Positive Trade Out (Non Regrettable)

[spirit of norm smith 12,897]

Whilst there’s been the list of Regrettable Trades OUT, in a recent post, I was thinking of what players traded out have actually yielded a positive return.  

I can only recall the trade out of Troy Longmuir some 20 years ago.  Longmuir played for a few years and got about another 40 games across Freo and also Carlton.
We got pick 19 which was an early round 2 pick in 1999.  We picked Brad Green who went in to play for 13 years,  254 games, one B&F and captained the club.  

[DistrACTION Jackson 6,418]

Colin Sylvia

[Bay Riffin 1,413]

I thought the Ingerson trade was a steal back in the day. The player we lost was a draftee in Paul Rouvray who didn't play a game. the following best explains it.

 

Ingerson's trade in exchange for National Draft selection #27 was part of the complicated deal that sent Paul Salmon to Hawthorn and Darren Jarman to the Crows. Adelaide player - and former Melbourne draftee Paul Rouvray - was on his way to Sydney as part of the deal before deciding he wanted to play for the Demons. The Ingerson trade convinced Melbourne to pull out of the running for Rouvray, who went to the Swans and never played a game. Essendon believed they had an in-principle agreement with Adelaide to trade for Ingerson, but he thought he'd get more opportunity at Melbourne.

[Demonstone 19,085]

Trading Jordie Gysberts to North in exchange for Cam Pedersen was very much a win for us.

[Deemania since 56 6,132]

48 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Whilst there’s been the list of Regrettable Trades OUT, in a recent post, I was thinking of what players traded out have actually yielded a positive return.  

I can only recall the trade out of Troy Longmuir some 20 years ago.  Longmuir played for a few years and got about another 40 games across Freo and also Carlton.
We got pick 19 which was an early round 2 pick in 1999.  We picked Brad Green who went in to play for 13 years,  254 games, one B&F and captained the club.  

Without any hesitation, what a beautiful outcome for the Dees; Brad was all class. 

[Deemania since 56 6,132]

2 minutes ago, demonstone said:

Trading Jordie Gysberts to North in exchange for Cam Pedersen was very much a win for us.

This was the one that I liked more than any other - Cam was all heart.

[Bay Riffin 1,413]

1 minute ago, demonstone said:

Trading Jordie Gysberts to North in exchange for Cam Pedersen was very much a win for us.

very much so. Pederson strarted slowly, his first match for us marred by the panic mark whilst ducking his head. then went onto become a handy forward and what I thought was a very handy running ruckman when Maxy went down.

[Grimes Times 1,278]

Ones that didnt happen.

Melb wanted to trade Darren Kowell to Freo for a compensation pick, which at the time it was said they wanted to use on a young kid from Healsville named David Wirrapanda. Kowell refused to move and the trade never happened.

Melb had agreed on a trade with Haw of Ryan Fergerson for Brad Seweell in 2005. Fergerson refused the moved and wanted to stay at Melb. Sewell had only played 2 season at the time.

 

 

Edited May 18, 2020 by Grimes Times

[spirit of norm smith 12,897]

58 minutes ago, demonstone said:

Trading Jordie Gysberts to North in exchange for Cam Pedersen was very much a win for us.

Yes. A good one. One bloke (Pedersen) had heart and spirit for a contest. The other bloke didn’t.  

[spirit of norm smith 12,897]

52 minutes ago, Grimes Times said:

Ones that didnt happen.

Melb wanted to trade Darren Kowell to Freo for a compensation pick, which at the time it was said they wanted to use on a young kid from Healsville named David Wirrapanda. Kowell refused to move and the trade never happened.

Melb had agreed on a trade with Haw of Ryan Fergerson for Brad Seweell in 2005. Fergerson refused the moved and wanted to stay at Melb. Sewell had only played 2 season at the time.

 

 

Yes both non trades were killers.  The Ferguson one made sense for both clubs at the time but he wanted to stay. Sewell would have been a gun pickup for us. 

[Moonshadow 16,163]

Jesse Hogan

[spirit of norm smith 12,897]

52 minutes ago, Moonshadow said:

Jesse Hogan

Too soon to call this one. 
It’s Hogan out and May & Kolodjashnij in. 

I really hope that both Hogan and May can workout their injury and other issues and have a really good next few years.  Jesse is a good kid that needs support and a good run. 

[MyFavouriteMartian 572]

Watts.!

Moloney.

 

[Sir Why You Little 34,434]

Jack Watts

[Satyriconhome 9,982]

So the Hogan and Watts trades were good, not according to other threads, the team has gone nowhere since

Please explain

[spirit of norm smith 12,897]

49 minutes ago, Satyriconhome said:

So the Hogan and Watts trades were good, not according to other threads, the team has gone nowhere since

Please explain

Agree. Yes it’s too soon imo.  

[whatwhat say what 18,907]

4 hours ago, demonstone said:

Trading Jordie Gysberts to North in exchange for Cam Pedersen was very much a win for us.

it's funny when you look at how it played out for the three major players in two trades over the course of three years

brock mclean - 63 games with the blues

gysberts - 19 games with the dees

gysberts - 0 games with the kangas

pedersen - 64 games with the dees

[dl4e 5,583]

Sam Blease.

[Deeko2 698]

15 minutes ago, dl4e said:

Sam Blease.

