Demonland Player of the Year

[Demonland 66,532]

Please place your votes -

6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1 ...

[Jerry Lundergard 392]

6. Bate

5. Frawley

4. Trengove

3. Garland

2. Dunn

1. Scully

[Trisul 649]

4 Bate

3 Dunn

2 Jamar

1 Garland

[Bring-Back-Powell 13,419]

Fun to give votes this week...........not!

6) Bate

5) Scully

Anyone now, nobody deserves votes

4) Bruce

3) Frawley

2) Dunn

1) Trengove

Edited June 27, 2010 by Bring-Back-Powell

[joeboy 2,872]

6 - Bate

5 - Frawley

4 - Bruce

3 - Jones

2 - Trengove

1 - Scully

[Mono 454]

6 - Bate

5 - Frawley

4 - Bruce

3 - Scully

2 - Trengove

1 - Green

[titan_uranus 22,787]

Why the Dunn love? Don't get that.

6- Bate

5- Frawley

4- Scully

3- Grimes

2- Garland

1- Watts

[Jerry Lundergard 392]

Why the Dunn love? Don't get that.

6- Bate

5- Frawley

4- Scully

3- Grimes

2- Garland

1- Watts

Watts was better was he?

[PeterJames 46]

Someone gave watts votes?

oh why bother..

[Bring-Back-Powell 13,419]

Watts was better was he?

Agree, at least Dunn kicked 2 goals and troubled their defenders just a little.

[Jaded No More 59,151]

6- Bate

5- Scully

4- McKenzie

3- Frawley

2- Garland

1- Grimes

Our midfield performance made me sick today. At least Scully and McKenzie showed some fight!

[Nasher 33,166]

6- Bate

5- Scully

4- McKenzie

3- Frawley

2- Garland

1- Grimes

Our midfield performance made me sick today. At least Scully and McKenzie showed some fight!

I can't be buggered voting today, because coming up with anyone after Bate and Frawley is too hard.

Interesting you gave JG a vote though. I love the boy to death like as much as the rest, but I thought he was our WOG today. He just torched it so many times, it was very frustrating. JT wasn't too far behind in this regard.

FWIW I thought Dunn was reasonable today and I'd probably have him in my 6 somewhere.

[Jaded No More 59,151]

I can't be buggered voting today, because coming up with anyone after Bate and Frawley is too hard.

Interesting you gave JG a vote though. I love the boy to death like as much as the rest, but I thought he was our WOG today. He just torched it so many times, it was very frustrating. JT wasn't too far behind in this regard.

I gave him a vote for putting his body on the line time and time again and actually having a go.

Finding 6 players who deserved votes though was a struggle. It was a toss up between him and Dunn, but Dunn has so many brainfarts each week that I can't bring myself to reward him. He makes my blood boil after 6 years in the system.

[Deevout 449]

6: Bate

5: .....

4: .....

3: Frawley

2: Trengove

1: Wooden Spoon on that effort. :S

[gOLLy 401]

1.Garland

2.MacDonald

3.Bate

4.Bruce (First half)

5.Grimes

5.Dunn

[Red Sox 2]

6 - Bate..obvious

5 - Frawley...another quality scalp

4 - Garland....played well, especially early when most slept

3 - Trengove.....could've finished his work a little more efficiently but was in and amongst it

2 - Scully....same as JT really

1 - Bruce....tried hard

And to all the Watts bashers....I thought he was far from the worst. Yes we saw the soles of his shoes far too often but wasn't alone there. He was up and about a bit more but Gerard Healy probably summed him up well by saying he need to show a bit more urgency.

[The Great One 99 125]

6. M.Bate

5. T.Scully

4. J.MacDonald

3. J.McKenzie

2. J.Frawley

1. J.Trengove

Very hard to give a vote from a weak display. Only leaned towards the younger boys due to their excuse of being young.

Dissapointing day.

[MelbournePassion 7]

6- Matthew Bate

5- Jack Grimes

4- Cameron Bruce

3- Tom Scully

2- Brad Green

1- Jack Trengove

Very disappointing. We MUST start well against St.Kilda next week. I don't care if St.Kilda are the form team of the competition. We got 22 players out there and so do they. We got to be the in the game from start to finish, no excuses.

CARN THE DEES.

[Eth 4]

6 - Matthew Bate

5 - James Frawley

4 - Brad Green

3 - Tom Scully

2 - Jack Trengove

1 - Cam Bruce

[titan_uranus 22,787]

Watts was better was he?

Someone gave watts votes?

oh why bother..

I saw improvement in him. And I saw more effort from him than from plenty of other players. It wasn't a brilliant performance, hardly even a good one, but I thought he at least showed something compared to previous efforts.

Agree, at least Dunn kicked 2 goals and troubled their defenders just a little.

To me that's overselling Dunn immensely. He was meant to do a defensive job on Johncock, but old Stiffy had a good game.

[Red Sox 2]

Agree that Johncock got away from Dunn too much and the points on the day go to stiffy but Dunn was not too bad on the very few occasions we got the ball into our 50 and had we got even close to matching clearances/stoppages that we should have then Dunn could have exploited this area more. He just didn't really get the delivery required to exploit him.

Extra credit to Matty Bate on his game due to this fact. Super effort Bater.

[deeflog 679]

6. Bate

5. Frawley

4. Dunn

3. Bruce

2. Scully

1. Green

[Nasher 33,166]

He was meant to do a defensive job on Johncock, but old Stiffy had a good game.

You state this as if it's a given. How do you know his role was supposed to be defensive?

[Demon Tragic 0]

6. Bate

5. Frawley

4. Dunn

3. Trengove

2. Jamar

1. Moloney

[Deeoldfart 7,820]

6. Bate

5. Frawley

4. Dunn

3. Grimes

2. Garland

1. Scully

Oh, the sheer agony selecting the best of a pitiful lot!