15 minutes ago, Pates said:

This will probably be an unpopular thought but I actually didn't think Tomlinson played a bad game, and I don't think it's a coincidence that Lever had one of his best games for the year with him in. McKay is a bloody good footballer and was getting regular (and quite often unpressured) service, getting hands on the ball hasn't been his problem it's the finishing that's been his main issue. I personally think Tommo stays, as does Smith.

Unless there are absolute gun footballers that are direct replacements (say a Petty or Oliver) I say given them a body of games to prove their worth to the team. Our backline functions better with to key pillars complimenting the Lever interceptor. And JVR and Smith seemed to have space from each other which is actually what Roo needs, space to have his opponent one on one. I would expect more from Smith going forward, but giving him one game and dropping is going to do nothing for him or the team.

Bowser for Hibberd
Sparrow for for Oliver (Sparrow Sub)

Can’t see Sparrow getting dropped.  Most pressure acts vs Freo and second most vs Carlton. I reckon his suspension cost us 4 points against Port. 

Hibberd for Bowey

Oliver for ANB - done very little the last few weeks, and definitely needs to keep working on this skills. 

Clarrie didn’t train today. Any idea why?

54 minutes ago, DeeSpencer said:

Harmes was the sub, doesn’t count 

It will be Bowey and Tomlinson for Oliver and Hibberd.

Gus goes back, plays as an interceptor. Hibberd is the best possible match up for Ash Johnson.

Lever has to play on a tall, be it Cox or Mihocek but he would’ve had to do that anyway.

Spare me the Lever has to be the third tall. He still is. Hibberd > Tomlinson unless the opposition has 2 gun big talls like Carlton.

Tomlinson stays. 7 cm taller than hibberd. No cooincidence imo May and Lever had best game of the seadon with 2021 looking defence.

Hibberd in for Bowey.  Maybe takes Elliot

32 minutes ago, Fat Tony said:

I think we’re playing one too many midgets in the forward line. With Chandler, Spargo, and Pickett, we are getting out marked a few times per match.

With Hibberd and Oliver coming back in this week, I wonder if one of the outs will be Chandler or Spargo. Tomlinson is also possible. 

That's what I would think too. Although on form, you could also throw Pickett into that conversation as well

3 minutes ago, bobby1554 said:

That's what I would think too. Although on form, you could also throw Pickett into that conversation as well

one of the reasons fcfc struggled to get any ball movement going on friday night was because of the defensive work that he did

i know he doesn't get it much, but boy does his defensive efforts count for a lot

A little mid season reminder...

form ≠ possessions

Oliver definite if fit, and probably Hibberd, even though without Bowey our backs will be slower.

People should not expect Kossie to be everywhere.

There could be a surprise in for us if weather fine. Maybe even in the middle.

Like some others, not too fazed about this game, and i would not be surprised to see different styles of delivery into the forward line, quite early in the piece..

 

1 hour ago, Pates said:

This will probably be an unpopular thought but I actually didn't think Tomlinson played a bad game, and I don't think it's a coincidence that Lever had one of his best games for the year with him in. McKay is a bloody good footballer and was getting regular (and quite often unpressured) service, getting hands on the ball hasn't been his problem it's the finishing that's been his main issue. I personally think Tommo stays, as does Smith.

 

It's not out of the realms of possibility that Tomlinson stays in the side for the rest of the year as a defender to support the brilliant May/Lever combo (or is it Lever/May!)

This is on the proviso that Petty returns to the forward line and BBB is never seen again.

 

 

22 minutes ago, bobby1554 said:

That's what I would think too. Although on form, you could also throw Pickett into that conversation as well

Those criticising Pickett need to look at the fact he averages 1.9 goals a game and is equal second with goal assists. Sure he's not smashing it but he works really hard, is clever, makes the opposition nervous and can cut you to ribbons at any moment. I'm not sure what people expect from him but the chance of him getting dropped is less than zero. 

