Hard done by

[Steamin Demon 370]

This is probably not a ground breaking thread but I thought I'd share an insight of one of the playing group.

I had a chat with a Jack Watts (not on the family day) about what Roosy was like. Jack told me that they can finally see how a real coach operates after six years of rubbish. The group kind of felt hard done by as its obvious the last 5-6 years were a waste.

Some might read this in a negative light but it's not how Jack portrayed it. It's as though they felt like "where has this been"? Jack said he has never been more optimistic about the year ahead and that PR has had a enormous effect on the group.

Its not massive but I thought it was worth a share.

[McQueen 17,864]

Not sure if this has been placed in any other thread but think it's suited to this one.

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2014-02-18/roos-attitude-critical-in-win-trengove

Edited February 18, 2014 by McQueen

[Wells 11 4,839]

The irony in this has got to be that if Melbourne wasnt such a complete and total basket case I doubt roosy would have been offered the money nor have been interested in the position. So.....if he's really as good as everyone seems to be saying we should probably thank Neeld and schwab!

[old dee 22,946]

The irony in this has got to be that if Melbourne wasnt such a complete and total basket case I doubt roosy would have been offered the money nor have been interested in the position. So.....if he's really as good as everyone seems to be saying we should probably thank Neeld and schwab!

Sorry to say Wells 11 but that has got to be the strangest conclusion I have seen in some time.

It is a bit like saying just as well they bombed Hiroshima because we end up with Mazda cars.

[Bitter but optimistic 21,387]

This is probably not a ground breaking thread but I thought I'd share an insight of one of the playing group.

I had a chat with a Jack Watts (not on the family day) about what Roosy was like. Jack told me that they can finally see how a real coach operates after six years of rubbish. The group kind of felt hard done by as its obvious the last 5-6 years were a waste.

Some might read this in a negative light but it's not how Jack portrayed it. It's as though they felt like "where has this been"? Jack said he has never been more optimistic about the year ahead and that PR has had a enormous effect on the group.

Its not massive but I thought it was worth a share.

That is a really interesting comment Steam but I think it's a bit harsh to put Bailey in the same basket as Neeld.

[The Song Formerly Known As 6,479]

bahahahahahah is this a joke?

I feel hard done by the 5-6 years of a team not having a crack, or seeming to give a damn.

And i have paid EVERY YEAR to feel this way, you Jack and the rest, have been paid quite handsomely to feel "hard done by."

Losers move blame onto other people.

Take some of it onto yourselves please boys, not all of it is the coaches fault.

Hard done by?

Spare me please.

[old dee 22,946]

That is a really interesting comment Steam but I think it's a bit harsh to put Bailey in the same basket as Neeld.

He and his underlings gave us all those wonderful players like Gysberts, Cook, Bennel, Martin, Campbell etc etc

Presidered over 186.

Cut every Senior player for kids who were not ready.

Not harsh IMO.

Well deserved

[Moonshadow 16,344]

This is probably not a ground breaking thread but I thought I'd share an insight of one of the playing group.

I had a chat with a Jack Watts (not on the family day) about what Roosy was like. Jack told me that they can finally see how a real coach operates after six years of rubbish. The group kind of felt hard done by as its obvious the last 5-6 years were a waste.

Some might read this in a negative light but it's not how Jack portrayed it. It's as though they felt like "where has this been"? Jack said he has never been more optimistic about the year ahead and that PR has had a enormous effect on the group.

Its not massive but I thought it was worth a share.

That's all well and true, but when are we going to see the real Jack Watts? It's easy to throw mud, but harder to catch it.

[old dee 22,946]

That's all well and true, but when are we going to see the real Jack Watts? It's easy to throw mud, but harder to catch it.

2014

[Moonshadow 16,344]

We shall see old. I truly hope you are correct. Talk is cheap though.

[Redleg 37,894]

He and his underlings gave us all those wonderful players like Gysberts, Cook, Bennel, Martin, Campbell etc etc

Presidered over 186.

Cut every Senior player for kids who were not ready.

Not harsh IMO.

Well deserved

Dean is pretty ill and I think out of respect we should leave him out of these sort of discussions.

