WELCOME TO THE MELBOURNE FOOTBALL CLUB - CHRIS DAWES

[olisik 4,060]

Which teams are getting value for their NQRs?

And who do you consider our NQRs capable of landing our targets?

I didn't say our NQR's could specifically land a target, I said that we should get value or currency for them.

Any of our NQR's should be capable of landing a late draft pick of anything which could be on-traded later as part of a package.

[beelzebub 23,370]

How are we able to offer/can they ask for our Moloney compensation pick? We don't even know what it is yet or if it will even be anything. That's a major drawback of this system.

And it's very much a part of why a lot of secondary deals are hanging in limbo.

The FA segment is way too long, AFL just trying To wring every last morsel of exposure during the off season doing no one any real favours .

[nutbean 8,838]

I may be going against the trend (although many here are happy to get Dawes).

I am a huge fan - his work ethic is something we sorely need. The cross on him this season is he wasnt taking marks like the seasons before but he chases, tackles, harrasses, presents, shepherds and block. A lot of good stuff that sometimes doesnt really hit the stat sheet. I will be happy nutbean when this deal is done.

[beelzebub 23,370]

Nut...his hand was still quite sore from accounts

[jnrmac 20,061]

Why don't we play Martin as First Ruck and put Jamar at FF?

[daisycutter 29,614]

Why don't we play Martin as First Ruck and put Jamar at FF?

[boydie 655]

Why don't we play Martin as First Ruck and put Jamar at FF?

Because he cant kick and when the ball hits the ground he's useless.

[rpfc 28,417]

Why don't we play Martin as First Ruck and put Jamar at FF?

I would say that because the are both NQR for the position.

Martin isn't big enough to compete againt the bigger rucks out there, and Jamar isn't a FF - he would just be a big lump who would sit there.

Having Dawes at FF, Pedersen at Back-up ruck/FP and Jamar in the ruck is far better than what we currently have.

[Jordie_tackles 354]

Because he cant kick and when the ball hits the ground he's useless.

Martin is far better than Jamar when the ball hits the deck

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

Is Pedersen big enough to ruck?

[Demons 32 235]

Is Pedersen big enough to ruck?

He can pinch hit, but that's about it.

[rpfc 28,417]

Is Pedersen big enough to ruck?

He can pinch hit, but that's about it.

I believe the thinking is that he is just a pinch hitter as you say D32, but that he is far more dangerous prospect in the forward line than Martin.

And that is the balnace you want when you have a ruckman like Jamar who will dominate time in the middle - all you need is a chop out. Martin needs 1st ruck; he is not a forward at all.

[GawnWithTheWind 604]

Have we had any mail today about discussions with Dawes?

I'd love for the club to get it out of the way so they can focus on a ray/pederson/others deal

[Jonesbag 487]

Have we had any mail today about discussions with Dawes?

I'd love for the club to get it out of the way so they can focus on a ray/pederson/others deal

I agree, I havent heard a peep either. Would love to get an update

[Damo 3,356]

Right now im just happy that Dawes selected MFC as the place he would prefer to go. If we pay with pick 20 I think its about right but believe there is more we have to give Collingwood. I dont even mind if we go with Gumby.

Whatever, last week when Dawes said he wanted to go to MFC was a boost.

Edited October 15, 2012 by Franky_31

[wisedog 352]

Considering we traded pick 12 for Mitch Clark, who had shown substantially more than Dawes, I feel pick 20 is as close to a FAIR deal as can be achieved given available draft picks. Perhaps if Lucas Cook hadn't been talked down so much in the media, he could have been thrown in as a sweetener.

We would have traded pick 4 for Wellingham and Dawes (reportedly). What's to stop Collingwood demanding pick 4 for Dawes and pick 17 (which they got for Wellingham)?

I've heard it said from Collingwood supporters that later picks are of no interest to them, as there isn't enough room on the list as it is. So from that perpective, I'm not sure why they would be interested in any of our players either.

