Scully finishes 4th in Sheedy Medal

[Stigga 25]

WARD WINS INAUGURAL SHEEDY MEDAL

What a joke!

I can think if about a dozen players that had a better year than him.

[wattsup 470]

yea i was thinking the same thing when i read it, they are obviously trying to make themselves feel better

[stinga81 210]

Fixing the votes to justify the pay packet, has done SFA this year, we would have read about it otherwise.

[Moonshadow 16,609]

I was surprised he finished anything better than 4th last.

[Real Demon 232]

That's comedy!!!!

Had no impact on any GWS game I saw this year!

[Yossarian 1,808]

Should've given it to Israel Folau.

[pitmaster 3,156]

Justifies our draft compensation though.

[Real Demon 232]

Justifies our draft compensation though.

Not if you're a Bulldogs supporter..........Callan Ward won!

[Dee man 299]

In slightly unrelated news, the other player we lost during last year's trade period (Matthew Warnock) has been nominated for the AFL's MVP award (every club has to nominate their three best players): http://www.aflpa.com.au/news/post/afl_players_announce_2012_mvp_nominees

Having not seen too many GC or GWS games, I'm probably in no position to comment. But it looks as though Warnock has been of more value to the Suns than Scully has been to the Giants.

[gotzy9 33]

You mean $$$$$cully

[Hannibal 5,814]

When one considers that only 5 players played more games than him then it's feasible.

On a stats average he rated 11th, but it's subjective. And the following doesn't rate efficiency, hurt factor, etc. He's a fail.

http://finalsiren.com/Fixture.asp?SeasonID=2012&TeamID=21&Sort=AverageRating%20Desc#Player

[bush demon 1,928]

he came about 15o something in the herald sun super player points thing. Still wearing Melbourne jumper as mark of respect.

Edited September 6, 2012 by bush demon

[Whispering_Jack 28,118]

"Tom's fourth placing was the result of an anomaly caused as a result of the use of a system of weighting the judges' votes," said Giants' CEO David Matthews after the count.

He also refused to confirm or deny that the club's assistant director of recruiting based in Melbourne, Mr. Phil Scully was on the judging panel or that he devised the weighting system itself.

Heavy stuff indeed!

[DemonDave 1,078]

Do they really have to insist on typing GIANTS in capitals every time in this story? Dont tell me they do it all throughout their website (no I'm not going to look) as some kind of ironical branding. UGH.

[jnrmac 19,505]

Was obviously part of the signing. 'Must finish in the top 4 at the B& F

Their lack of credibility just got even bigger...

[Nascent 7,737]

Do they really have to insist on typing GIANTS in capitals every time in this story? Dont tell me they do it all throughout their website (no I'm not going to look) as some kind of ironical branding. UGH.

Pretty much every article I've read involving GWS and Gold Coast have had their moniker's spelt in capitals... no idea why and it's absolutely annoying to read.

[RalphiusMaximus 6,000]

he came about 15o something in the herald sun super player points thing. Still wearing Melbourne jumper as mark of respect.

Interesting to see the SC player ratings across the league. Grimes is our best at 41.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

Who cares.

[P-man 13,352]

That's hilarious. He was a tick above rubbish in every Giants game I saw bar one.

[baysidedave 246]

It's bollocks, he was useless this year, they are only trying to justify how much there paying him, they know he's a dud but don't want to admit it.

[ickey_11 145]

Curious how Scully beat Giles? Giles has had an excellent year for a one out rookie ruckman.

Though looking at the 6-10 positions, they all had crap years so I would could only argue about one place; we are talking about the bottom team here.

[Chook 14,701]

In light of Scully's stellar performance at his new club, I propose that the AFL retroactively compensate Melbourne by awarding them an additional first round pick. I'm sure you'll agree this is more than fair.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

WARD WINS INAUGURAL SHEEDY MEDAL

What a joke!

I can think if about a dozen players that had a better year than him.

Callan Ward has been very good all year in a crap team. He was a shoo in

When one considers that only 5 players played more games than him then it's feasible.

On a stats average he rated 11th, but it's subjective. And the following doesn't rate efficiency, hurt factor, etc. He's a fail.

http://finalsiren.co...ing Desc#Player

An epic one at this stage.

MFC have dodged a bullet with the 2 PPs. Very lucky.

[Stigga 25]

Callan Ward has been very good all year in a crap team. He was a shoo in

.

Giles

Treolar

Coniglio

Shiel

Palmer

Darley

Bugg

Devon Smith

Mohr

Cornes

Power

Phil Davis

How these blokes finished behind Scully...

[Guest KingDingAling]

Not if you're a Bulldogs supporter..........Callan Ward won!

Poor Bullies!

Ward is elite already!

Scully isn't Wards bootlace, we got great compo in comparison to the Bullies.