 

5 hours ago, demonstone said:

Trading Jordie Gysberts to North in exchange for Cam Pedersen was very much a win for us.

Two names here that I thought were going to be stars for us for a long time.  Both of these players I was against trading at the time and when so I deep down hoped they'd go on to have decent careers somewhere else.... I don't recall either of them ever firing a shot.

Living in the bush I don't get to go to many games but I was at the G early on in Sam's career where he put on a clinic on the wing.  He would have had close to 30 touches and I'm pretty sure polled some Brownlow votes.  I was there the next year when he kicked a few against the Saints.... must have been his good luck charm.

Jordy also started positively I believe winning a lot of the pill early on in his career.  It seems both of these players got worse the longer they played for us.

I hated Cam after his first year, thought he was the biggest flop of all time... especially after he ducked his head early.  By the end of his time however I had a massive man crush on him.  The way he kept using his body as a battering ram and played with passion made him one of my favourites and was happy to see a bloke finally get all he could out of his body - although I think it took a few rockets for him to click.

I thought out best trade out was Watts.  I was personally sick of defending him and had heard stories that he was a little bit naughty away from the club.  Obviously a talented boy but I think everyone agrees he lacks the dedication to be great.  Very happy with your Fritter - when he plays forward!!

[TeamPlayedFine39 8,154]

3 minutes ago, Deeko2 said:

 

Two names here that I thought were going to be stars for us for a long time.  Both of these players I was against trading at the time and when so I deep down hoped they'd go on to have decent careers somewhere else.... I don't recall either of them ever firing a shot.

Living in the bush I don't get to go to many games but I was at the G early on in Sam's career where he put on a clinic on the wing.  He would have had close to 30 touches and I'm pretty sure polled some Brownlow votes.  I was there the next year when he kicked a few against the Saints.... must have been his good luck charm.

Jordy also started positively I believe winning a lot of the pill early on in his career.  It seems both of these players got worse the longer they played for us.

I hated Cam after his first year, thought he was the biggest flop of all time... especially after he ducked his head early.  By the end of his time however I had a massive man crush on him.  The way he kept using his body as a battering ram and played with passion made him one of my favourites and was happy to see a bloke finally get all he could out of his body - although I think it took a few rockets for him to click.

I thought out best trade out was Watts.  I was personally sick of defending him and had heard stories that he was a little bit naughty away from the club.  Obviously a talented boy but I think everyone agrees he lacks the dedication to be great.  Very happy with your Fritter - when he plays forward!!

Agree with most of this.

At the start of 2010 I went to the club intra-match at Casey and saw Gysberts towelling up our established mids and even overshadowing Scully and Trengove.  Was in and under all day, extracting and playing well above his size and experience.  I thought we had a star on our hands when I left that day and 26 on debut against Geelong in Geelong and 27 the following week against Carlton (who played finals that year) cemented this belief.  2 rising star nominations over 2 years and a couple of Brownlow votes in a 30 possession performance against Essendon, he had the makings of an inspired draft choice.

 

Then... fell of the face of the earth after 2011.  Whether it was Bailey leaving, Neeld arriving, or just a lack of passion or will to play at the top level?  I don't know.  But the kid definitely had the talent to play.

 

[Ethan Tremblay 28,358]

We traded Phil Gilbert to Fremantle in 1994 for a 17 year old Jeff Farmer. Who is Phil Gilbert you ask? No idea. 

[spirit of norm smith 12,897]

Yes of course. Freo was very generous to us in the early days. They got Longmuir and Gilbert and we got Farmer and Green.  Winner 
 

Whilst not a player trade out, the pick 2 to Freo for Jeff White was handy.

(Freo ontraded pick 2 to the tigers for Chris Bond. What a Brain explosion?) 

[YesitwasaWin4theAges 5,795]

Freo have a habit for ridiculous trades, kings of the brain fade as they are known in 94 traded the rights for Andrew Mcleod for Chris Groom, who had played 12 games in 2 years.

Who in there right mind would do such a trade, Mcleod who was highly regarded had just blitzed in the 94 season and won a SANFL flag with Port.

 

 

[MyFavouriteMartian 572]

2 hours ago, Deeko2 said:

I hated Cam after his first year, thought he was the biggest flop of all time... especially after he ducked his head early.  By the end of his time however I had a massive man crush on him.  The way he kept using his body as a battering ram and played with passion made him one of my favourites and was happy to see a bloke finally get all he could out of his body - although I think it took a few rockets for him to click.

Rockets to click.?

Or maybe Marriage,  and children,  and becoming a Dee,  entrenched in the team fabric.  being accepted.?  I am guessing, but in Cam's case,  I reckon it was likely something that added to his confidence, and completed him...  rather than some,  who need being lowered a peg or two,  before they wake up.? 

Or a combo of the above.    He never appeared to be a big head to my eyes.

[MyFavouriteMartian 572]

2 hours ago, TeamPlayedFine39 said:

Then... fell of the face of the earth after 2011.  Whether it was Bailey leaving, Neeld arriving, or just a lack of passion or will to play at the top level?  I don't know.  But the kid definitely had the talent to play.

Based on his early successes, how do we know it wasn't a 3rd possibility.?

How do we know it wasn't other players leading him astray off-field.?

 

I heard watta was a strong influence on on some of our other players... I think I heard,?  was it Petracca,  was a buddy.? I'm not certain now.?  But I do recall hearing he was an influence on some, after dark.