Chris Dawes Article

[PJ_12345 1,098]

He may be a smart bloke, but remember in his last article he said that the coaching staff and the players told him that he should move on from Collingwood because he was not good enough. Like most Melbourne players, the more games they miss the higher Demonland rate them. Struggled at Collongwood, they got rid of him and recruited an old player in Lynch. I don't see how he will be any better at Melbourne.

He is a good player, you dont win premierships by being ordinary.

At Collingwood he was Clokes decoy and used as back up ruck, and was he in the 22 - no. Would he be in our 22 - definately

That goes for Byrnes, Clark and any other player we have picked up.

BTW, Dawes chose to leave - big difference

[Yourenextdipper 19]

Plenty of ordinary players have been lucky enough to be part of a premiership team, it does not mean that he as an individual is a good player.

If Collingwood thought that Dawes was in their best 22 he would still be there. He was told that he would not be in the best 22 and should look elsewhere (by the coaches and players!!! He wrote about this). He will be in the best 22 at Melbourne because the club has recruited poorly, including topping up with players who are not seen as AFL standard by other clubs.

Melbourne got into this mess by thinking that they were smarter at judging talent than other clubs and drafting poorly, maybe now they should start to pay attention to who other clubs say are not up to it.

[MadAsHell 4,088]

Plenty of ordinary players have been lucky enough to be part of a premiership team, it does not mean that he as an individual is a good player.

If Collingwood thought that Dawes was in their best 22 he would still be there. He was told that he would not be in the best 22 and should look elsewhere (by the coaches and players!!! He wrote about this). He will be in the best 22 at Melbourne because the club has recruited poorly, including topping up with players who are not seen as AFL standard by other clubs.

Melbourne got into this mess by thinking that they were smarter at judging talent than other clubs and drafting poorly, maybe now they should start to pay attention to who other clubs say are not up to it.

That's right, Collingwood didn't think Dawes was AFL standard, that's why he's played 71 AFL games.

Same as Byrnes who played over 100 games with Geelong including two flags and Rodan who's managed over 170 AFL games.

Players who aren't AFL standard I think you'll find would normally be weeded out of a premiership winning team or have their careers ended before they got up to as many as 170 odd AFL games.

[Chook 14,556]

Plenty of ordinary players have been lucky enough to be part of a premiership team, it does not mean that he as an individual is a good player.

If Collingwood thought that Dawes was in their best 22 he would still be there. He was told that he would not be in the best 22 and should look elsewhere (by the coaches and players!!! He wrote about this). He will be in the best 22 at Melbourne because the club has recruited poorly, including topping up with players who are not seen as AFL standard by other clubs.

Melbourne got into this mess by thinking that they were smarter at judging talent than other clubs and drafting poorly, maybe now they should start to pay attention to who other clubs say are not up to it.

You are assuming (without even seeing Dawes play for us) that Collingwood never make any mistakes or that they might have different needs than us. They needed a forward who could play in the ruck. We don't. The role that Dawes will play here is therefore very different to the one he was asked to play at Collingwood.

Time will tell if we got value or not, but remember that he wasn't delisted or anything. He was simply traded because he was not needed. And let's be honest; when you have Travis Cloke at full forward, most other players aiming to play that position would not be needed either.

Edited April 24, 2013 by Chook

[Demon Stalwart 255]

When will people actually take some things at face Value ?

I enjoyed what Dawes had to say and he confirmed for me that the pre season training not only sounded

Good but was good at least in his opinion

I like the look of Dawes and I believe he will contribute to the team as a whole.

But like everything we will just have to wait and see, but we can at least give him the benefit of the doubt for now, at least till he has a chance to show us what he can do on the field when in the Red and the Blue

[rpfc 27,497]

You are being trolled.

School holidays.

[Rod Grinter Riot Squad 5,636]

Brisbane wanted to keep Clark, Collingwood players told Dawes that he would struggle to get a game and should look elsewhere. Huge difference.

The players told Dawes did they?

Wonder what the coaches do there...

[Yourenextdipper 19]

You are being trolled.

School holidays.

Not at troll, a paid up member who finished school in the 90's and predicted that Melbourne would finish bottom 2 when trade week was completed due to the terrible top up strategy.

The club traded for leadership, but were any of the players that Melbourne picked up in their previous clubs leadership groups?

[rpfc 27,497]

Not at troll, a paid up member who finished school in the 90's and predicted that Melbourne would finish bottom 2 when trade week was completed due to the terrible top up strategy.

The club traded for leadership, but were any of the players that Melbourne picked up in their previous clubs leadership groups?

Stick around for a while and I will interact.

Not many pick 'I hate Dawes' to start posting.

[PaulRB 5,968]

I thought it was a good article and courageous of Dawes to put his name to the assertion that the MFC playing group will come good on the field.

In any behaviour / performance change process having players make public statements of their intention or the intention of the group only deepens the commitment of the player to deliver.

He looks (and writes) like a man who has been challenged by the manner of him leaving Collingwood, to take his game and leadership to another level at Melbourne.

Looking forward to Dawes getting onto the G in Red and Blue.

