6 minutes ago, Gawndy the Great said:

No true small forward! Kozzy better than Moore everyday of the week. 

I disagree. Love Kozzie but Moore has kicked one less goal and has Kozzie covered in just about every other stat

Two mids on the half forward flank. Yeah Heeney does kick goals but come on.

I - Whitfield, Neale, Treloar, Butters

 

Happy for Treloar, he's been huge this year 

Bont Captain, Cripps VC

Best thing about the awards tonight is how little I heard about Daicos. Good job Howie. 

Max now one of only 10 players picked 7+ times

Edited August 29, 20241 yr by Mickey

How on earth does Zorko and Ryan get AA honours. Selectors have no idea 

Fantastic Max! A bit of sunshine in our current dark days. Best ruck of all time 

GAWN HAS TO BE CONSIDERED AS ONE OF THE GREATEST RUCKMAN TO HAVE EVER PLAYED THE GAME. 

CERTAINLY IS MELBOURNE’S GREATEST RUCKMAN 

A reminder that not everything about this club sucks right now. 

The greatest ruck the game has ever seen. 

Otherwise, can’t decide what’s more egregiously wrong:

- Ryan and McGovern both selected over Andrews

- Waterman selected over Curnow and Stengle

10 minutes ago, spirit of norm smith said:

GAWN HAS TO BE CONSIDERED AS ONE OF THE GREATEST RUCKMAN TO HAVE EVER PLAYED THE GAME. 

CERTAINLY IS MELBOURNE’S GREATEST RUCKMAN 

No. He is the greatest.  Simon Madden next but did more work as a forward.  As a pure ruckman Max has no peer.

Absolute legend and arguably the best player in the comp over the past 5 years. Looking forward to his next 3 - 4 years.

Congrats to big Jesse and turning his career around.

Really do miss him.

Superb Max ty.

In such illustrious company now with 7.

Very few can claim that mantle.

We will be able to tell our grandkids that we were privileged to watch the Great Max Gawn play. What a legend.

34 minutes ago, titan_uranus said:

Otherwise, can’t decide what’s more egregiously wrong:

- Ryan and McGovern both selected over Andrews

- Waterman selected over Curnow and Stengle

Waterman over Curnow is ridiculous. 

I love Max. I’ve never appreciated him more than I do right now.

Massive congratulations - I desperately want him to get a 9th and another flag, he'll be a AFL legend after that. That's where I think he sits. ( I think he is already, just he'll need those stats to get through the bias against anything Melbourne).

Instead of floating stupid ideas like Wildcard round why doesn't an AA 2nd team even come close to getting a go?

8 hours ago, Oxdee said:

How on earth does Zorko and Ryan get AA honours. Selectors have no idea 

The Dorko selection baffles me?? 

First reaction to that team - gee the standard of this comp has slipped a few notches. 

I just noticed Zorko was selected 🤢🤢🤢 wtf!?

9 hours ago, Bates Mate said:

Waterman over Curnow is ridiculous. 

Not really.

Curnow is over rated and yet to really prove himself - when it counts. Good player, thats all.