[Bitter but optimistic 21,387]

He and his underlings gave us all those wonderful players like Gysberts, Cook, Bennel, Martin, Campbell etc etc

Presidered over 186.

Cut every Senior player for kids who were not ready.

Not harsh IMO.

Well deser

He wasn't perfect that's for sure OD. However, we had some memorable and inspiring wins under Bailey that will stick in my memory forever. Bailey was not divisive in the same way as Neeld.

[old dee 22,946]

He wasn't perfect that's for sure OD. However, we had some memorable and inspiring wins under Bailey that will stick in my memory forever. Bailey was not divisive in the same way as Neeld.

What you say is true Bbo And we are getting off the thread theme so I will leave it there but just say I cannot forgive yet

[KingDingAling 3,614]

I'd be disappointed if any of our players blamed the previous coaches or board.

Nathan Jones didn't seem to have any trouble performing, it comes from within, Jones knows this - as do all the elite.

We've had a lot of pea hearts on our list over the years, thankfully most of them are now gone.

[old dee 22,946]

Dean is pretty ill and I think out of respect we should leave him out of these sort of discussions.

Yes poor timing Redleg

[Bitter but optimistic 21,387]

Dean is pretty ill and I think out of respect we should leave him out of these sort of discussions.

Appreciate your compassion RL but disagree with your contention. We are not into character assination but a discussion of the club and its performance in various situations. We all have sympathy for Dean and his family but we cannot expunge his time at the club from our history nor its (possible) impact on our current state.

[Moonshadow 16,344]

I'd be disappointed if any of our players blamed the previous coaches or board.

Nathan Jones didn't seem to have any trouble performing, it comes from within, Jones knows this - as do all the elite.

We've had a lot of pea hearts on our list over the years, thankfully most of them are now gone.

Agreed. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I've never read Bailey or Neeld blaming individual players for the team's failings.

[Guest]

At the end of the day, these blokes are meant to be adults. Neeld carried on like a madman at times but he didn't make Brent Moloney not try.
I'm pretty certain that if we do come good, a lot of the same guys who didn't like Neeldy or Bails will be looking for plenty of plaudits and won't be palming those plaudits onto Paul Roos exclusively.

[What 18,810]

if Mark Neeld was responsible for us losing cry babies like Moloney, Rivers and Sylvia then I want to shake his hand.

Thank you Neeldy for weeding out the culture killers!

[jabberwocky 2,301]

The irony in this has got to be that if Melbourne wasnt such a complete and total basket case I doubt roosy would have been offered the money nor have been interested in the position. So.....if he's really as good as everyone seems to be saying we should probably thank Neeld and schwab!

Cuddles....is that you?

[mjt 640]

I'd be disappointed if any of our players blamed the previous coaches or board.

Nathan Jones didn't seem to have any trouble performing, it comes from within, Jones knows this - as do all the elite.

We've had a lot of pea hearts on our list over the years, thankfully most of them are now gone.

The club was gifted the most highly decorated junior footballers in the country over the last 7 years , and 2 coaches screwed them its as simple as that, I think people are going to be very shocked this year .

[Steamin Demon 370]

bahahahahahah is this a joke?

I feel hard done by the 5-6 years of a team not having a crack, or seeming to give a damn.

And i have paid EVERY YEAR to feel this way, you Jack and the rest, have been paid quite handsomely to feel "hard done by."

Losers move blame onto other people.

Take some of it onto yourselves please boys, not all of it is the coaches fault.

Hard done by?

Spare me please.

No joke mate, he was merely stating that they now felt like they were being coached. He freely admits he's got to improve as the the entire list.

[rpfc 27,590]

I kind of just want to move on - I know Roos is an improvement, I am not surprised the players agree.

[Little Goffy 12,722]

Lol, sounds like Goldilocks to me.

"This coach is too soft"

"This coach is too hard"

"Ahhh, this coach is just right"

[mjt 640]

No joke mate, he was merely stating that they now felt like they were being coached. He freely admits he's got to improve as the the entire list.

If your good enough you get 10 yrs on a list Jacks lost 5 of those already, we should thank him for his loyalty.