I think the Rookie draft is apt for many a proposed draftee.

I think he deserves another chance

I rate him...immensely - can't quite crack a permanent position at the Cats. I think he'd complement our need for outside mid/half forward very nicely.

 

Edited August 5, 20196 yr by Engorged Onion

4 minutes ago, Engorged Onion said:

I rate him...immensely - can't quite crack a permanent position at the Cats. I think he'd complement our need for outside mid/half forward very nicely.

 

Agree he's a pretty decent AFL footballer who's a lovely kick for goal from distance.

He's been injured for a few weeks this year, but is otherwise ensconced in their best 22.

he was killing it last year, but should really be in their best 22 this year.. what's happened. did he do a brayshaw or what? lol

Is slow, isn't a great defensive runner or player.

It's a big no from me.

Why the bump? Some sort of news?

1 minute ago, titan_uranus said:

Why the bump? Some sort of news?

Yeap it’s the offseason, expect random posters linking random players/coaches/sponsors to us.

No thank you! No Geelong players.

1 hour ago, Dee tention said:

No thank you! No Geelong players.

Agreed. We don’t need the likes of Hawkins, Dangerfield or Kelly

He’s contracted until the end of 2020, will be 28 next season, would be onto his fourth club and is very injury prone. Sounds like just the sort of player a club in our position needs. 

Edited August 5, 20196 yr by Ethan Tremblay

39 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

He’s contracted until the end of 2020, will be 28 next season, would be onto his fourth club and is very injury prone. Sounds like just the sort of player a club in our position needs. 

Agreed. 

5 year deal. 

Men En Gola

8 hours ago, Rocky said:

he was killing it last year, but should really be in their best 22 this year.. what's happened. did he do a brayshaw or what? lol

He is best 22.

Been out of the side because of injury.

20 hours ago, Demon Disciple said:

Agreed. We don’t need the likes of Hawkins, Dangerfield or Kelly

Nup! Don’t want them...

I have a Moral Turpitude! Lol...

No no no

23 hours ago, Dee tention said:

No thank you! No Geelong players.

It's a no for me too - I still feel filthy from the Tom Gillies trade. 

2nd round pick anyone? Playing pretty well tonight

Ok. Just ok.  Cats are very disappointing. 

Would prefer not.

Non. Pass. No thanks. Nein

He was one of the geelong players that stood out for me in the elimination final last year. Big bodied. Reminds me now of vandenberg. We need one of these players in our side at least

Bit of a meh player. Gets a fair bit of the ball but has no hurt factor at all and is slow.

Pass

4 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Bit of a meh player. Gets a fair bit of the ball but has no hurt factor at all and is slow.

Pass

If Vandenberg can get out there we wont need him

In what world is Menegola slow? He has an excellent burst of speed and power. His issues are ball use under pressure - he's very much a straight lines get it on the boot type - and durability. Had 2 excellent seasons at Geelong but he bounced off 2 AFL lists due to injuries and had an interrupted year this year. He'd be a risk. Not the sort of player you'd chase in contract.