The Jesse Hogan Panic Room - all contract talk here

[old55 23,047]

If Hogan left we'd be looking at Freo's 1st this year (3) and next year.  We should be able to convert them into something like Tom Mitchell, Hamish Hartlett and Michael Hibberd and leave our picks intact.  That's where it sits IMO.  That's why it's important for Hogan to decide.

Edited September 8, 2016 by Fifty-5

[chook fowler 19,299]

13 minutes ago, Redleg said:

Might want to stop the Dad jokes, as I read somewhere his father wasn't well and that was a major part of the pull back home..

Oops

[Guest]

9 minutes ago, Fifty-5 said:

If Hogan left we'd be looking at Freo's 1st this year (3) and next year.  We should be able to convert them into something like Tom Mitchell, Hamish Hartlett and Michael Hibberd and leave our picks intact.  That's where it sits IMO.  That's why it's important for Hogan to decide.

I agree he needs to decide now, but Freo won't be allowed to trade next years 1st unless they get another 1st through trades this summer, as they'll have only used one 1st in 4 years.

[old55 23,047]

2 minutes ago, schmuttt said:

I agree he needs to decide now, but Freo won't be allowed to trade next years 1st unless they get another 1st through trades this summer, as they'll have only used one 1st in 4 years.

Very good point!  And they don't have a 2nd this year either.  It would have to be some Judd-style deal then 3, 2017 2nd, good player.

[Mickey 4,524]

7 minutes ago, Fifty-5 said:

Very good point!  And they don't have a 2nd this year either.  It would have to be some Judd-style deal then 3, 2017 2nd, good player.

Plus need to get Hill and McCarthy in

[old55 23,047]

1 minute ago, Mickey said:

Plus need to get Hill and McCarthy in

It's quite possible with those deals needing to get done and high value pick 3 that Freo are biding their time until next year before pushing it.

[Guest]

5 minutes ago, Fifty-5 said:

It's quite possible with those deals needing to get done and high value pick 3 that Freo are biding their time until next year before pushing it.

Freo definitely would prefer to get him next year value wise, they'll want to keep 3 for sure. On the other hand we would want to get it done this year whilst they have 3 and the fact we need to learn to play without him long term if he goes so might as well go now.

[John Crow Batty 8,828]

14 minutes ago, Mickey said:

Plus need to get Hill and McCarthy in

 McCarthy walked out of GWS and stood down for the season. What's the deal there.? Is he like any other contracted player?

Edited September 8, 2016 by america de cali

[Redleg 40,386]

4 minutes ago, america de cali said:

 McCarthy walked out of GWS and stood down for the season. What's the deal there.?

Said he was suffering from some form of mental illness and needed to get home as part of the remedy.

[Guest]

3 minutes ago, america de cali said:

 McCarthy walked out of GWS and stood down for the season. What's the deal there.? Is he like any other contracted player?

Will be traded like any other contracted player. I actually had no issue with what GWS did, they wanted to make a stand regarding players and I think they sent a message. Sure they'll lose out in value (They would have ended up with pick 3 this year...) but it was ridiculous how McCarthy signed a new deal then a couple months later wanted out.

[daisycutter 29,438]

reckon jesse won't make his decision till this thread reaches 100 pages

we are at 67 pages, so come on all you 'landers, start posting like crazy

 

[Guest]

2 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

reckon jesse won't make his decision till this thread reaches 100 pages

we are at 67 pages, so come on all you 'landers, start posting like crazy

 

Oh, it'll go well past that in trade week.

[worldwideweb_demon 90]

Sad that we may have to trade our superstar but seems to be the fact of modern football. Anyone know how well Adelaide did for losing Dangerfield last year?

I am guessing they would have been better if they traded with us or another team the year before?

[Redleg 40,386]

If Jesse wanted to go back west next year, he would have to tell us within the next 4 weeks, as trade week starts then.

We can assume then, that if we are not told that by the end of trade week, that he is probably happy to extend his contract with us.

I don't see him playing an extra year with us, if he wants to go home and then allowing Freo to screw us, when he is uncontracted. 

We have been good to him, paid a lot for him and  paid him for a year, when he was out injured.

I think he would want us to be treated fairly, if he chose to leave.

Edited September 8, 2016 by Redleg

[binman 42,148]

1 minute ago, Redleg said:

If Jesse wanted to go back west next year, he would have to tell us within the next 4 weeks, as trade week starts then.

We can assume then, that if we are not told that by the end of trade week, that he is probably happy to extend his contract with us.

I don't see him playing an extra year with us, if he wants to go home and then allowing Freo to screw us, when he is uncontracted. 

We have been good to him, paid a lot for him and  paid him for a year, when he was out injured.

I think he would want us to be treated fairly, if he chose to leave.

Agree. 

