Players with best disposal

[CHAMP 347]

Over at Big Footy there's a thread entitled "Player with the best disposal on your side". I trawled through 4 pages and 57 posts and there was not a single Melbourne post. If you think about it this is fair enough. With Trav off to Brissy there really isn't a stand-out any more. Yze and Green historically might have got a guernsey but not these days. It's a sad indictment really. Seems most clubs can raise arguments for two or three but in our case any nomination would be fanciful. Maybe a couple of the new blokes will make a name for themself.

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,829]

Cameron Bruce's kicking, lock the thread....

[mo64 5,874]

Over at Big Footy there's a thread entitled "Player with the best disposal on your side". I trawled through 4 pages and 57 posts and there was not a single Melbourne post. If you think about it this is fair enough. With Trav off to Brissy there really isn't a stand-out any more. Yze and Green historically might have got a guernsey but not these days. It's a sad indictment really. Seems most clubs can raise arguments for two or three but in our case any nomination would be fanciful. Maybe a couple of the new blokes will make a name for themself.

You make a good point CHAMP. There really isn't anyone that stands out, and that included TJ when he was there. For mine, the player with the best execution and decision making when it comes to disposal is Jared Rivers. He may have an awkward kicking style, but it's effective. Next would be Brock McLean, and in his short career, Ricky Petterd.

[dee3 0]

Simple, we dont have one... Brad Green maybe at his best, he weights the bakll nicely.. Tj was it, but he did turn it over alot.. it's easier to name who is not...

[Bring-Back-Powell 14,829]

McLean, Davey and Sylvia strike me as players with clean disposal.

Brad Green still showed glimpes of his lethal left foot with beautiful set shot goal on the HFF flank V Geelong. I still hold hope that Green will return to his best this year.

Adem Yze was awesome in the early 2000's on the wing. How many goals did he set up from the members wing at the G'

I have a funny feeling we could be singing Addam Maric's praises in the future. Doesn't he hold the record for the most accurate shots for goal in the TAC Cup?

[CHAMP 347]

You make a good point CHAMP. There really isn't anyone that stands out, and that included TJ when he was there. For mine, the player with the best execution and decision making when it comes to disposal is Jared Rivers. He may have an awkward kicking style, but it's effective. Next would be Brock McLean, and in his short career, Ricky Petterd.

Perhaps it is time to introduce the tennis ball drills that Jared did as a youngster in SA to bring his kicking up to scratch.

[old55 23,573]

Wheatley. There's hardly a better kick in the league now Buckley has retired.

We've plenty who can kick - McLean is under-rated, Dunn has skill, Sylvia's OK, CJ and PJ are both good kicks, Bell is very good. Davey can kick. Morton and Maric are meant to be sensational kicks. I think we're on the positive side in the kicking skills area.

I think Yze, Green and White are over-rated and Bruce is truly horrible.

[CHAMP 347]

Simple, we dont have one... Brad Green maybe at his best, he weights the bakll nicely.. Tj was it, but he did turn it over alot.. it's easier to name who is not...

Exactly, we'd rank quite well on the scale of "most butchers" (even with Godders and Ward off the list).

[IvanBartul13 2,564]

Maric would be the best kick at the club. Jeff White is probably under-estimated in this area technically.

[CHAMP 347]

Wheatley. There's hardly a better kick in the league now Buckley has retired.

We've plenty who can kick - McLean is under-rated, Dunn has skill, Sylvia's OK, CJ and PJ are both good kicks, Bell is very good. Davey can kick. Morton and Maric are meant to be sensational kicks. I think we're on the positive side in the kicking skills area.

I think Yze, Green and White are over-rated and Bruce is truly horrible.

We're looking for someone who can hit a team-mate on the chest from 35 off one step (and he's gone).

[Wrecker45 3,378]

Whelan rarely misses a target by hand or foot, the only problem is his body seems to be packing up on him.

[mo64 5,874]

We're looking for someone who can hit a team-mate on the chest from 35 off one step (and he's gone).

