https://sen.lu/2RwtQxO

 

McCartin reckons he has overcome his concussion issues and is looking for another chance. Wants to resume with St Kilda, but with the season up in the air, would you punt on him if an opportunity opens up in some form of mid-season draft.

 

We are lacking a KPF. There is no way TMac is getting back to his best. Steven May would be a better forward candidate atm. 

 

Anyhoo, would ya? 

I wouldn't recruit him and I also wouldn't write TMac off at this early stage.

 

I’d entertain the idea. Back in the 2014 draft I was hoping the Saints would choose Petracca or Brayshaw and therefore allowing us to take McCartin. Had a gut feel he’d be a champion forward. Has been crueled by injury.

We also need to bolster our forward line and Paddy could be an option. A far better marking option than Weid.

We don’t have a good forward line and we can’t rely on Melksham and Fritsch to kick 8 between them every week. They were both disappointing in round 1 as they only contributed 1 between them against WC. However, they will be much better against lesser teams and lesser defenders.

As for T Mac, we all bagged him after round 1 but he still managed 2 goals on the back of a poor performance against pretty much the best side in the league. That suggests to me that he would’ve been on track for a solid 50 goal year if the season went 22 games. To T Mac’s credit he’s a very accurate shot for goal and makes the most of his chances unlike many other forwards around the league.

Edited April 13, 20206 yr by Bring-Back-Powell

With KK and Bennell on the list...

No, we can't afford to carry another.

Surely it's not worth the risk for Paddy. I'm no expert but the effects of another concussion for the poor guy would be disastrous.

2 minutes ago, rjay said:

With KK and Bennell on the list...

No, we can't afford to carry another.

not to mention Smith and AVB.

I wish them all including McCartin the best

Well, surprise surprise.

A constantly injured footy player without a job declares himself over his injury problems and ready to go. 

Sounds legit.

 

Hard pass.

Edited April 13, 20206 yr by ding

Weid, Brown and Tmac. Not exactly set the world on fire (for us or Bombers), I wouldn’t have an issue with it. Is it too many injury concerns on the list, potentially but he is further along in development than say a Bradtke.

Edited April 13, 20206 yr by Cards13

Did the newbie who started this thread not see the other one already in existence?  ?

41 minutes ago, demonstone said:

Did the newbie who started this thread not see the other one already in existence?  ?

Whoopsie. Merged.

i'd have to say its a pass from me.

I think he can be a good player, but like others have said we have too many injury plagued players on the list as it is. and besides I reckon we could have T.Lockett playing down forward and we'd struggle get 40 goals out of him a year with our dodgy forward structures and poor kicking going inside F50.

I think a high quality KPF is our last gap atm, but I don’t think it’s Paddy.

Hopefully for him he gets healthy, back to playing consistently, and to a high level.

It depends on how the Weid travels if he has a good year then we don't need Paddy but if he continues to struggle I would grab Paddy.

McCartin's view of himself is different from that of his family.

Look i wish him all the best, but im going to have to pass. I think his confidence and fitness are major issues coming back into the fold.

He's simply missed to much football to be considered for the MFC.

I wouldn’t have picked him up in the Rookie Draft the year he was recruited.

whorethorn can have him

we're already carrying too many wounded

2 hours ago, Demon Dude said:

I reckon we could have T.Lockett playing down forward and we'd struggle get 40 goals out of him a year

To be fair, Plugger is many, many years past his prime.

Definately amd emphatically NOT

We already have one with KK, Do we want to take a very risky and already life comprimised player into the fold?? Nup!

Edited April 13, 20206 yr by picket fence

I can’t remember him doing anything to suggest he could play the game anyway without the other issues. 
Also I thought St Kilda said that they’d have a spot for him if he got things worked out? Or am I thinking of someone else?

Edited April 13, 20206 yr by Uncle Fester

10 minutes ago, Uncle Fester said:

I can’t remember him doing anything to suggest he could play the game anyway without the other issues. 
Also I thought St Kilda said that they’d have a spot for him if he got things worked out? Or am I thinking of someone else?

Yes they did say that, but I doubt very much that he will play again.

Firstly, I wish the rules had been changed so players with long-term concussion weren't delisted but put on some sort of temporary long-term injury list. That is, they still stay conected with their club but they don't count as a number for list purposes.  

That being said, when AFL returns in 2021 it's going to look very different. With expectations of reduced list sizes, I can't see why we would wish to add a perenially injured player to our list. 

Edited April 13, 20206 yr by La Dee-vina Comedia

6 hours ago, demonstone said:

I wouldn't recruit him and I also wouldn't write TMac off at this early stage.

Agree. Also not writing Weid off.

Would prefer what we have, than take a punt on a fragile Paddy.

Highly doubt he is over his concussion issues, though I'm not a doctor.

5 hours ago, rjay said:

With KK and Bennell on the list...

No, we can't afford to carry another.

Especially with list sizes set to reduce over the next couple of years