 

58 minutes ago, Dee*ceiving said:

Out Bowey and Harmes (suspended)

Chandler sub?

Harmes wasn’t in the 22. 

you’d drop Chandler? who would replace his run and chase up fwd?

Happy with Chandler in the team for a bit longer, 

Still ticking over score involvements but agree he is having a patch where he needs to convert more.

Kept a close eye on him in the Carlton game, was getting into great positions and often ignored.

Either way, leads to the question, Does a small forward work as the sub?

1 hour ago, DeeSpencer said:

Harmes was the sub, doesn’t count 

It will be Bowey and Tomlinson for Oliver and Hibberd.

Gus goes back, plays as an interceptor. Hibberd is the best possible match up for Ash Johnson.

Lever has to play on a tall, be it Cox or Mihocek but he would’ve had to do that anyway.

Spare me the Lever has to be the third tall. He still is. Hibberd > Tomlinson unless the opposition has 2 gun big talls like Carlton.

Agree. sounds like the most likely scenario.

Chandler has a big game coming soon, might bag hatful. 

Pies pleaded guilty "De Goey and asked for only three weeks. AFL want a minimum of four.

I'm happy if he only gets the one.

Edited June 6, 20232 yr by YearOfTheDees

Every week there are predictions of omitting Spargo, ANB or Sparrow. Every second week Pickett gets thrown in.
 

Yet, in the last three years there have been two more earthquakes in Melbourne than omissions of any of the above. 

3 minutes ago, speed demon said:

Every week there are predictions of omitting Spargo, ANB or Sparrow. Every second week Pickett gets thrown in.
 

Yet, in the last three years there have been two more earthquakes in Melbourne than omissions of any of the above. 

Some people watch football and some just look at the stats on a Monday morning.

21 minutes ago, speed demon said:

Every week there are predictions of omitting Spargo, ANB or Sparrow. Every second week Pickett gets thrown in.
 

Yet, in the last three years there have been two more earthquakes in Melbourne than omissions of any of the above. 

And guess what happened the last time there was an earthquake in Vic? Before the recent one a couple of weeks ago.

Edited June 6, 20232 yr by Dee Zephyr

3 ganes for De Goey.

Pretty light 

People were talking 5 and 6 for Pickett and DeFloggys was twice as bad. The Tribunal CSAFD. Apologies to those offended in advance. 

Edited June 6, 20232 yr by 4_Kent_Watts

3 minutes ago, layzie said:

3 ganes for De Goey.

Pretty light 

You wonder how De Goey gets 3, for concussing his victim, putting him out of that game and the next and Kozzie gets 2 for no injury at all to his victim and he jumps up smiling and pats Kozzie on the bum.

How is it only one more for De Goey in those circumstances?

Surely it’s only 1 for Kozzie, or 4 at least for De Goey.

No wonder the system is a farcical disaster.

13 minutes ago, layzie said:

3 ganes for De Goey.

Pretty light 

Interesting ti see if the AFL ask them to rethink it

1 hour ago, Roost it far said:

Those criticising Pickett need to look at the fact he averages 1.9 goals a game and is equal second with goal assists. Sure he's not smashing it but he works really hard, is clever, makes the opposition nervous and can cut you to ribbons at any moment. I'm not sure what people expect from him but the chance of him getting dropped is less than zero. 

Not criticising Pickett, however he has had only 6 disposals in 2 of the last 3 games. Yeah, sure, he has the type of game that can cut you to ribbons, however it doesn’t happen that often. All I am saying is that if the finger is being pointed at Spargo, ANB and Chandler, then Pickett needs the heat on him as well.

12 minutes ago, bobby1554 said:

Not criticising Pickett, however he has had only 6 disposals in 2 of the last 3 games. Yeah, sure, he has the type of game that can cut you to ribbons, however it doesn’t happen that often. All I am saying is that if the finger is being pointed at Spargo, ANB and Chandler, then Pickett needs the heat on him as well.

Personally I think it’s only ANB that has dropped off