Player position changes

[DeeZee 6,912]

Ive rejigged the side into positions I think would give us a new lease of life and more  Benefit going forward. Hunt and Hibberd on the wings for a more attacking mindset.

Lever at CHB and Watts in Vince's old position. J. Smith who I rate very highly could even take OMacs spot if he doesn't come up.

Jetta OMac Watts

Brayshaw Lever Salem

Hibberd Oliver  Hunt

Petracca TMac  Melksham 

Garlett. Hogan Pederson

 

Gawn Viney Jones

 

Joel Smith, Lewis, Harmes ,ANB

[JTR 2,695]

On 8/29/2017 at 7:28 PM, Jaded said:

I think the club wants Lever to allow Hunt and Salem more time on the wings. 

Plus it might save us from Vince taking kick outs, my least favourite 30 seconds in every game. 

I would have that second least favourite, behind a Tmac/Omac switch of play in our defensive 50.

I usually watch through my fingers

[Earl Hood 5,880]

I would like to see Garlett have a rotation through the middle in each quarter and Clarrie go forward for a period each quarter. Garlett can be quite creative at centre bounces and I believe Clarrie could be a difficult matchup in a forward pocket every now and then. 

[Deespicable 2,574]

You only have to ask Jamie Shanahan to understand the importance of playing well in the final game of the season, because otherwise the coach has that image in his memory for up to six months.

As a result I'll be very surprised if we see T-Mac anywhere near the defence early next season - he'll line up at CHF in Rd 1 and with his huge tank will be asked to provide forward pressure and marking clout. And as we now know, he is an accurate set shot kick.

I've said this before, but I think Jonesy could play off a back flank - there are enough small forwards now that his size shouldn't hold him back and he's smart and courageous and bloody hard to beat one-on-one. He's also one of our top 3 most attacking kicks - I reckon he'd be a bit like McVeigh back there for us

Sending Jonesy back would mean that Bernie is no longer required back there. That doesn't necessarily spell the end as I reckon Bernie could play as a forward with his pressure tackling, courage, marking and kicking making him a useful option - a bit like a Glenn Lovett or how Peter Rohde used to be late in their careers.

And Jonesy to defence and Bernie up forward could give Trac a bit more time in the middle with Ollie, Jack Viney, and Dom.

Please don't forget Joel Smith and Vanders when factoring your 2018 line-ups - assuming both are fit, I'd have them in my best 22.

[defuture15 857]

Some thoughts.

Jetta is too talented to just play back. I know he has been the real general 

Back there but I think his desire could be used through the middle.

Id like to see jessie and tom as the forwards and weed taking the marks from the kick ins. He can mark but the forward line is too crowded.

Need outside players Salem, Hibberd, Hunt.

Bugg and Melksham on hff

Trac, brayshaw, oliver mids

Watts wing/outside mid

Frost ruck/wing/back attack

Oscar back defend

 

[Young Blood 2,036]

Apart from Tmac moving forward if we were to pick up Lever the only other player I can see moving up the ground is Hunt. I think the football department would be looking to see how they can get more out of his run and carry to get deeper forward entries in transition.

Edited September 4, 2017 by mongrel

[Mazer Rackham 14,970]

What is the point of moving players around if, when the crunch time comes, we dissolve and melt?

 

 

There is something more urgent to be addressed than positional changes.

[deelete my account 1,194]

2 hours ago, Deespicable said:

Please don't forget Joel Smith and Vanders when factoring your 2018 line-ups - assuming both are fit, I'd have them in my best 22.

I know Joel Smith was starting 22 in round 1 last year, but through no fault of his own, didn't get the time to establish his position in the best 22 yet, nor have we had enough time to assess whether he's capable of being best 22 through consistent application. And Vanders has been too far out to know whether he can recapture his form from 2 years ago.

So it's perfectly understandable to not have them in the 22, pending next years 2 to 4 week experimental stints that Goodwin seems to use for each depth player looking to break in.

Edited September 4, 2017 by Wrecked Owl Dees Function

[defuture15 857]

Vanders would be a good big bodied mid if he makes it

[monoccular 16,684]

1 hour ago, defuture15 said:

Some thoughts.

Jetta is too talented to just play back. I know he has been the real general 

Back there but I think his desire could be used through the middle.

