All Australian: Which Dees Deserve a Nod?

[Demonland 71,622]

Which Dees do you think deserve a look in for an All Australian nod for the 40 man squad?

The AFL website has picked out 4 Dees.

Jeff Garlett: The classy forward has put together the most consistent season of his 165-game career, booting a team-leading 38 goals, and equal with fellow All Australian contender Essendon's Orazio Fantasia. Garlett's forward-half pressure has also been a staple of his game and a marked improvement on recent seasons.

Michael Hibberd: Missed the first four games due to an Achilles injury, but the former Bomber has been one of the competition's best defenders this season. Hibberd has been one of the recruits of the year, with the attacking defender averaging a career-high 28 disposals and ranking No.1 in the AFL for average metres gained per match (566.9m).

Neville Jetta: The underrated defender does not get the credit he deserves but the fact of the matter is Jetta is one of the competition's best one-on-one defenders. Regularly matches up on the opposition's most dangerous small forward and rarely gets beaten.

Clayton Oliver: Deserves to be in the final team based on his consistent output in a breakout second year at AFL level. Oliver has averaged 30 disposals, including 10 games above 30 touches or more, and 6.8 clearances per game. Gets criticised by some for over handballing, but his hands in heavy congestion are elite and almost unrivalled. - Ben Guthrie 

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-08-16/all-australian-40man-squad-whos-in-the-mix-from-your-club

[Wiseblood 24,637]

Realistically, probably only Hibberd gets the nod on a back flank.  He's been unbelievable this year.

If I put my red and blue glasses on then I would try and sneak Jetta and Oliver in there as well, but I don't think it will happen.  Jetta is one of the best in the game at the moment but there are others who get more of the ball, and therefore more exposure, he will get the nod ahead of him.  Doesn't make it right, though.

[Demonland 71,622]

Just now, Wiseblood said:

Realistically, probably only Hibberd gets the nod on a back flank.  He's been unbelievable this year.

If I put my red and blue glasses on then I would try and sneak Jetta and Oliver in there as well, but I don't think it will happen.  Jetta is one of the best in the game at the moment but there are others who get more of the ball, and therefore more exposure, he will get the nod ahead of him.  Doesn't make it right, though.

I'm talking about the 40 man squad. I think Hibberd is a definite inclusion in the actual team. Clarry man get a bench spot. Jetta of course is always overlooked and perhaps my one eyed red and blue glasses prevent me from being objective.

[Wiseblood 24,637]

Just now, Demonland said:

I'm talking about the 40 man squad. I think Hibberd is a definite inclusion in the actual team. Clarry man get a bench spot. Jetta of course is always overlooked and perhaps my one eyed red and blue glasses prevent me from being objective.

Ah, of course.  Sorry, missed that at the start.

The four above should certainly be in the squad.  Not sure if we can sneak another one in there this year.

[Demonland 71,622]

Just now, Wiseblood said:

Ah, of course.  Sorry, missed that at the start.

The four above should certainly be in the squad.  Not sure if we can sneak another one in there this year.

I think Garlett has been fantastic for most of the year but his form in the past few weeks might cost him a spot in the 40 man squad.

[bandicoot 1,395]

Team of 40:

Hibberd, Jetta, Oliver. 

Cant see garlett, jones, viney making it as year has been inconsistent. 

Jetta should be a lock and hibberd very close to top 22.

[binman 42,683]

All four will make the squad.

I will be shocked if Jetta does not make  final team. The premier small defender in the league and won't be over looked this year.

Hibberd will make the squad but I'm not he will make the final team. It seems it takes more than season at the elite level to make the final cut and for this reason i dont think Oliver will make the 22 either.  

Agree DL that garlett's last few weeks will cost him a spot in the 22

[rjay 24,887]

I think Oliver should make the 22 but won't...

He is our Selwood/Dangerfield, we would struggle without him in the team.

[Tony Tea 2,806]

Jeff Garlett: Too much Eddie love.

Michael Hibberd: Must be a good chance.

Neville Jetta: Too much Laird love.

Clayton Oliver: Oliver may be robbed in the same way Robbo was robbed - the selectors will pick a Brad Johnson type who has been a long time favourite, but who has not been previously picked. 

Do the AA selectors stray outside their brief when they pick players for a career's worth of work instead of for that one year's worth of work?

[SFebes 4,884]

Jetta, Hibberd, Oliver for 40 man squad. Jetta, Hibberd for 30 man squad and Hibberd for AA team.

[ProperDee 1,698]

Agree. Only those 4 could be considered.  Clarry should be a lock for the 22 given he is  6th or 7th in the AFL Coaches votes and the Brownlow predictor. Hibbo a must for a HBF.

