Scully "steps away"

[Stein9193 129]

Couldn't care less. I'm pleased that he's done. He took the money and ran, that doesn't mean he's entitled to me now feeling sorry for him. I don't care about his family, his dad his wife, his gardener, his former roommate or anyone relating to him I've never met including he himself. So long and good luck.

Edited January 26, 2021 by Stein9193

[rjay 24,916]

39 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

I know all that. A Ball magnet who is not a good kick is not the best player of Football in the land. 
the recruiters and media completely misread the room. 
it just so happened we had the first 2 picks and the 3rd Player is now one of the Greatest of all time. 
 

just so MFC

He was the consensus number one, so not just so MFC in this case.

At the time the Tiges would have loved him...grew up a Richmond supporter.

How lucky were they to miss???

[Fork 'em 6,983]

46 minutes ago, Sir Why You Little said:

I know all that. A Ball magnet who is not a good kick is not the best player of Football in the land. 
the recruiters and media completely misread the room. 
it just so happened we had the first 2 picks and the 3rd Player is now one of the Greatest of all time. 
 

just so MFC

Every-one's a genius recruiter with 10yrs of hindsight.
5-6yrs ago Martin shopped himself around for big coin and got no takers.
Still a loose cannon.
I think it was the rocket he needed to prove every-one wrong.
Would the same thing have happened if we picked him up ..... Who knows.

Edited January 26, 2021 by Fork 'em

[radar 1,865]

Pretty sure Tigers took Tamblyn and Deledio in same draft overlooking Buddy and Cyril. 
We got same compo for Scully as Cats got for Ablett 

[Macca 16,958]

1 hour ago, rjay said:

He was the consensus number one, so not just so MFC in this case.

At the time the Tiges would have loved him...grew up a Richmond supporter.

How lucky were they to miss???

McMahon didn't miss though

If he misses that shot for goal a lot of things could (or would) have been different

It was a real sliding doors moment ... Tiger fans who for years were filthy that McMahon kicked that goal are probably now thankful that he did kick the goal

Do Richmond win the 3 flags without Martin? And if they had have lost that game against us does Martin end up elsewhere?

It should be remembered that Trengove was all the rage as well and the Tigers might have picked Trengove over Martin if Jack was available.  Or Scully of course who they were just as enamoured with

One goal kicked or missed changes the course of history.  The bottom end of the ladder in 2009 had 3 or 4 teams that weren't trying to win so any unplanned win didn't suit any of those teams

 

Edited January 26, 2021 by Macca

[Pennant St Dee 13,171]

I wish him no ill, the club is bigger than any player.

Hope he is in a good place health wise 

[Fork 'em 6,983]

1 hour ago, Macca said:

 Do Richmond win the 3 flags without Martin? And if they had have lost that game against us does Martin end up elsewhere?

It should be remembered that Trengove was all the rage as well and the Tigers might have picked Trengove over Martin if Jack was available.  Or Scully of course who they were just as enamoured with

 

 

No they don't win 3 flags wthout Martin.
Be lucky to win one.
 
Saw Brendan Gale recently tried to write/re-write history by declaring they would have taken him at 1.

[Pates 9,660]

The Scully/Trenners vs Martin debate has been done to death but I'll add a quick 2 cents to the argument. Development wise we were such a ridiculous basket case at the time and I really think the tanking issues with creating a culture of losing played it's part in it. I think we could've been handed the greatest player potential wise (I'm talking Judd, Ablett, Voss etc) and still completely stuffed up his development. Therefor I see the argument of who we chose being moot, I think Dusty should just count his blessings that we didn't choose him.

[Half forward flank 1,022]

7 hours ago, Sir Why You Little said:

I remember the talk well, but I could never understand the hype after seeing him play. He was worthy of playing AFL level, but he was never the number 1 kid in the land. I took an interest in him earlier than usual, because my Uncle was an Old Hailebury boy, so he was talking him up.

Just strange times, the MFC was all over the place

Yes, I remember the talk well  too. It was like a boys club where no one was prepared to speak their own mind. I do not want to sound a know all but I was also massively underwhelmed when I saw Sheahans footage on Jack watts at Brighton on his Future stars program. All I saw was a kid taller than his opponent lead out, mark and kick from 35 to 40 with no pressure on. I felt we were looking for players who were clones of the type of players we needed regardless of their real attributes or desire.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,816]

Surprised MFC supporters still hate him.

Yes, in 2012 and 2013 I can understand the hate but surely by now he's a long forgotten former MFC player that is now at his third club and is probably near retirement.

 

[Macca 16,958]

7 hours ago, Fork 'em said:

No they don't win 3 flags wthout Martin.
Be lucky to win one.
 
Saw Brendan Gale recently tried to write/re-write history by declaring they would have taken him at 1.

The book title?

The 3 Flags of Richmond (How Jordan McMahon Changed the Course of History)

And it shouldn't be forgotten that Richmond were also tanking that day ... they and their supporters desperately wanted Scully

[KingDingAling 3,757]

I would’ve took the money too if I were Scully. We were a basket case of a club. He set himself up for life. Made the most out of a very limited skill set. When it’s all said and done Scully was an above average athlete and below average football player. He got paid millions more than footballers twice his capability. Fair play to him. 

[nosoupforme 3,085]

In 2012 Tom Scully moved to GWS on a six figure sum and signed a contract for six years worth six million dollars, However his father Phil was also working as a  recruiting officer for the Giants and was on a 100,000 dollars a year for six years. Not long before signing Tom.

How coincidental,   as Tom stated he had no knowledge of  an offer to his father prior to signing  his own deal.

That is not fair play.