Id like to see jessie and tom as the forwards and weed taking the marks from the kick ins. He can mark but the forward line is too crowded.

Need outside players Salem, Hibberd, Hunt.

Bugg and Melksham on hff

Trac, brayshaw, oliver mids

Watts wing/outside mid

Frost ruck/wing/back attack

Oscar back defend

 

Just a question - when we are not kicking in from behinds (and lets be optimistic as we always are before the shyt hits the fan late in the season), like maybe the opposition don't score a lot of behinds (hopefully not a lot at all and the deep defenders have little to do), where do you place weed the rest of the time?

[defuture15 857]

He does the roaming fwd role not jessie.

We were killed by our lack of contested marking players out of defence this year

[chook fowler 18,595]

According to Casey, Spencer might be moved to the wing. 

[ProperDee 1,698]

5 minutes ago, chook fowler said:

According to Casey, Spencer might be moved to the wing. 

Jake or Frank?

Edited September 4, 2017 by ProperDee

[chook fowler 18,595]

23 minutes ago, ProperDee said:

Jake or Frank?

Frank would be better

[jnrmac 19,508]

On 8/29/2017 at 7:16 PM, tiers said:

Let's consider how the FD might resurrect the wingman position and game. Not sort of midfielders but genuine wingmen. Leave the midfielders' work to Oliver, Viney, Jones, Petracca, ANB, AVB, Brayshaw Salem etc.

Say Sam Frost, Jack Watts and Jayden Hunt as rotating connector players dedicated to providing an outlet option for the back line and the skill/speed to rapidly transfer the ball to the forward line.

Two on the ground at any time with two way running between the 50s in the space between the square and the boundary. Not down the line but wider than the corridor with a licence to run, run and run and kick long to a well prepared and spread forward line who are aware of what is coming and how.

At the other end, provide a crowd to fill gaps and frustrate opposition forwards. When we win the ball, provide a moving target and become 60-80m power players who, with good coaching and a developed game plan,  could revolutionise the game. Nothing to lose. Can't be worse than the current, unsuccessful game plan.

Finally, let's change the tone of this topic and this site. Please restrict any comments to the merits, or otherwise of the proposal, not on the players.

Stretch is the ideal wingman if he can generate some overall improvement in his contested work....

[Older demon 2,326]

Frost signs on for 2 years to me means TMac plays forward, especially if we land Lever. Trac and Clarry the midfield is yours along with Viney. 

I did read somewhere that at this draft the club is looking for more mids suggesting Lewis, Vince and Jones will be on the flanks.

Hoges to be CHF roaming far and wide

[monoccular 16,684]

2 hours ago, defuture15 said:

He does the roaming fwd role not jessie.

We were killed by our lack of contested marking players out of defence this year

I must say I would have Jesse about 75% high forward including marking target for kick ins, shared with Max (if he decides to put footy ahead of media in 2018) with Tom McD doing the other 25%, both with sojourns into the mid...........unless of course that Weideman absolutely demands selection with consistent good VFL performances. 

1 hour ago, chook fowler said:

According to Casey, Spencer might be moved to the wing. 

 

1 hour ago, ProperDee said:

Jake or Frank?

 

1 hour ago, chook fowler said:

Frank would be better

Even Stuart would be better, had he not unfortunately have passed away in 2011 aged around 80. 

[Umpire Please 120]

10 hours ago, monoccular said:

I must say I would have Jesse about 75% high forward including marking target for kick ins, shared with Max (if he decides to put footy ahead of media in 2018) with Tom McD doing the other 25%, both with sojourns into the mid...........unless of course that Weideman absolutely demands selection with consistent good VFL performances. 

 

 

Even Stuart would be better, had he not unfortunately have passed away in 2011 aged around 80. 

When is Hogans contract due? As this will be another distraction he will have to deal with. The media starting the "is he staying or going back west " debate and pressure. 

[Bring-Back-Powell 13,651]

5 hours ago, Umpire Please said:

When is Hogans contract due? As this will be another distraction he will have to deal with. The media starting the "is he staying or going back west " debate and pressure. 

He's out of contract at the end of 2019 so the media will already start writing articles about this sometime next year.

Edited September 5, 2017 by Bring-Back-Powell