I'm assuming you're talking about TJ. His kick off one step annoyed the crap out of me. It's effectiveness was overrated. Looked great when it hit a target. Put his poor teammate under pressure when it didn't.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

I'm assuming you're talking about TJ. His kick off one step annoyed the crap out of me. It's effectiveness was overrated. Looked great when it hit a target. Put his poor teammate under pressure when it didn't.

Agreed. He could just as easily hit his teammate's opponent. Hit and miss but more miss was creeping into his game.

[JACKATTACK 17]

It seems that we have traded in our skillfull and soft list with a tough and skilless one. Hopefully Morton can correc this somewhat.

[Bay Riffin 1,474]

Whelan very good, Davey excellent, Mclean very good, White good Sylvia very good.

We are not that bad by foot you know.

confidence is a wonderful thing.

richmond are considered one of the worst but if watched that infamous game last year when they beat us, their foot skills were the best I had seen all year, bar maybe Geelong.

[jacey 333]

Wheatley. There's hardly a better kick in the league now Buckley has retired.

My votes with Wheatley too. Penetrating and usually to his team mate's advantage.

It'll be interesting where Wheatley fits in with DB team and if he's in the best DB 22, it might help explain why he went to China.

I really hope he has a great year.

[Bleeds_Red_&_Blue 172]

at least having no players with a high quantity of disposals shows that we dont solely depend on anyone .. look at carlton , theyre putting their whole seasons outcome and thensome on Judd .. if he doesnt get 35 possies a game there will be an extra utencil added in carltons kitchen again this year

[Rampaging Demons 1]

still think yze would be our best kick....

johnstone, agree with the above - bursting both team mates and opponents nipples!

our kicking skills are poor - the number of times a leading forward would get delivery at their feet, well...

i just hope that Bailey is able to remedy this!!

[Little Goffy 14,545]

Ok. This one will surprise some but then we'll all go, 'oh, yeah, of course...'

Matthew Whelan!

Consistently 80% plus disposal efficiency, which places him in Champion Data's elite category - but the important part is that he does this while almost continuously under pressure given his usual role of close checking in defence.

Priceless, underrated player. He's James McDonald rebuilt for back-pocket / small defender. Can't wait to have him back. Fingers crossed.

[Anders 14]

Brad Green is probably our safest user. TJ had the potential to be sublime but last year was terrible.

[Pates 9,660]

Brad Green is probably our safest user. TJ had the potential to be sublime but last year was terrible.

TJ could be both damaging to his opposition and to his team, his type of game ensured that. It's high risk, low, and penetrating. If he saw a chance in the centre and he had a 10cm target to hit he'd go for it, often of one step. Best disposal, but potentially damaging.

But TJ has moved on and so should we, therefor my nominations would be Whelan and McLean. I've rarely seen these two turn it over by foot.

[Mondê 525]

Johnstone's disposal was hugely overrated. The notion that he was the best kick in the team lead him to be designated the kicking in duties in which I can count dozens of occassions where he turned it over trying to be TOO precise and sometimes costing us goals. Forward of the centre he had the potential to be damaging but once again, he didn't do it often enough. Lazy player.

The best kick in the team for mine is easily Davey, without having seen the new kids play I can't see any other regular in the 22 that has the ability of Davey to hit targets.

[Deemented 0]

Wheatley for me. If he doesn't hit the target he atleast puts it to our our players advantage and not the opposition. TJ just kicked it either at us or them without thinking "if I miss I should miss left" or wherever our player was.

[Yze_Magic 3]

Cameron Bruce

LOL

[Damo 3,356]

Just going on Point Kick outs, which in conjunction with kicking for goal, is the best method to work out who has best disposal;

I would say Yze then Davey then Neitz then Green.

If you look at our kicking out disasters Whelan and Wheatley were so bad, that often TJ had to amble from the centre to kick out.

I reckon if Wheatley kicked long to the wings, he would have been a much better option but most of his (bad) kicks come from going short to the pocket.

He is more accurate kicking longer distances than short in my opinion. he has a talent that is rarely used but highly rated by supporters.