The Other Preliminary Final

[Diamond_Jim 12,017]

Hoping for a Collingwood win as a Melbourne v Collingwood Grand Final would be so right on so many grounds.

Of course Richmond supporters would say we avoided them but there's always next year.

[Jibroni 4,239]

I expect Richmond to be too good and Collingwood to fade in the 2nd half.

Tigers by 33.

[Smokey 4,146]

My heart says Collingwood in a nail biter, my head says Richmond by plenty.  

[Sir Why You Little 34,933]

Both Richmond and Collingwood blood and bone left on the MCG turf...

[Diamond_Jim 12,017]

Interesting that many people are almost writing Collingwood off.

They were only beaten in the last quarter in the West and beat the seemingly inform GWS.

Or is it that people think Richmond are so good.

Sidebottom is elite and they have a dominant ruck in Grundy. Pendlebury delivers week in week out. Forward line is a little brittle and they seem to have patched together a decent backline. And of course there is that star player that Buckley discovered by switching him down back.. can't quite remember his name.

[Dr.D 1,771]

Rich have been the best team for the last 2 seasons..and what changes this week? nothing. Tigers by 30+

[daisycutter 28,688]

don't give a fig. filth or ferals, who cares, will thrash either.

go dees. raise hell in the west

[DSP 1,488]

Tigers by 3 goals.

Either way, I hope its the most physical game ever played.

[CBDees 3,162]

6 minutes ago, DSP said:

Tigers by 3 goals.

Either way, I hope its the most physical game ever played.

Let’s hope that they go hard at it, plenty of (two-week) injuries and lots of reports!

[loges 6,245]

Just thought the Pies, GWS game was really scrappy, so Tiges for me.

Edited September 20, 2018 by loges
My mistake

[DubDee 21,271]

I'd expect Maynard and Adams etc to really rough up the tigers.  Probably the only chance collingwood have.  on talent and structure, the tigers should win easily.

[Jaded No More 59,133]

Could not care less who wins, as I think at our best we can beat both.

Would I prefer to beat Collingwood on GF day, for sure.

Do I hope both teams get loads of medium term injuries? yes. 

 

[Clintosaurus 6,673]

Think it will be close and 80 points will be enough to win it. Hope they beat the shyte out of each other.

[What 18,810]

I begrudgingly admire how well the Pies have gone this season despite being slaughtered by injury.

I think they run out of gas tonight though.  Tigers by 76.

 

[sue 8,477]

56 minutes ago, Jaded said:

Could not care less who wins, as I think at our best we can beat both.

....

True, but if we lose to WCE do you really want C'wood in a GF?

[Jaded No More 59,133]

4 minutes ago, sue said:

True, but if we lose to WCE do you really want C'wood in a GF?

Good point.

To be fair I am not even contemplating the possibility of a WCE win.

[beelzebub 22,330]

I hope both teams leave absolutely nothing out there ( apart from limbs etc ). Hope both a totally spent forces

[Jones 62]

Collingwood will play for 3 quarters and Richmond will win

[At the break of Gawn 3,672]

I like our chances against Collingwood so I’m hoping for a Pies win.

[Dee Zephyr 18,018]

Pies have scored 76,70,69 in their last 3 games. They will need to score a lot more than that if they are to beat Richmond in my opinion. If Collingwood can win the territorial battle they could go close to beating them. Richmond do it better than most though. Tigers 94-67.

[dl4e 5,648]

I just absolutely hate the filth. I hope the tigers smash them to oblivion. I don't like Richmond either.

[beelzebub 22,330]

Not fussed who wins but a Dees filth granny would light a fuse under this town it hasn't seen the likes of for half a century !!

Just hoping for a maniacal game of attrition

[Diamond_Jim 12,017]

1 minute ago, beelzebub said:

Not fussed who wins but a Dees filth granny would light a fuse under this town it hasn't seen the likes of for half a century !!

Just hoping for a maniacal game of attrition

Should not be underestimated what it would do for our brand (hate that word) to re-ignite the mystical nostalgia of '58 and '64.

Could be the fillip to deliver another ten thousand members next year.

Some big hurdles still to be overcome but no use dwelling on the negatives at this time of year.

[Deeoldfart 7,820]

I think Richmond will win, and purely from a selfish perspective, that's the way I'd prefer it to go.  My rationale:

• I 'dees-pies' Collingwood so much that the thought of them playing off in a Grand Final makes me want to puke;  and
• if we happened to play Collingwood in the Grand Final, Grundy has the capacity to reduce the influence of our major trump card in big Max, making a win more difficult for us.

It hurts me to say it, but I want a Richmond win tomorrow night.  Maybe by a big margin, so they drink a tub full of their own bathwater before facing a rampant Dees outfit. 

[Whispering_Jack 28,094]

I would be very surprised if Collingwood were to win against Richmond on their showing against GWS. The intensity of their game last week was a few notches below that of the night before and they will need to lift to match it with Richmond.