On 06/09/2023 at 06:59, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Noble dropped for Collingwood after 83 straight games.

Hopefully the Pie players are rattled by this, a permanent fixture getting dropped.

Just saying this to a friend.. hopefully pies players are nervous about their spots and over do it 

There is some good analysis about this game. The following isn't. Don't blame me if you want your five minutes back after reading it. You have been warned. 

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/we-asked-an-ai-bot-to-predict-every-game-of-this-year-s-afl-final-series-20230905-p5e24u.html?fbclid=IwAR2z_f9OgcLEg8H_9v_5i8SxdPQUtQHqWhWk8W7ZYqQwbs95zPwUpSlRzBI

On a stats level too basic to be mentioned in the Stats thread:

Since round 10 (21 May) Collingwood have played 4 games only against teams in the finals.  They had a good 2 point win against Port in Adelaide and have lost to Melbourne, Carlton and the Lions.

Over the same time frame, Melbourne have played seven games against each of the fnalists (excepting Port) including Carlton twice and have only lost to GWS (somehow) and the conttroversial loss to Carlton.

I reckon that is pretty good form coming into the finals.

 

 

  On 06/09/2023 at 06:59, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Noble dropped for Collingwood after 83 straight games.

Hopefully the Pie players are rattled by this, a permanent fixture getting dropped.

 

If Pie's side is out  where is ours?

That's quite a vigil they got there. 

Really hope it doesn't bind them together. 

  On 06/09/2023 at 07:09, Deebauched said:

If Pie's side is out  where is ours?

 Both Not out till 615pm

  On 06/09/2023 at 07:09, Deebauched said:

If Pie's side is out  where is ours?

was a leak

both side out at 6:25

Those in the media and general folks thinking the Pies will win are think back to 6 weeks ago when they were untouchable. at that stage they were by far the best team in it

can they flick the switch? who knows. but it’s bloody hard to change form and switch on from a low base

this is why i’m quietly confident whilst crapping my dacks at the same time

  On 06/09/2023 at 07:02, DubDee said:

Noble dropped for who?

changing up their backline at this stage is a good sign for us

Moore, Murphy and McReery coming in one would assume. 

  On 06/09/2023 at 02:29, DubDee said:

My App says 22oC and Sunny

Shorts and thongs weather!

Melbourne, Florida?

  On 06/09/2023 at 06:49, Mel Bourne said:

In the words of Iggy Pop “gimme danger”. 

But it’s been more common over the last few years, as digital consoles have made it easier. I was moved to have a look at some of the previous performances and as well as PK, Sting, Vance Joy and the The Living End all played live. A couple of their songs used “track” - a phantom keyboard or string part here and there, but that would be the case with their usual live shows too. 

As for Kiss, they’ll certainly have some modern augmentation, as they’ve been leaning on it more and more in recent years. 
 

The oscillation between “game chat” and “KISS chat” on this thread has been very funny. It’s helped the nerves! 

Me and Iggy pop are built differently. I feel like you are asking to sound terrible by going down the live route. No one represents themselves as well as possible in these situations playing live and it’s through no fault of their own. You get a bit of wind and you are doomed. Which is only one of a million ways it can fall apart. I blame the afl. Like I do with most things.

This two weeks has been horrible. I hate the bye and I hate Collingwood more. I feel like I’m pacing around unable to concentrate on anything. Losing this game would hurt more than most to state the bleeding obvious. I am living with a high level of underlying anxiety for the next month it seems. Sometimes I miss sucking as a football team. No expectations had its perks. Then I think how much it will suck when I no longer get to watch max, Clarry, trac, Gus, may etc and I quickly snap out of it.

  On 06/09/2023 at 00:48, monoccular said:

Pity the AFL are so tight that, like the score review system, they won’t expend a few dollars to provide roaming mikes to the questioners at these press conferences.  I guess directors’ bonuses and overseas junkets are a higher priority.

The types of questions asked can be highly specific, leading thoughts and matters not considered. It is a great shame that in the coaches' responses, one has to interpret what the original question might have been - because you cannot hear the question in full, in part and sometimes, not hear it at all. 

  On 06/09/2023 at 06:49, Mel Bourne said:

In the words of Iggy Pop “gimme danger”. 

But it’s been more common over the last few years, as digital consoles have made it easier. I was moved to have a look at some of the previous performances and as well as PK, Sting, Vance Joy and the The Living End all played live. A couple of their songs used “track” - a phantom keyboard or string part here and there, but that would be the case with their usual live shows too. 

As for Kiss, they’ll certainly have some modern augmentation, as they’ve been leaning on it more and more in recent years. 
 

The oscillation between “game chat” and “KISS chat” on this thread has been very funny. It’s helped the nerves! 

You forgot the best in the past few years...Lionel Richie

  On 06/09/2023 at 07:07, Demonland said:

 

So we can confirm that there is nothing Noble about Collingwood? 

Sheesh brutal call on Noble.

He's usually the one setting them up off half back with his speed and kicking.

Noble will be back next week versus the Blues you’d imagine

Edited September 6, 20231 yr by DubDee

  On 06/09/2023 at 07:41, dazzledavey36 said:

Sheesh brutal call on Noble.

He's usually the one setting them up off half back with his speed and kicking.

100% correct. No Daicos and Noble out limits their run and carry capabilities and precision kicking. Our good luck I say.

  On 06/09/2023 at 07:36, von said:

This two weeks has been horrible. I hate the bye and I hate Collingwood more. I feel like I’m pacing around unable to concentrate on anything. Losing this game would hurt more than most to state the bleeding obviou

I know the feeling. The thought of losing and having to see all their sneering toothless grins after the game is making me sick. What's worse is that i am staying the night at a mates house who is a Collingwood supporter, and he is also going to the game.  Fortunately we have an unspoken gentlemen's agreement not to hang it on each other after a game. His wife, who doesn't follow footy at all, is not so discreet. It won't be pretty.

I'm actually stumped with the Noble omission. This would have been the perfect game and conditions for him.

Yeah dunno

My guess:

Tmac in.

Smith in the starting 22.

Laurie on the bench

 

The other possibility i can see is hibberd comes in for turner.

Or perhaps Salem given he had not found his best form.

That said I really can't see salo not being selected.

  On 06/09/2023 at 07:57, He de mon said:

I know the feeling. The thought of losing and having to see all their sneering toothless grins after the game is making me sick. What's worse is that i am staying the night at a mates house who is a Collingwood supporter, and he is also going to the game.  Fortunately we have an unspoken gentlemen's agreement not to hang it on each other after a game. His wife, who doesn't follow footy at all, is not so discreet. It won't be pretty.

Probably better off staying in a cheap motel for the night.

  On 06/09/2023 at 08:04, Deebauched said:

Probably better off staying in a cheap motel for the night.

Yeah, but we couldn't get someone to look after the dogs, and his house is dog friendly. It will be sweet if we win though.

  On 06/09/2023 at 08:02, binman said:

My guess:

Tmac in.

Smith in the starting 22.

Laurie on the bench

 

The other possibility i can see is hibberd comes in for turner.

Or perhaps Salem given he had not found his best form.

That said I really can't see salo not being selected.

After his first quarter in 2021 I decree that Salem should never be dropped. 

The full back was a walking cripple if I remember correctly .

They would likely have confronted a mountain too high to climb without Salo.

He stays