WELCOME TO DEMONLAND - PAUL ROOS

[Bang Bang Bang 5,619]

I hate to be a wet blanket here but I think many of us are vastly over-anticipating what Roos is going to do for us. If it was 1991 and we had 22 of him it would be a different story! The fact remains we have major list problems. By my count we have 7 genuine footballers and a bunch of hopefuls, and a staggering number of aloso-rans like Tapscott and Strauss who seem to have no 'special' quality for any coach to unlock. The 05/06 grand final teams that Roos coached had Kirk, Goodes, Hall, Barry, O'Keefe, Bolton, Buchanan, Kennelly, McVeigh, Crouch etc. It remains to be seen to what extent they were a successful team because of Roos himself. We certainly do not have a group anything like that at this moment in time.

Of course it is a big step in the right direction but let's not get carried away and raise expectations too high, particularly early on. He still needs to rebuild his list, instill a new gameplan and mould the players into the team he wants, erasing years of bad habits in a group with zero confidence and very little heart. For one thing I don't see how he can 'fix' the issue that we have a list full of blokes that make outrageously bad skill errors with staggering consistency. What could of course make a big immmediate impact is if Roos' signature creates the opportunity for us to draft in an established quality midfielder or two. However, I for one will be looking at 3-4 years from now in a team headlined by Viney and Hogan for any genuine on-field results... (but you never know...!)

I don't think anyone is expecting dramatic on-field improvement next year just because Roos is there. I for one expect us to be very much bottom 4.

Having said that I expect a "Sack Roos" thread as early as Round 5.

Let's not forget that Roos is not only a Premiership coach, but he kept a side in the top half of the ladder for nearly a decade straight, without ever needing to bottom out and without the aid of top draft picks. The culture he created up there and his ability to instantly make the MFC an attractive place for players to come/stay is what excites me most.

[Robot Devil 1,895]

Anyone think it might be worthwhile to give Sheeds a call to see if he's available?

Is the hot water service in the change rooms on the blink?

http://basham.com.au/insidesauce.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/kevin-sheedy01.jpg

Edited August 31, 2013 by Robot Devil

[Return to Glory 7,869]

I hate to be a wet blanket on your wet blanket, but Roos hasn't signed yet.

I see your wet blankets and I raise a breath of fresh air. Signed.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Roos Coach, Taidgh Kennelly Assistant, or so the Australian says; I can live with that. What a get.

[mitch 127]

I see your wet blankets and I raise a breath of fresh air. Signed.

Link?

[Demon Stalwart 255]

And if he doesn't sign now what then ?

After how so many here have put their heart on their sleeve and committed already to a Roos lead revival !

All I can say Roo's, is go on sign the bloody thing and lets get on with it

Just don't bet the house on it, at least not quite yet .

But in case you do and he doesn't than you can always turn to the help line for problem gambling to let your frustrations known

Please just don't do it here

I'm just glad I don't have a gambling addiction , but if we did get Roos I have to admit that could just change

[DemonOX 8,581]

well i'll call it

Welcome to the Melbourne Demons Paul Roos .

Make us into a team worthy of our jumper , our heritage , our sufferance and persevering hope.

We dont expect miracles but a competitive team is the bar.

Do what you do and do it well.

Go Dees.

Don't jinx us bb

[Deestar3 167]

I hate to be a wet blanket here but I think many of us are vastly over-anticipating what Roos is going to do for us. If it was 1991 and we had 22 of him it would be a different story! The fact remains we have major list problems. By my count we have 7 genuine footballers and a bunch of hopefuls, and a staggering number of aloso-rans like Tapscott and Strauss who seem to have no 'special' quality for any coach to unlock. The 05/06 grand final teams that Roos coached had Kirk, Goodes, Hall, Barry, O'Keefe, Bolton, Buchanan, Kennelly, McVeigh, Crouch etc. It remains to be seen to what extent they were a successful team because of Roos himself. We certainly do not have a group anything like that at this moment in time.

Of course it is a big step in the right direction but let's not get carried away and raise expectations too high, particularly early on. He still needs to rebuild his list, instill a new gameplan and mould the players into the team he wants, erasing years of bad habits in a group with zero confidence and very little heart. For one thing I don't see how he can 'fix' the issue that we have a list full of blokes that make outrageously bad skill errors with staggering consistency. What could of course make a big immmediate impact is if Roos' signature creates the opportunity for us to draft in an established quality midfielder or two. However, I for one will be looking at 3-4 years from now in a team headlined by Viney and Hogan for any genuine on-field results... (but you never know...!)

[ILLDieADemon 804]

http://www.3aw.com.au/podcasts Half Way down 3AW Football Preview you can listen to it online or download the entire show (apprx 36mb) the Roos discussion happens at the 22.10 mark.

If anyone would know it would be Mike and after hearing his comments on 3aw it looks like its a done deal.

Bring on 2014 boys.

[Deestar3 167]

well glad you are not the coach. Happy to take roos assessment of the team...nobody expects miracles but I think it is sheer arrogance to suggest that your opinion is where we are at . I was listening to Luke Dalhaus who said he had the worst skills by hand & foot at the club last year & he is still working on them. With hard work, good coaching & most importantly confidence ....a lot can change.

[dee-luded 2,958]

Anyone think it might be worthwhile to give Sheeds a call to see if he's available?

I think he needs to dust his cape off, & fly back into the Essendon Airport hanger,,, where he was Jet'isoned from.

they need his spruiking & old fashioned inner straight talk,, urgently.