[layzie 33,752]

I do think now that Clarry has done enough to be in the 22. I'd love to see Jetta at least make the 30 but I just can't see it happening because its not fancy enough.

[david_neitz_is_my_dad 4,083]

Oliver will make the next 8 years

[The Chazz 4,077]

All 4 should make the squad, but;

Hibberd won't make the team because of the media's love for Howe, as well as Laird's proven history in making the team.  Not to mention that the token Geelong player on each line means Tuohy will be more likely to get a spot.

Garlett won't make the team because of the fact that Eddy is a better small forward.  Just...

Oliver may make the interchange.

Jetta is a lock for a back pocket, or potential spot on the bench. 

[FarNorthernD 5,861]

Regarding Oliver, how many second year players have made the AA team? I'm guessing it would be a small and illustrious list

[FarNorthernD 5,861]

So to answer my own question Oliver would join 3 other players (that i can find) to make the AA team in their 2nd year; Ricciuto, Wingard and Jeremy Cameron. Other notables are

3rd year -  Judd, Selwood Bontempelli, 

4th - L Matthews, N Buckley, Dangerfield and that disgraced ex Essendon coach

5th - Carey, Voss and Fyfe

6th - G Ablett Jnr

10th - G Ablett Snr

[KingDingAling 3,752]

The thing with Oliver and the AA is that the midfield is red hot this year. Dustin Martin, Tom Mitchell, and Patrick Dangerfield. I would probably think Josh Kelly gets a wing. And Oliver misses out due to Martin, Mitchell and Danger. Oliver may get a bench position. I would give him a spot on the interchange. He has been a top 5 mid this year. Just not a top 3.

[Watts the matter 1,235]

52 minutes ago, fndee said:

So to answer my own question Oliver would join 3 other players (that i can find) to make the AA team in their 2nd year; Ricciuto, Wingard and Jeremy Cameron. Other notables are

3rd year -  Judd, Selwood Bontempelli, Stringer 

4th - L Matthews, N Buckley, Dangerfield and that disgraced ex Essendon coach, J. Riewoldt, Franklin, Frawley, N. Riewoldt

5th - Carey, Voss and Fyfe

6th - G Ablett Jnr

10th - G Ablett Snr

 

[P-man 13,366]

Oliver and Hibberd will definitely make the squad of 40.

Jetta should make the squad but he's just the sort of player you can see being overlooked.

Garlett's last few weeks may cost him a squad position. He needs to smash the last couple of weeks to put himself back in the frame. That said, he'd still be a worthy inclusion as it stands.

i would tip Oliver to be a greater chance than Hibberd to make the final 22 due to the amount of competition for those back six spots.

As great an achievement as it would be for Oliver, and as much as I wanted to get Hibberd to the club, and as much as I love Jeffy, Jetta is the one I'd most like to see get the nod.

The great thing is that all four would be a great story in their own right.

Edited August 16, 2017 by P-man

[What 18,810]

Hibberd and Oliver surely will make the AA team.  Jetta a huge chance and will be a certainty if they choose a lock down defender, as they should .

Check out other teams forums and all three make a high % of the teams.  

 

[Little Goffy 14,462]

You've got to feel for Neville Jetta. Last year Dane Rampe, this year Rory Laird, and always the selectors think 'ok we've got a small defender so don't need another one'.

Here's the question - would you have two Neville Jettas in your team at once? For me, I'd say hell yes. Given how well he performs when out of position, outsized, isolated and outnumbered, he's much more than just a one-trick 'lock down the opponent's goalsneak' defender.

Hibberd just keeps doing his job at least as well as anyone else in the position and must surely be on the shortlist and I can't think of two players I'd rather have on the half-back flank.

Garlett it'll depend on his final couple of games and whether they can erase the memory of the recent form slump.. Kick six against Brisbane then a match-winning four against Collingwood, he'd be in.

[Dappa Dan 2,188]

Surprised to see oliver not in people's 22. Was widely regarded as a bench 22 midfielder mid year by impartials. And hasn't dropped off.

Hibberd and Jetta will duke it out for one spot in the 22... both won't get in though.

[Bitter but optimistic 22,219]

Nev Jetta. Would be one of the first pencilled in every selection meeting.  Honest, reliable and puts in a workmanlike effort every game.

And that is just what will deny him an all Aussie place. No flowing locks, no controversy - just does his job every week.

Pity we haven't got a few more like him.

[titan_uranus 24,975]

Hibberd, Jetta and Oliver should all be in the squad. I don't think Garlett's been good enough.

I can make a case for all three to be in the 22 but I suspect the best chance is Jetta, has been hyped up (somewhat, at least) in the media this year.

[Moonshadow 17,675]

Hibberd will make final team. Jetta and Jeffy will make squad of 40