TEAMS: SF vs Brisbane

[DubDee 25,806]

Strong EMGs in

Wouldn't mind a late change of Bedford in for Spargo.  We need speed and pressure in the fwd 50

[praha 11,240]

Not at all confident but gee whiz , Brisbane is not Prelim caliber. We should at least get there. A Geelong vs Brisbane Prelim is going to be a snorefest.

[At the break of Gawn 4,460]

2 minutes ago, praha said:

Not at all confident but gee whiz , Brisbane is not Prelim caliber. We should at least get there. A Geelong vs Brisbane Prelim is going to be a snorefest.

A win is just expected. It’d be a disaster if we don’t make the prelim. To lose two home finals in a row against 2 interstate sides would just be an embarrassment.

[IRW 1,387]

1 hour ago, Redlagged said:

Hard to argue with this, isn't it? Premiers then backing up to finish second, in such a competitive environment. Not too bad.

That judgement is on hold until the season is over.

Lose tomorrow and it's 5th or 6th rather than 2nd

[layzie 33,793]

Well maybe there will be late changes.

[Superunknown 4,215]

Sometimes reading this forum is like reading Christmas cards from a grandma what with the excess and redundant “ “

”fair “ dinkum “<insert poster name” this post is just “not on”

 

👀👀😂😂😂😵‍💫😵‍💫😵‍💫❤️💙❤️⏱

[Wells 11 5,396]

3 hours ago, Diamond_Jim said:

The conservative and probably correct decision.

Cannot help but think that with all the walking wounded our season is sputtering to its end but let's hope not

seems to sum up the mood here and in me too DJ. I’m open to being surprised but have that familiar MFCSS cloud around me. 

[faultydet 7,594]

28 minutes ago, titan_uranus said:

Embarrassed? Towelled?

In our three H&A games against Sydney and Collingwood we led all of them at three quarter time. 

In the final against Sydney we led by two goals halfway into the third quarter of one of the best and most intense games of the year.

In the Geelong game we weren't at our best but still closed to within a goal in the fourth.

They were all in their own way frustrating/disappointing, as every loss is to an extent, but in no way were we embarrassed in any of them.

Ok, so we led at 3/4 time against Swans an Colonwood in 3 games and lost ALL 3 OF THEM.

We also lost to Geelong

Whats your point mate? We are not playing like a challenger, and unlike last year we have shown NOTHING that would intimidate the other contenders.

Tell me what I missed, because I don't think its much.

 

 

 

[At Least I Saw a Flag 5,233]

Captain Obvious here ...

Reigning premiers, undefeated after 10 rounds. Going out in straight sets would represent a fail.

Reaching a Prelim would be a pass ...

One difference between 2021 and 2022 is our record against top teams.

Thank you ...

 

[dees189227 12,385]

I'd expect better games from Neal- Bullen & Melksham tomorrow night 

[The Reverend 1,736]

Oh ye of little faith, have trust in the word of the coach, for blessed are they who believe even in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary, for they will be rewarded with another premiership. Blessed are they who refuse to be weighed down by common sense and logic for they will inherit a dynasty the likes of which has never been seen before. Blessed are they who keep the faith for they will be smiling smugly on the way to get the paper on Saturday morning. 

GO DEES!

[COOLX 207]

I cannot see us winning this time around against Brisbane . We another tall to forward to back up B.Brown. Some how the MCG has become a bogey ground for us and it is certainly one for Brisbane yet they would have learnt something from their past two encounters against us . We the the other hand lack flair , we have bottomed out  , we are frighten to make decent changes to the team . 

[Pennant St Dee 13,170]

3 hours ago, picket fence said:

How Melksham and Spargo both stay is the eight wonder of world! Also no way would I have risked tracc. MADNESS!

Oh ffs, give it a rest, Spargo was good last week his delivery and decision making was fine.

All you do every time you call for Spargo to be dropped is confirm your footy IQ is limited 

[dee-tox 4,835]

Hard to understand ANB getting another game after his last six weeks... Has been putrid.

Then again, maybe he so important to 'structures' that we couldn't take a risk in bringing in a replacement?

[deanox 9,910]

18 hours ago, faultydet said:

Staggering that so many on here can't see what's directly in front of them.

We are not a premiership side this year. We may get over the Lions this week, and that has been well analyzed by a few on here who have mentioned the low pressure game that Brisbane play and that we thrive on. 

But as Colonwood and Sydney have shown very clearly this year, we are far from elite when it comes to moving the ball under intense pressure, particularly from the midfield into the forward line.