It does seem the only thing that could hold up this trade is Collingwood pursuing pick 4, (perhaps with Dawes and pick 17 in return).

However, we all assume that Collingwood is playing hardball on this one, but it could be that we haven't even offered pick 20 yet.

[Allen Jakovich 516]

I would make Sylvia watch Ryan O'Keefe's grand final 3 times a week for the next 4 months. I would say that there's no reason you can't have O'Keefe's 2012 if you get fitter, more dedicated, and give 100% to every contest in every minute of every game. Don't do it for a quarter, or a half, but 120 minutes. Don't coast from contest to contest as you often do; and try and match O'Keefe's tackle count from 2102. O'Keefe averaged 6.5 tackles per game to Sylvia's 3.8. His desperation and physicality around stoppages and contested ball was significant.

Jones did a great job of having the type of year that Brad Sewell produces and there's no reason that Sylvia can't emulate O'Keefe.

When Colin Sylvia returned to the side in Round 5, he was coming back from a broken back. Do you think you could forgive him for not tackling with the same intensity?

From Rounds 14-23, he averaged 4.9 tackles a game, and 6 tackles a game from Rounds 14-19. I don't consider that coasting from contest to contest. That's not far off O'Keefe, and given his pre-season was ruined, that's a fantastic effort.

Give the bloke a break ffs.

[Straight Sets Simon 23,113]

The misleading thing about tacke numbers is that some players tackle when they miss a contest or going for the ball. Then there are those like Trengove and Sylvia who just wait outside packs to tackle.

[Hannibal 5,814]

When Colin Sylvia returned to the side in Round 5, he was coming back from a broken back. Do you think you could forgive him for not tackling with the same intensity?

From Rounds 14-23, he averaged 4.9 tackles a game, and 6 tackles a game from Rounds 14-19. I don't consider that coasting from contest to contest. That's not far off O'Keefe, and given his pre-season was ruined, that's a fantastic effort.

Give the bloke a break ffs.

"When Colin Sylvia returned to the side in Round 5, he was coming back from a broken back. Do you think you could forgive him for not tackling with the same intensity?"

No.

"From Rounds 14-23, he averaged 4.9 tackles a game, and 6 tackles a game from Rounds 14-19. I don't consider that coasting from contest to contest."

He had a pretty good 6 week period, but he can do far better. He's lazy. I watch him closely and he often "coasts". He could increase his output by at least 25%.

"That's not far off O'Keefe, and given his pre-season was ruined, that's a fantastic effort."

A small portion of his year was pretty good, but he's appallingly inconsistent and always has been. The 30 year old O'Keefe averaged 25 possessions, kicked 20 goals and had arguably his best ever year. Sylvia has the natural talent to emulate that. And no, Sylvia's entire preseason wasn't "ruined" at all. I won't be satisfied by two good months, I'll be satisfied by 22 games played at a very high standard. Nothing less.

"Give the bloke a break ffs."

I give no-one a break. I leave that for supporters like you.

[nutbean 8,838]

I give no-one a break. I leave that for supporters like you.

I mark Colin Sylvia harder than any other MFC footballer because with his god given talents he should be consistently a top 10 footballer in the AFL and a star and to date, besides the odd cameo confirming this, he has yet to break into the top 100.

[Lucifers Hero 39,779]

pies are being greedy...they want to eat all the pies

Yes, they do like to eat their own don't they!!!

[Forest Demon 4,681]

Collingwood are doing very well if they manage to get any more than pick 20 for Dawes, but if there are other clubs circling then I guess that determines the market more than what value people like us or people in the media think.

Skipped 1 page of this thread and all of a sudden it has turned into yet another Sylvia bashing threads. Surely all those hell bent on continually potting Colin can do it in one of the handful of threads they have already started this year for that exact purpose.

[markc 975]

on facebook now Trade Rumour: Chris Dawes to Melbourne. Pick 20 and Ricky Petterd to Collingwood.

[GrandOld 367]

Ricky

[Jonesbag 487]

20 and Petterd is rumoured, im ok with it. Petterd stank this year