I think he'll stay. Even if there is a big pull to live near family i honestly can't see how attractive Freo would be to go to as a club (its funny how all the talk is freo and not WC at all, though i suppose they have Kennedy).  They're now in a rebuild and realistically 2-3 years behind us in terms of that rebuild. They don't have that many young guns on the list. As i've noted the travel factor is a huge negative, particularly for  a KP with a history of back issues. And i reckon Ross Lyon would be a pretty intimating coach and i wonder how Jesse would go with him.

[Ted Lasso 18,914]

On 9/8/2016 at 4:11 PM, Redleg said:

If Jesse wanted to go back west next year, he would have to tell us within the next 4 weeks, as trade week starts then.

We can assume then, that if we are not told that by the end of trade week, that he is probably happy to extend his contract with us.

I don't see him playing an extra year with us, if he wants to go home and then allowing Freo to screw us, when he is uncontracted. 

We have been good to him, paid a lot for him and  paid him for a year, when he was out injured.

I think he would want us to be treated fairly, if he chose to leave.

And there is no doubt the club and Jesse are aware of this, no doubt the conversations have already happened to see where he's at as far as extending, I suspect the future of Dawes might be tied to the outcome of that conversation.

The club knows Jesse is our biggest trade asset, maybe Gawn is the only other one in the same conversation and if he leaves we simply have to get a good return on him,

 

[Copuchas 758]

5 minutes ago, Redleg said:

If Jesse wanted to go back west next year, he would have to tell us within the next 4 weeks, as trade week starts then.

We can assume then, that if we are not told that by the end of trade week, that he is probably happy to extend his contract with us.

I don't see him playing an extra year with us, if he wants to go home and then allowing Freo to screw us, when he is uncontracted. 

We have been good to him, paid a lot for him and  paid him for a year, when he was out injured.

I think he would want us to be treated fairly, if he chose to leave.

Redleg, that's well reasoned logic albeit with one caveat.  There's been several oblique references on here to the nature of the family issue Jesse is contending with and Paul Roos made an even more subtle reference to it.  It would seem apparent that resolution of that issue is likely a primary driver in Jesse's decision making.  Unfortunately, the timing of the resolution is not a controllable variable and hence the possibility remains that we end up getting screwed, albeit inadvertently.

 

[John Crow Batty 8,828]

18 minutes ago, Copuchas said:

Redleg, that's well reasoned logic albeit with one caveat.  There's been several oblique references on here to the nature of the family issue Jesse is contending with and Paul Roos made an even more subtle reference to it.  It would seem apparent that resolution of that issue is likely a primary driver in Jesse's decision making.  Unfortunately, the timing of the resolution is not a controllable variable and hence the possibility remains that we end up getting screwed, albeit inadvertently.

 

Roos ever the diplomat  will skirt around any unpalatable truth if negotiations are in progress. Family reasons is the least controversial angle he could put on it. Family reasons may be the truth or not but could also be a face saving move for all parties involved in an effort to get a deal done.  

Edited September 8, 2016 by america de cali

[Deestroy All 14,262]

Been replaced on the club website banner by Jack Watts. 

 

Dun dun Dunnnnnnn

[DemonOX 8,734]

5 minutes ago, Deestroy All said:

Been replaced on the club website banner by Jack Watts. 

 

Dun dun Dunnnnnnn

Yep he's gone based on that. 

Does he have a Twitter account???

Edited September 8, 2016 by DemonOX

[faultydet 7,594]

6 minutes ago, Deestroy All said:

Been replaced on the club website banner by Jack Watts. 

 

Dun dun Dunnnnnnn

Hasn't there been several faces there during the season?

[Deestroy All 14,262]

2 minutes ago, faultydet said:

Hasn't there been several faces there during the season?

Not that I've noticed. Been Jones and Hogan. 

 

I'm just stirring [censored] btw. 

[Generation dee 1,336]

The news I got at the best and fairest, from another of our players who was tight with jesse-

He was absolutely staying until about July. Since then he's gotten homesick and is more likely to leave than stay. This player said it's his gut feeling he will make that known at the exit meetings, which will be had after Casey finish the finals.

[DubDee 24,765]

1 minute ago, Generation dee said:

The news I got at the best and fairest, from another of our players who was tight with jesse-

He was absolutely staying until about July. Since then he's gotten homesick and is more likely to leave than stay. This player said it's his gut feeling he will make that known at the exit meetings, which will be had after Casey finish the finals.

Faaark me. Homesick?! 

Would explain his last 6 weeks of footy too. Him leaving will put us back a long long way. 

[faultydet 7,594]

2 minutes ago, Generation dee said:

The news I got at the best and fairest, from another of our players who was tight with jesse-

He was absolutely staying until about July. Since then he's gotten homesick and is more likely to leave than stay. This player said it's his gut feeling he will make that known at the exit meetings, which will be had after Casey finish the finals.

Perf is an isolated country town, full of screaming meatheads (and my nephew, who is awesome)

Why the hell would he be homesick for a place like that?