As much as it pains me, it's Geelong/Colonwood/Sydney for premiers this year. We are making up the numbers.

I definitely agree that Geelong and Sydney should be odds on, but although they've got a good record against us, I can't see the pies getting up in 3 more finals 

17 hours ago, titan_uranus said:

Embarrassed? Towelled?

In our three H&A games against Sydney and Collingwood we led all of them at three quarter time. 

In the final against Sydney we led by two goals halfway into the third quarter of one of the best and most intense games of the year.

In the Geelong game we weren't at our best but still closed to within a goal in the fourth.

They were all in their own way frustrating/disappointing, as every loss is to an extent, but in no way were we embarrassed in any of them.

I think this is something that's worth highlighting too.

Yeah we've got a poor record against those teams this year but it is also a bit of a sliding doors moment in a lot of those games. We've got a strong defensive structure meaning teams need to play their best to beat us.

I think most of us agree that rounds 11-13 we were outrun by Freo, the Swans and Collingwood, however this hasn't been an issue the last few weeks.

In round 17 Geelong beat us comfortably. We got back within a goal, yeah, but I don't think we ever looked like deserving to win. To me this was the worst lost of the year.

In round 19 the dogs kicks 17.8 to beat us by 10. In round 21 Collingwood had to kick 15.6 to beat us by 7 points. Last week the Swans kicked 14.7. In none of those games was fitness a factor, and I really think that a few luckier breaks in any game and we win.

 

To me this means that come Prelim and GF (if we make either or both) it's still a genuinely open contest.

Don't rule us out yet.

Edited September 9, 2022 by deanox

[Dr. Gonzo 24,206]

2 hours ago, faultydet said:

Even if we smash Brisbane this week, nobody in their right mind would be claiming they were wrong to doubt us.

We have been embarrassed so often by top 4 teams this year. I reckon you would search long and far for a team that wins a flag after being towelled in every high-pressure game they played in that year.

We are not winning the flag in 2022. We can reload for 2023, but prepare yourself for a letdown if you think dazzle is off the mark this year.

That might be so but what's it got to do with this week's selection?

[faultydet 7,594]

Just now, Dr. Gonzo said:

That might be so but what's it got to do with this week's selection?

Ah, nothing Dr G

We (may) beat the Lions this week, but we are on a hiding to nothing the following week.

 

[layzie 33,793]

Strong union by the sounds of it 

[Dr. Gonzo 24,206]

8 minutes ago, faultydet said:

Ah, nothing Dr G

We (may) beat the Lions this week, but we are on a hiding to nothing the following week.

 

You never know, what if the Cats suffer a bout of gastro like the week leading in to last year's Prelim? 🤣

Many here have completely lost it going by this thread. Yeah we may not win the flag this year but we are still in it and a win tomorrow night will see us in the final 4. From there anything can happen so strap yourselves in and enjoy the ride.

The whinging and moaning is unbelievable.

[layzie 33,793]

Goody won us a flag and still apparently is a nitwit who knows nothing about coaching.

[TheWiz 766]

I’m weirdly excited for this game. Not confident, but genuinely excited because this game will help to answer so many questions around our loading, fitness, game plan, predictability and selection consistency.

[Dr. Gonzo 24,206]

Just now, layzie said:

Goody won us a flag and still apparently is a nitwit who knows nothing about coaching.

It's madness, you'd think he was overlooking AA stars - Bowey might consider himself unlucky other than that there's no real options to bring in from Casey. Bedford had a chance earlier in the year, had one good game and that was it. Chandler maybe but unlikely he offers much more than Spargo or ANB who are proven premiership players. TMac is underdone and JVR isn't going to debut in a semi final.

The sooking on here is ridiculous.

[spirit of norm smith 16,435]

No change. 
 

ANB owes Goody big time. Weeks of fumbles and turnovers again tolerated. He must simply have a “blinder” to repay the coach’s faith in him. 
 

I guess it’s either Duck or no dinner this week for Goody. No change and we win. He’s a genius !! 
No change and we loss. He simply tolerated lack of performance too many times. 
 

Let’s unleash hell !! 

Edited September 8, 2022 by spirit of norm smith
K

[John Demonic 5,785]

I for one look forward to an easier draw next year if this year is a straight sets fail #SilverLinings #OddYearsNotEvensThisTimeRound

[Demon Dynasty 17,109]

1 hour ago, dees189227 said:

I'd expect better games from Neal- Bullen & Melksham tomorrow night 

I would add Gus, Kozzy, Viney,  Spargo, LJ & Max (to a lessor degrree) to that list

Edited September 8, 2022 by Demon Dynasty