9 hours ago, DeeZee said:

Jesse is at the b and f

...and he will be, next year, too.

6 hours ago, johndemonic said:

I can see freo fans using this to argue unders on Jesse, like the dolts last year who thought it justified us paying unders for (or not recruiting) Lever

Good luck to them on that! We set the price, they come to the party or we tell them to bugger off. 

49 minutes ago, Pates said:

Good luck to them on that! We set the price, they come to the party or we tell them to bugger off. 

Do we tell Gaff to bugger off as Jesse's cap space is unavailable for 1 more year too?

8 hours ago, Dr.D said:

hogan not in the top 10 in the best and fairest. and rightly so. 

 

8 hours ago, layzie said:

Makes for a nice smooth exit. 

 

7 hours ago, bing181 said:

He was 1 vote behind Lewis in 11th, after missing the last few games.

Churlish.

He finished 6th in votes per game out of players with more than 10 games. 

In the Sun to day they have done a comparison with the leading key forwards and Jesse leads all but one stat.

We are talking about a 23 year old future champion of the game and to ask for less than the absolute maximum in return is a joke.

I trust the FD to get a good deal, but to those on here or in the media to suggest he is not absolute top trade price is another joke.

I have warmed to May and KK would be handy for us, so lets see how we go next week.

Mahoney and Co have shown themselves capable of getting deals done and our list is getting there. 

But back to the main point. Those talking Jesse down because of a flaw in his game, are not giving his positives due recognition.

Jesse is a super talent and could rise to champion status if he puts in the effort and he has luck with injuries from now on so we need to extract maximum compo from the club he goes to, most likely the Dockers.

3 minutes ago, Redleg said:

In the Sun to day they have done a comparison with the leading key forwards and Jesse leads all but one stat.

We are talking about a 23 year old future champion of the game and to ask for less than the absolute maximum in return is a joke.

I trust the FD to get a good deal, but to those on here or in the media to suggest he is not absolute top trade price is another joke.

I have warmed to May and KK would be handy for us, so lets see how we go next week.

Mahoney and Co have shown themselves capable of getting deals done and our list is getting there. 

But back to the main point. Those talking Jesse down because of a flaw in his game, are not giving his positives due recognition.

Jesse is a super talent and could rise to champion status if he puts in the effort and he has luck with injuries from now on so we need to extract maximum compo from the club he goes to, most likely the Dockers.

we'll get 2 first rounders for him. im confident of that.

37 minutes ago, Redleg said:

In the Sun to day they have done a comparison with the leading key forwards and Jesse leads all but one stat.

We are talking about a 23 year old future champion of the game and to ask for less than the absolute maximum in return is a joke.

I trust the FD to get a good deal, but to those on here or in the media to suggest he is not absolute top trade price is another joke.

I have warmed to May and KK would be handy for us, so lets see how we go next week.

Mahoney and Co have shown themselves capable of getting deals done and our list is getting there. 

But back to the main point. Those talking Jesse down because of a flaw in his game, are not giving his positives due recognition.

Jesse is a super talent and could rise to champion status if he puts in the effort and he has luck with injuries from now on so we need to extract maximum compo from the club he goes to, most likely the Dockers.

Totally agree and he’s still contracted and the dockers want him desperately. 

If they are willing to offer him 1.2 mil a year they will have a hard time explaining why they shouldn’t cough up #5 & #6 for him and both parties walk away with what they want 

Melbourne has denied a move by Hogan to Fremantle.

Source Channel 7 just now 

38 minutes ago, Dr.D said:

we'll get 2 first rounders for him. im confident of that.

Like your avatar, you speak in riddles and seemingly struggle with communicating a narrative. (And like your avatar sake are consistently negative).

On one hand you talk Hogan down and basically say he is overrated. On the other you say we'll get to first rounders. Do you think clubs are in the habit of paying top price for average players?

9 minutes ago, binman said:

Like your avatar, you speak in riddles and seemingly struggle with communicating a narrative. (And like your avatar sake are consistently negative).

On one hand you talk Hogan down and basically say he is overrated. On the other you say we'll get to first rounders. Do you think clubs are in the habit of paying top price for average players?

lol! im talking about what i think will happen. I'd take a straight swap for may and hogan but i don't think the club will. i'd actually be happy going to the draft with the picks we get too. 

I can understand he may want to return to WA to be near his Mum, but he’s been here for several years now and surely most of his friends are Melbourne-based. Why would he want to go to a team that’s on the bottom rungs of the ladder (apart from $)? Most players who have retired and look back on their careers, when interviewed say that they would rather have been in a successful team than have earned more dollars. Also, maybe Melbourne can offer a few more $ as well?

Edited October 1, 20186 yr by Stormy Dee

21 minutes ago, DeeZee said:

Melbourne has denied a move by Hogan to Fremantle.

Source Channel 7 just now 

If he stays it may explain why we asked the AFL for permission to trade next years 1st round pick, which goes some of the way towards potentially getting May and KK.

I learnt very little from the BnF last night. No loose lips from any player.

what I did learn is that Gawny reads demonland and has @Demonland4276 in his gun hahha 

hi Max xx

29 minutes ago, DeeZee said:

Melbourne has denied a move by Hogan to Fremantle.

Source Channel 7 just now 

Good

No deal

Excellent

30 minutes ago, DeeZee said:

Melbourne has denied a move by Hogan to Fremantle.

Source Channel 7 just now 

GREAT NEWS - thanks for sharing.

Our 2019 premiership winning team will look fantastic with Hogan in it.

Melbourne may be making freo sweat to ensure we get pick 5 & 6

9 hours ago, Dr.D said:

hogan not in the top 10 in the best and fairest. and rightly so. 

In fairness he was 4th after rd 16 and got injured not long after that.

24 minutes ago, Leoncelli_36 said:

I learnt very little from the BnF last night. No loose lips from any player.

what I did learn is that Gawny reads demonland and has @Demonland4276 in his gun hahha 

hi Max xx

I am not worried about Max.

 

It’s his mother I fear!

9 hours ago, Dr.D said:

hogan not in the top 10 in the best and fairest. and rightly so. 

And yet you've said you'd be happy to do a straight swap with May who also didn't finish in the top 10, and before you say it's because he only played 17 games, Martin and Thompson both finished top 10 for them and both played the same or less games than May. Whereas all the Melbourne top 10 played more games than Jesse. 

Hi Max and Max's mum. Congratulations

I'll have a grande cappuccino , extra shot, no sugar . Cheers

7 minutes ago, Demonland4276 said:

I am not worried about Max.

 

It’s his mother I fear!

Did you change your name to Demonland4276 literally after Max said what he said at the BnF?

1 minute ago, A F said:

Did you change your name to Demonland4276 literally after Max said what he said at the BnF?

Of course. Who is it though?

13 minutes ago, Demonland4276 said:

I am not worried about Max.

 

It’s his mother I fear!

Beat us all to the punch!

27 minutes ago, Lord Neville X Flash said:

Melbourne may be making freo sweat to ensure we get pick 5 & 6

Isnt that basically what was said from the start?  We are happy to keep him unless something is put in front of us that we absolutely couldnt refuse?

Narrative has morphed since into this going down like a regular trade, fears of getting low balled.. etc

Mother of all offers thanks Freo, or GTFO

1 hour ago, DeeZee said:

Melbourne has denied a move by Hogan to Fremantle.

Source Channel 7 just now 

Really? Seems odd they would do it today and not at BnF or earlier when it was brought up? This is what I mean by not trusting what anyone says!