

64

22

42

34.38

Earl Spalding. 109 games. 65% win rate. 
Great period over 1987-1991. 

I'm genuinely surprised that Jones is as high as 32.78%. Essentially a one in three strike rate. I thought it would be much worse than that.

The winningest player with more than 50 games?

Jake.

Melksham.

Some of you just grated your teeth so loudly.

Just stop it, it’s an awful sound.

Players like Trevor Castles, Ross Fisher and Robin Andrew are in the pantheon that have cast in concrete 100% winning records for MFC. They are truly the unimpeachable undefeated. 

Edited April 23, 20214 yr by John Crow Batty

Charlie Spargo 39 games for a 64% winning percentage.  Not bad.

Jordon cannot be dropped. Clearly he is the lucky charm. 

Oscar Baker and Joel Smith are the 2 that stand out to me. Interesting.

The winning feeling

the young kids have got it

Huge game tomorrow night

Looks like James Jordan is the new Clyde Laidlaw!

(Fingers crossed because that's an 81% win rate and four premierships in 124 games)

1 hour ago, Little Goffy said:

Looks like James Jordan is the new Clyde Laidlaw!

It would appear that he is the new Jack Trengrove.  

Nathan Jones is hardly setting a good example when it comes to winning.

Updated:

No. Player	Games	Wins	Losses	Draw	Win %
23. James Jordon	6	6	0		100.00
6. Luke Jackson	12	10	2		83.33
24. Trent Rivers	15	11	4		73.33
20. Adam Tomlinson	19	13	6		68.42
32. Tom Sparrow	12	8	4		66.67
38. Mitch Brown	6	4	2		66.67
15. Ed Langdon	23	15	8		65.22
9. Charlie Spargo	40	26	14		65.00
36. Kysaiah Pickett	20	13	7		65.00
18. Jake Melksham	75	42	33		56.00
8. Jake Lever	42	23	19		54.76
1. Steven May	30	16	14		53.33
13. Clayton Oliver	105	55	50		52.38
30. Alex Neal-Bullen	86	45	41		52.33
26. Sam Weideman	44	23	21		52.27
31. Bayley Fritsch	66	34	32		51.52
22. Aaron Vandenberg	47	24	23		51.06
37. Kade Chandler	2	1	1		50.00
5. Christian Petracca	108	54	54		50.00
14. Michael Hibberd	74	37	37		50.00
10. Angus Brayshaw	100	48	52		48.00
29. Jayden Hunt	80	38	42		47.50
4. James Harmes	105	49	56		46.67
3. Christian Salem	112	52	60		46.43
44. Joel Smith	18	8	10		44.44
11. Max Gawn	140	59	81		42.14
25. Tom McDonald	176	69	107		39.20
39. Neville Jetta	156	61	95	2	39.10
7. Jack Viney	140	53	87		37.86
41. Jay Lockhart	22	8	14		36.36
34. Marty Hore	14	5	9		35.71
2. Nathan Jones	300	99	198	3	33.00
33. Oscar Baker	13	4	9		30.77
35. Harrison Petty	12	3	9		25.00
12. Toby Bedford	2	0	2		0.00

Dean Terlich: 35 games, 5 won, 30 lost

Winning Percentage = 14% 

 

20 minutes ago, FritschyBusiness said:

Updated:
 

No. Player	Games	Wins	Losses	Draw	Win %
23. James Jordon	6	6	0		100.00
6. Luke Jackson	12	10	2		83.33
24. Trent Rivers	15	11	4		73.33
20. Adam Tomlinson	19	13	6		68.42
32. Tom Sparrow	12	8	4		66.67
38. Mitch Brown	6	4	2		66.67
15. Ed Langdon	23	15	8		65.22
9. Charlie Spargo	40	26	14		65.00
36. Kysaiah Pickett	20	13	7		65.00
18. Jake Melksham	75	42	33		56.00
8. Jake Lever	42	23	19		54.76
1. Steven May	30	16	14		53.33
13. Clayton Oliver	105	55	50		52.38
30. Alex Neal-Bullen	86	45	41		52.33
26. Sam Weideman	44	23	21		52.27
31. Bayley Fritsch	66	34	32		51.52
22. Aaron Vandenberg	47	24	23		51.06
37. Kade Chandler	2	1	1		50.00
5. Christian Petracca	108	54	54		50.00
14. Michael Hibberd	74	37	37		50.00
10. Angus Brayshaw	100	48	52		48.00
29. Jayden Hunt	80	38	42		47.50
4. James Harmes	105	49	56		46.67
3. Christian Salem	112	52	60		46.43
44. Joel Smith	18	8	10		44.44
11. Max Gawn	140	59	81		42.14
25. Tom McDonald	176	69	107		39.20
39. Neville Jetta	156	61	95	2	39.10
7. Jack Viney	140	53	87		37.86
41. Jay Lockhart	22	8	14		36.36
34. Marty Hore	14	5	9		35.71
2. Nathan Jones	300	99	198	3	33.00
33. Oscar Baker	13	4	9		30.77
35. Harrison Petty	12	3	9		25.00
12. Toby Bedford	2	0	2		0.00

Trac made it to 50% ! 

When Viney gets to 50% we'll be really cookin!

29 minutes ago, DubDee said:

Dean Terlich: 35 games, 5 won, 30 lost

Winning Percentage = 14% 

 

Can't think of a player who very obviously had NOPE stamped on his name in big letters by a coach. 

Third in the B&F in 2013, in and out of the side in 2014 under Roos. Signed on for two years at the end of 2014, played two full seasons in the VFL when just about every other player on the senior list got picked at some point. Almost seemed like a stubborn standoff between coach and player in the end. Pretty funny in hindsight - probably not for Dean though.

28 minutes ago, DubDee said:

Trac made it to 50% ! 

When Viney gets to 50% we'll be really cookin!

Winning the next 34 on the trot isn't too much to ask for is it?

It is interesting that Viney's winning percentage is almost as low as Jones'.

It makes sense after a moment - Viney missed that couple of nearly competitive years under Bailey where we got the 8-9 wins a season, but was on deck from 2013 so got to participate in some of our worst.

Also missed a bunch of wins in 2018 through injury.

This is as good a moment as any to note how much he has been exemplifying the team-first approach this year.  Not having flashy games but playing an accouable role that releases Oliver and Petracca to do more. He's the Tomlinson of our midfield! ?