Demonland Player of the Year - Round 8

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,339]

Very surprised that some left Jones out of the top six players.

He was absolutely superb - his attack on the ball was on another level and I thought he was the one who set the tone in the last quarter to enable us to withstand the Dogs' charge and then run away with it.

Spencer and Toumpas might have caught the eye because their games were far superior to what they've shown in the past, but in terms of impact on the game they were not at the level of Nathan Jones. He was immense and was clearly in our best three for me.

He was well beaten in the first quarter, had two poor errors including one that any other year would have seen us drop our bundle and lose. I also thought Wallis was one of their better players. Was serviceable and great in the last but thought it was not close to his best.

[Lil_red_fire_engine 11,339]

6. Vandenberg

5. Vince

4. Hogan

3. Fitzpatrick

2. Pederson

1. Grimes

NB: Special mention to Brayshaw whose last quarter was truly immense and a sign of whats to come with this kid.

[jane02 3,782]

6. Vandenberg

5. Hogan

4. Pedersen

3. Vince

2. N Jones

1. Spencer

Edited May 24, 2015 by jane02

[La Dee-vina Comedia 17,059]

If anyone gives Matt Jones votes they should get a life ban.

6. vandenFyfe

5. Pedersen

4. Hogan

3. Vince

2. Fitzpatrick

1. Toumpas

I agree M Jones doesn't deserve votes, but this statement is overly harsh. His job was to keep Murphy quiet and he did it pretty well. After M Jones was subbed out Murphy came into the play. Now to my votes:

6. vandenBerg

5. N Jones

4. Hogan

3. Vince

2. Cross

1. Toumpas

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

I agree M Jones doesn't deserve votes, but this statement is overly harsh. His job was to keep Murphy quiet and he did it pretty well. After M Jones was subbed out Murphy came into the play. Now to my votes:

6. vandenBerg

5. N Jones

4. Hogan

3. Vince

2. Cross

1. Toumpas

I'll put my hand up, I was at the game and didn't even realise he was doing a job on Murphy, credit where it's due.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 17,059]

I'll put my hand up, I was at the game and didn't even realise he was doing a job on Murphy, credit where it's due.

Actually, the bigger shock is that I actually noticed. I'm not usually one who identifies match-ups. But Bail stopped Johanisen (I'm not sure if I've spelled that right, but Nasher can fix it with square brackets) and with M Jones stopping Murphy a lot of the Bulldogs run was successfully eliminated. So, even though M Jones and Bail didn't appear to do that much, and, with Riley, will likely be the first to be omitted when Viney, Tyson, JKH, etc are ready to return, they did their job.

[monoccular 17,691]

Carries team every week and watches teammates butcher the footy. No credit.

Makes a mistake and supporters go on about it like its the worst thing ever done by a Melbourne player.

I guess today I knew that Jones was human. Until today I was sure he was a machine.

I guess because it was so unusual it was commented upon. As you say, he is human after all.

What about Matty Jones job on Murph Wore him like a glove

I love Man on Man footy

I think that many (myself included) have not given him credit for that. Good post.

Nevertheless I would expect that he and Bail will make way for the likes of Viney, Tyson, Salem, Frost when they recover.

[FireOath 290]

6 - vandenBerg

5 - Vince

4 - Pedersen

3 - Spencer

2 - NJones

1 - Fitzpatrick

[Demonland 73,780]

Tommy still holds sway but look who's coming -

101. Tom McDonald

47. Jesse Hogan

46. Nathan Jones

36. Jeffrey Garlett

34. Bernie Vince

30. Christian Salem Aaron vandenBerg

29. Daniel Cross Colin Garland

25. Cam Pedersen

22. Jack Viney

17. Angus Brayshaw

10. Neville Jetta

7. Jack Watts

6. Jack Grimes

5. Jimmy Toumpas

4. Lynden Dunn Mark Jamar Viv Michie Ben Newton

3. Heritier Lubumba

1. Dom Tyson

[Deestroy All 14,266]

6 vandenBulldozer

5 Jones - the good one

4 Vince

3 Hogan

2 Pedo

1 Cross

Tom McDonald, where's he at? Really needs to lift his game. 1 weeks in a row he hasn't been in the votes.