[Ted Lasso 17,335]

If he has met with our leadership group it's pretty safe to Say it's done.

[Robot Devil 1,895]

If he has met with our leadership group it's pretty safe to Say it's done.

Would love to have been a fly on the wall at that meeting.

[Hannibal 5,814]

I hate to be a wet blanket here but I think many of us are vastly over-anticipating what Roos is going to do for us. If it was 1991 and we had 22 of him it would be a different story! The fact remains we have major list problems. By my count we have 7 genuine footballers and a bunch of hopefuls, and a staggering number of aloso-rans like Tapscott and Strauss who seem to have no 'special' quality for any coach to unlock. The 05/06 grand final teams that Roos coached had Kirk, Goodes, Hall, Barry, O'Keefe, Bolton, Buchanan, Kennelly, McVeigh, Crouch etc. It remains to be seen to what extent they were a successful team because of Roos himself. We certainly do not have a group anything like that at this moment in time.

Of course it is a big step in the right direction but let's not get carried away and raise expectations too high, particularly early on. He still needs to rebuild his list, instill a new gameplan and mould the players into the team he wants, erasing years of bad habits in a group with zero confidence and very little heart. For one thing I don't see how he can 'fix' the issue that we have a list full of blokes that make outrageously bad skill errors with staggering consistency. What could of course make a big immmediate impact is if Roos' signature creates the opportunity for us to draft in an established quality midfielder or two. However, I for one will be looking at 3-4 years from now in a team headlined by Viney and Hogan for any genuine on-field results... (but you never know...!)

I think we all know that mate. Although I reckon we've more dormant talent that some believe.

I'm delirious. You can please yourself.

[What 18,810]

I think we all know that mate. Although I reckon we've more dormant talent that some believe.

I'm delirious. You can please yourself.

Yup.

How can anyone pour cold water on this?

This is the absolute best possible scenario for the MFC

it is like a dream

There are dozens of positives and literally no negatives

[beelzebub 22,771]

Don't jinx us bb

I'm pretty sure what we're currently seeing is stage managed PR ( pun intended )

Listen to language now used. Consider the relative timing of many and various.

Roos has already met leadership group. Has been in constant discussion with club for months.

PR's pr is running this til its all above board.

This is a show. Script's been written ..agreed to.

[Sir Why You Little 35,374]

After listening to the MMM Podcast i reckon it's a done deal.

There is no other reason Roos would meet with the leadership group.

[chookrat 3,870]

I don't think anyone is expecting dramatic on-field improvement next year just because Roos is there. I for one expect us to be very much bottom 4.

Having said that I expect a "Sack Roos" thread as early as Round 5.

Let's not forget that Roos is not only a Premiership coach, but he kept a side in the top half of the ladder for nearly a decade straight, without ever needing to bottom out and without the aid of top draft picks. The culture he created up there and his ability to instantly make the MFC an attractive place for players to come/stay is what excites me most.

I expect we will train the house down during preseason

[chookrat 3,870]

I don't think anyone is expecting dramatic on-field improvement next year just because Roos is there. I for one expect us to be very much bottom 4.

Having said that I expect a "Sack Roos" thread as early as Round 5.

Let's not forget that Roos is not only a Premiership coach, but he kept a side in the top half of the ladder for nearly a decade straight, without ever needing to bottom out and without the aid of top draft picks. The culture he created up there and his ability to instantly make the MFC an attractive place for players to come/stay is what excites me most.

I expect we will train the house down during preseason

[Crompton's the man 635]

Is the hot water service in the change rooms on the blink?http://basham.com.au/insidesauce.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/kevin-sheedy01.jpg

Sheedy's not available

He's pre-booked to unglug the blocked sewer pipes at his former club.

It's a long-term job involving copious use of cover-all-odours perfumes ( imported in bulk from New Orleans houses of ill repute )

[chookrat 3,870]

I don't think anyone is expecting dramatic on-field improvement next year just because Roos is there. I for one expect us to be very much bottom 4.

Having said that I expect a "Sack Roos" thread as early as Round 5.

Let's not forget that Roos is not only a Premiership coach, but he kept a side in the top half of the ladder for nearly a decade straight, without ever needing to bottom out and without the aid of top draft picks. The culture he created up there and his ability to instantly make the MFC an attractive place for players to come/stay is what excites me most.

I expect we will train the house down during preseason

[Footynut 302]

This the Australian link...

Seems a definite done deal.

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/sport/afl/paul-roos-close-to-signing-2m-deal-to-coach-melbourne-demons/story-fnca0u4y-1226708022794

[chookrat 3,870]

I don't think anyone is expecting dramatic on-field improvement next year just because Roos is there. I for one expect us to be very much bottom 4.

Having said that I expect a "Sack Roos" thread as early as Round 5.

Let's not forget that Roos is not only a Premiership coach, but he kept a side in the top half of the ladder for nearly a decade straight, without ever needing to bottom out and without the aid of top draft picks. The culture he created up there and his ability to instantly make the MFC an attractive place for players to come/stay is what excites me most.

I expect we will train the house down during preseason

[keep13alive 78]

The irony of pelican denham reporting it.LOL

[Guest]

This the Australian link...

Seems a definite done deal.

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/sport/afl/paul-roos-close-to-signing-2m-deal-to-coach-melbourne-demons/story-fnca0u4y-1226708022794

Kennelly and Stone too? My god. Excitement levels through the roof