Deemented

Cheney is a small, T Mc is a tall, McNamara has looked alright at times at Sandy.

I agree he was one of our best for 3 quaters. Having a shot twice from the same spot when someone was on at the top of the goal square ruined everything he did in the first three quaters. He needs to be dropped to send a message to him and everyone else. Teams win. Not 22 players playing for themselves.

Heard Baily or someone at the club say he wouldnt play this year because they wanted him to concentrate on school. Yze should be dropped for anyone. I was in the punt rd pocket in the last quater, he sould have kicked to the top of the square twice. Too selfish.

The cats are on at $34 as well.

1 adult 3 children not AFL just club members

Wheatley for me. If he doesn't hit the target he atleast puts it to our our players advantage and not the opposition. TJ just kicked it either at us or them without thinking "if I miss I should miss left" or wherever our player was.

Good start for TJ at brissie. Good luck to him.

J Stynes! I think PJ can come good. I remember watching him in a forward pocket vs the filth QB and he con move pretty well I was suprised how quick he was. When we lose JW and he gets more time in the middle I think he can be a good ruckman, he definitely has the right shape to push the lighter ruckmen out of the way and stand his ground against the bigger men around the ground. Why would we try someone new who's not going to be great. Jamar can go and we should draft someone young to back up PJ.

Swans won a flag without a traditional spine. We maybe only have Newton as a KPP, can't count on Neitz or White, Garland might come good as CHB. I think to get a good spine we have to do a full rebuild with three years at th bottom plus priority picks and get them all in that three year period but there are no garuantees with KPP you would almost need to get two for each position to make sure you got a good spine.

I don't understand how they can leave out players that had one great year for last years team on the proviso that they have to back up one good year with another the next to make AA. How many Geelong players had a good year last year. They didn't even play finals. Lucas was stiff. How can you kick 7 in a quater of footy and miss out for S Johnson?

Judd is, if not the best all round footballer going round he would have to be top 3. Champions lift the players around them, how much better are we when Neita is on the ground. Alot of the younger Melbourne players inspire their teamates but none consistently. IMO Judd is worth any 2 players on our list and a draft pick (hopefully not 4 but 20) as his ability to perform when it counts is unquestionable. Norm Smith in a losing GF side. Having said that I think the eagles will make him an offer he can't refuse.