Edited January 26, 2021 by nosoupforme

[dazzledavey36 54,832]

1 hour ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Surprised MFC supporters still hate him.

Yes, in 2012 and 2013 I can understand the hate but surely by now he's a long forgotten former MFC player that is now at his third club and is probably near retirement.

 

Speaks more on the individual that they can still hold s grudge on something that happened 10 years ago...

[Sir Why You Little 37,019]

2 minutes ago, nosoupforme said:

In 2012 Tom Scully moved to GWS on a six figure sum and signed a contract for six years worth six million dollars, However his father Phil was also working as a  recruiting officer for the Giants and was on a 100,000 dollars a year for six years. Not long before signing Tom.

How coincidental,   as Tom stated he had no knowledge of  an offer to his father prior to signing  his own deal.

That is not fair play.

Yep. The family were on a nearly $7mill long term deal, and Tom didn’t know anything about it. 
as a member I was disgusted at The AFL. 

[rjay 24,916]

40 minutes ago, nosoupforme said:

In 2012 Tom Scully moved to GWS on a six figure sum and signed a contract for six years worth six million dollars, However his father Phil was also working as a  recruiting officer for the Giants and was on a 100,000 dollars a year for six years. Not long before signing Tom.

How coincidental,   as Tom stated he had no knowledge of  an offer to his father prior to signing  his own deal.

That is not fair play.

Not fair play but in the end both clubs got screwed...Tom & his dad set themselves up nicely through no fault of their own.

[picket fence 17,134]

20 hours ago, Hannibal Inc. said:

Thankfully, he'll end his career as a very ordinary pick one.  Imagine if he became an AA quality gun and you had to watch him run around every week ?

Good riddance.

I'm more than disappointed that he turned out a dud pick 1. We have a history, more than any other club of stuffing up our early draft picks. He is just one of many!

[Lord Travis 10,727]

3 hours ago, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Surprised MFC supporters still hate him.

Yes, in 2012 and 2013 I can understand the hate but surely by now he's a long forgotten former MFC player that is now at his third club and is probably near retirement.

 

Average footballer, seems like a robot of a person, plays a boring style of footy built on running 50kms to receive one handball, has a punchable face, disliked by his teammates across three clubs. He’s not exactly a likeable bloke, regardless of him bailing on us all those years ago.

Don’t blame him for taking the money and leaving either. I’d have done the same, as would most others. Just don’t like him!

Edited January 27, 2021 by Lord Travis

[nosoupforme 3,085]

1 hour ago, rjay said:

Not fair play but in the end both clubs got screwed...Tom & his dad set themselves up nicely through no fault of their own.

You have always been a fence sitter.         How did TOM  and his Dad get  Screwed?    Please explain. 

 I think you meant we got screwed.     The father maneuvered everything for his own gain through his son when he saw the opportunity.  I am sure GWS had a say.

[ManDee 7,134]

9 minutes ago, nosoupforme said:

You have always been a fence sitter.         How did TOM  and his Dad get  Screwed?    Please explain. 

 I think you meant we got screwed.     The father maneuvered everything for his own gain through his son when he saw the opportunity.  I am sure GWS had a say.

I think you should read it again Soup.

[rjay 24,916]

14 minutes ago, nosoupforme said:

You have always been a fence sitter.         How did TOM  and his Dad get  Screwed?    Please explain. 

 I think you meant we got screwed.     The father maneuvered everything for his own gain through his son when he saw the opportunity.  I am sure GWS had a say.

 

4 minutes ago, ManDee said:

I think you should read it again Soup.

That's pretty funny 'soup'...

As 'Man' says...Read It Again.

Not sitting on the fence here but your comprehension is sadly lacking.

[hemingway 7,625]

Scully is a good example of a young champion footballer that makes the grade but struggles to make an impact. Happens to many if not most. It’s a warning that champion schoolboys need careful assessment. Also a warning that many schoolboys are “over trained” by the time they get there and develop chronic injuries early on. From memory Scully had problems almost from the start. Certainly, he had an injury hampered career.  

From a monetary viewpoint he was in the right place at the right time. He and Dad made a killing but only because clubs came knocking with pockets if not sacks of money. Given the nature of the dog eat dog mentality of footy these days, you can’t blame him.  Sure he may have misled many in the process but he was a young kid taking the advice of an elder. And whose to say he was wrong. Financially, footy has delivered a comfortable lifestyle and secure future, even if he never works a day in his life. 

As it was, it turned out to be a blessing for the Demons. Saved the club lots of money and what to do with an overpaid player that falls below expectations. And think of how many of us would have had the Jack Watts if Scully had continued with the Dees. 

[Fork 'em 6,983]

19 minutes ago, hemingway said:

Scully is a good example of a young champion footballer that makes the grade but struggles to make an impact. Happens to many if not most. It’s a warning that champion schoolboys need careful assessment. Also a warning that many schoolboys are “over trained” by the time they get there and develop chronic injuries early on. From memory Scully had problems almost from the start. Certainly, he had an injury hampered career.  

 

Yes .... Pretty sure he turned up already with Osteitis pubis issues.
Or started suffering very soon after.

Edited January 27, 2021 by Fork 'em

[Pickett2Jackson 3,904]

1 hour ago, picket fence said:

I'm more than disappointed that he turned out a dud pick 1. We have a history, more than any other club of stuffing up our early draft picks. He is just one of many!

Relax, its not like we passed on Dustin Martin to pick him.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,816]

Scully had a very good 2016 and 2017 and was nominated in the All Aust 40 squad both years. This coincided with back to back prelim finals for his club.

To call him a below average played is incorrect IMO.