James Stewart

[dazzledavey36 49,212]

Has officially asked for a trade and Carlton lead the race but is open to any Melbourne based club.

Surprise surprise Carlton Essendon and Collingwood are the clubs interested yet we are not which is disappointing.

198cm key forward who has kicked some big bags in the NEAFL. Would be the perfect foil for Hogan and add an extra big body as Weidemen continues to develop.

Surely we are having a serious look at him.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/james-stewart-tells-gws-he-wants-to-be-traded-to-melbournebased-club/news-story/8ea2fa5bd60f745132b3e6dc0d2742c6

[DemonLad5 1,640]

No thank you. He's a slightly better forward than Sam Frost

[Whispering_Jack 28,089]

I had an interesting discussion with a Carlton supporter on Saturday. He was fairly assured that the Blues would be getting both Marchbank and Stewart and possibly even one more GWS player who isn't getting a regular game. I thought that getting one player who can't make the grade at another might sometimes be helpful but trying to build your side up around what are effectively 'rejects' was going over the top. That's where some clubs appear to be heading. 

[Redleg 38,016]

22 minutes ago, Whispering_Jack said:

I had an interesting discussion with a Carlton supporter on Saturday. He was fairly assured that the Blues would be getting both Marchbank and Stewart and possibly even one more GWS player who isn't getting a regular game. I thought that getting one player who can't make the grade at another might sometimes be helpful but trying to build your side up around what are effectively 'rejects' was going over the top. That's where some clubs appear to be heading. 

Don't think that necessarily applies to GWS. They still have players not getting a game, who clearly would at other clubs.

[DeeSpencer 23,417]

2 hours ago, Whispering_Jack said:

I had an interesting discussion with a Carlton supporter on Saturday. He was fairly assured that the Blues would be getting both Marchbank and Stewart and possibly even one more GWS player who isn't getting a regular game. I thought that getting one player who can't make the grade at another might sometimes be helpful but trying to build your side up around what are effectively 'rejects' was going over the top. That's where some clubs appear to be heading. 

2 years ago Carlton way overpaid for Jaksch who was a speculative player who probably won't make it and Whiley who was a reject depth player.

But last year they got a good deal for Plowman who's good enough to make it, Phillips who's a handy 2nd ruck then 2 guys in Sumner and Lamb who were young enough to fill out their depth spots given how much Carlton needed to clean out. So 1 good player, 1 ruckmen who are their own category and 2 rejects in the right age bracket.

Marchbank was tracking well for a young tall. He's certainly not a reject. Stewart is more like that, but given Carlton's lack of tall forwards he's worth a look.

Looking at his NEAFL form it's mostly 2 or 3 goals in the first half of the year then in the back half he kicks a few bags of 5 and then an 8 goal haul. I think you'd have to look up what opposition they were against and how much GWS won by but that's some serious goal kicking. 

I'd certainly rather have Stewart than Dawes or Pedersen but I'm really not sure what he'd be worth as a trade and what contract he'd want. If he has to be paid big money and it costs a early 3rd or late 2nd round pick (that we don't have) I'm not sure it's a good deal.

[rjay 24,038]

2 hours ago, Redleg said:

Don't think that necessarily applies to GWS. They still have players not getting a game, who clearly would at other clubs.

We beat them this year and they will be one of the teams we have to beat to win a flag.

Not sure we need to top up on their rejects, we've got a couple and one gun. Maybe we should look at targeting another gun in the next few seasons.

Edited September 27, 2016 by rjay

[MadAsHell 4,089]

I wouldn't mind Stewart, especially if Hogan were to leave. But if the rumors about Hogan signing an extension are true then I feel he'd be low on our radar.

Word is he's capable of playing 2nd ruck, however 19 hit outs in 17 AFL games in 2015 when he was playing the 2nd ruck/forward role doesn't fill me with confidence.

I think we're better off drafting Darcy Cameron and picking up Luke Lowden as a DFA personally.

[Biffen 12,426]

I thought he was good as Captain Ahab .

Looks good in a pork pie hat too.

[TeamPlayedFine39 8,187]

10 hours ago, Redleg said:

Don't think that necessarily applies to GWS. They still have players not getting a game, who clearly would at other clubs.

The danger is though that they are probably not getting the stars and gamebreakers that the early picks may otherwise get you.  I'm not convinced that there are genuine A Graders not getting a game for GWS.

Carlton/Silvagni are going all-in on the GWS offcuts.

[MadAsHell 4,089]

14 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Has officially asked for a trade and Carlton lead the race but is open to any Melbourne based club.

Surprise surprise Carlton Essendon and Collingwood are the clubs interested yet we are not which is disappointing.

198cm key forward who has kicked some big bags in the NEAFL. Would be the perfect foil for Hogan and add an extra big body as Weidemen continues to develop.

Surely we are having a serious look at him.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/james-stewart-tells-gws-he-wants-to-be-traded-to-melbournebased-club/news-story/8ea2fa5bd60f745132b3e6dc0d2742c6

Unless James & his father are the types to forgive and forget I can't see him ending up at the filth.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/craig-stewart-slams-former-club-collingwood-over-lack-of-respect-for-son-james-stewart/news-story/22989cd60663438a8ff3aa210a15fee8

[beelzebub 22,282]

20 hours ago, Redleg said:

Don't think that necessarily applies to GWS. They still have players not getting a game, who clearly would at other clubs.

and with recent history I think the Blues have a discount card with the Giants !!

[Roger Mellie 3,595]

36 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

and with recent history I think the Blues have a discount card with the Giants !!

Or they're just repeat suckers (I hope)

[Dante 2,562]

On 9/27/2016 at 10:40 PM, Whispering_Jack said:

I had an interesting discussion with a Carlton supporter on Saturday. He was fairly assured that the Blues would be getting both Marchbank and Stewart and possibly even one more GWS player who isn't getting a regular game. I thought that getting one player who can't make the grade at another might sometimes be helpful but trying to build your side up around what are effectively 'rejects' was going over the top. That's where some clubs appear to be heading. 

I agree, I don't want the players that can't make it at GWS, I want the ones that can.

We have a few that were from GWS and couldn't get a game and that's fine, but no more, I'm sure we have enough depth players and now we need best 22.

[Bitter but optimistic 21,554]

On ‎9‎/‎28‎/‎2016 at 7:27 AM, Biffen said:

I thought he was good as Captain Ahab .

Looks good in a pork pie hat too.

Made some great westerns

[btdemon 475]

On 28 September 2016 at 7:27 AM, Biffen said:

I thought he was good as Captain Ahab .

Looks good in a pork pie hat too.

Gregory Peck

[Biffen 12,426]

1 minute ago, btdemon said:

Gregory Peck

Cash only.

[Satyriconhome 10,010]

Reckon the Dogs were reading this topic with both Gregory and James before the game

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_the_West_Was_Won_(film)