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

6. vanderhaus

5. Blessed be thy name Jesse H. Christ

4. Weekend at Bernie Vince's

3. Brackets Pedersen

2. Avatar Fitzpatrick

1. Angry old man

[Jesse Christ 2,884]

Oh [censored] I forgot about the good Jones. He can have 4 votes too

[Uncle Fester 2,848]

6. Vandenberg

5. Vince

4. Hogan

3. Fitzpatrick

2. [Pedersen]

1. Grimes

NB: Special mention to Brayshaw whose last quarter was truly immense and a sign of whats to come with this kid.

Pretty much as I saw the top 4. The last two votes I couldn't seperate from a bunch of players. [Pedersen], Grimes, Garlett (creative and always kept the defence honest), Watts (went when it was his turn, and was very creative at times), Spencer (mongrel and hardness), Toumpas (worked hard all day and got better the longer the game went), Brayshaw (worked hard all day, and then went up a cog in the last), Jones, N and Jones, M (both of them overcame quiet moments to influence the game when it was needed), or even Pigdog who came off the bench and attacked any and every Footscray player he saw with the ball.

Great team game, and all the players should feel like they played an important part in the win.

Edit: And Cross... how could I forget him?

Edited May 25, 2015 by Uncle Fester

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

I really wanted to know what people actually thought of this week so I did the first ten votes

It took me 5 minutes

vanD 59
vince 39
hogan 31
peddo 22
spencer 18
jones 16
fitz 9

toumpas 6
grimes 5
brayshaw 4

[CBDees 3,167]

6. Vandenberg -

5. Fitzpatrick-

4. Hogan-

3. Pedersen-

2. Vince-

1. Toumpas -

[Bitter but optimistic 22,289]

Pedo

VanDemon

NJones

Hogan

Spencer

Vince

[Moonshadow 17,678]

Pedo

VanDemon

NJones

Hogan

Spencer

Vince

Surprised you didn't give your love child Spencil all the votes Uncle Bitter. I've never seen a grown man at the footy gush over a player like you did yesterday. At least you kept your shirt buttoned up this time, thankfully.

Spence did well, I might add, and his kicking looked, um.... good.

Hogan

vanders

the Pedo

Toump

Spencil

Edited May 25, 2015 by Moonshadow

[CBDees 3,167]

Surprised you didn't give your love child Spencil all the votes Uncle Bitter. I've never seen a grown man at the footy gush over a player like you did yesterday. At least you kept your shirt buttoned up this time, thankfully.

Spence did well, I might add, and his kicking looked, um.... good.

Hogan

vanders

the Pedo

Toump

Spencil

Similarly surprised that you couldn't think of a single player worthy of your sixth vote Moonshadow!

[Moonshadow 17,678]

Similarly surprised that you couldn't think of a single player worthy of your sixth vote Moonshadow!

Oops. Sixth vote goes to Gus. Sorry CBD

[Dinosaur Rover 197]

He must of been reading Demonland...a few of us called for him to be moved back last year.

...but seriously it was a good move to bring him in against Boyd otherwise Dunn would have been outsized again and when Boyd was subbed out with only one handball. The beauty with Fitz is he then had the pace to go with a smaller opponent.

Early days but if he can develop as a defender then he offers height and leg speed. Could be a career saving move but lets wait and see.

This is the future with more and more big forwards and resting rucks

We have done well with dunn at 1.92m on the likes of kurt tippet (until last game) but effective tall defender is required - maybe fitzies the one

Edited May 25, 2015 by Dinosaur Rover

[Deeoldfart 8,145]

Just got back from the 'G' so my votes are late again ...... but for the record:

6. vandenBerg

5. Vince

4. N.Jones

3. Hogan

2. Pedersen

1. Fitzpatrick

[Demon Dynasty 17,135]

6. Vanders

5. Mr. Vince

4. Jones Boy

3. Grubby (Grimes)

2. the Toump

1. Crossy