[rjay 23,922]

In an off field capacity I am ecstatic to have him at the club. Now I'm looking forward to seeing what he can do on the field.

Hopefully emulates Clark circa 2012...

Yep, I think that says it pretty well. Handles himself well in the media but I'm hoping he can back it up on the ground.

He has a lot to prove though, a big personal challenge.

[dee-luded 2,958]

another good article that helps to understand whats going on inside.

its great to hear the players are excited with the changes, & how we're moving going to move ahead.

the leadership IMO is growing, & this will inturn help the the club build a harder culture.

# no passengers.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

more talk.. what else is he going to say?

I'll see Dawes playing well and Melbourne winning games before I commence any backslapping

[PaulRB 5,968]

Look forward to Dawes and Hogan lining up for Casey on the weekend. Glimpse of the future!?

No coincidence that this articles come out just as Dawes is able to hit the field again.

Edited April 24, 2013 by PaulRB

[Dr. Gonzo 22,486]

Can't believe no-one has raised the issue of the MFC not having a boot room yet!! No wonder this club can't win games, what an absolute disgrace!

[Gorgoroth 12,330]

I reckon Dawes would be still at Collingwood if Malthouse was.

[Satyriconhome 9,982]

Not at troll, a paid up member who finished school in the 90's and predicted that Melbourne would finish bottom 2 when trade week was completed due to the terrible top up strategy.

The club traded for leadership, but were any of the players that Melbourne picked up in their previous clubs leadership groups?

So you read the newspapers and decided that was MFC strategy, there are many different forms of leadership, it is leadership in how you prepare yourself, how you survive through adversity, Rodan although not in the AFL side, led from the front for the VFL side on Saturday, that side was full of young MFC players, invaluable. Perhaps with you only finishing school in the 90's adversity is perhaps a word you are not familiar with.

Also we drafted poorly?....we have had 2 guys in Viney and Matt Jones who have played all 4 games and Terlich who has played 3, come straight into the side, if we were winning, journalists would be drooling over them

I like what Chris Dawes wrote, and the other thing I like, we could have panicked and put him in the team before he was ready or fully fit, the coaching staff and obviously Chris decided not to, leadership, frustrating for him as it must have been

Edited April 24, 2013 by Satyriconhome

[Yourenextdipper 19]

Satyriconhome this forum would be much better off without you constantly sniping and insulting anyone that does not share your opinion. You are a broken record. I get it, you believe that the club can do no wrong and you are a supirior supporter to everyone else. Now either add something new to your posts or move on, I'm sick if reading the same post from you every two minutes.

[old dee 22,925]

Satyriconhome this forum would be much better off without you constantly sniping and insulting anyone that does not share your opinion. You are a broken record. I get it, you believe that the club can do no wrong and you are a supirior supporter to everyone else. Now either add something new to your posts or move on, I'm sick if reading the same post from you every two minutes.

You would wonder why we are not in the eight right now!

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

Can't believe no-one has raised the issue of the MFC not having a boot room yet!! No wonder this club can't win games, what an absolute disgrace!

down at the Lexus centre they have a boot room, sock room, jocks room, mouthgaurd room.. you have to tour the facility before training.. members' money well spent

[rjay 23,922]

You would wonder why we are not in the eight right now!

Now that's a whole other question 'old dee'.

[Satyriconhome 9,982]

Satyriconhome this forum would be much better off without you constantly sniping and insulting anyone that does not share your opinion. You are a broken record. I get it, you believe that the club can do no wrong and you are a supirior supporter to everyone else. Now either add something new to your posts or move on, I'm sick if reading the same post from you every two minutes.

Don't read them then precious, didn't say that, that's how you interpret it, just following WYL's example, what insult, it was a statement, I don't have a very high opinion of most people under the age of 35 these days, too much "Give me" "I Want" for me.

I do not believe the Club has got everything right, but Chris Dawes is one decision I think is, hence my post in this topic, difference between some and me, try to stay on topic

If posters must continually post, in my humble opinion, untruths, rumour, lies, rubbish, strange theories, then as a Public Forum I have a right to be able to answer them.

Don't post yourself if you can't handle it

[Satyriconhome 9,982]

down at the Lexus centre they have a boot room, sock room, jocks room, mouthgaurd room.. you have to tour the facility before training.. members' money well spent

But not enough car park allocation

[Sir Why You Little 34,574]

Don't read them then precious, didn't say that, that's how you interpret it, just following WYL's example, what insult, it was a statement, I don't have a very high opinion of most people under the age of 35 these days, too much "Give me" "I Want" for me.

I do not believe the Club has got everything right, but Chris Dawes is one decision I think is, hence my post in this topic, difference between some and me, try to stay on topic

If posters must continually post, in my humble opinion, untruths, rumour, lies, rubbish, strange theories, then as a Public Forum I have a right to be able to answer them.

Don't post yourself if you can't handle it

Must you mention my name in all your posts.

It is very tiresome.

[Satyriconhome 9,982]

Must you mention my name in all your posts.

It is very tiresome.

Just to make sure you are still reading them WYL, nice to see you are, and I miss Rangey, any comment on Dawes?