Who comes in and who goes out?

No change (barring injury).

Sorry Ben.

Out  wied

In BBB

Just now, Lord Nev said:

No change (barring injury).

Sorry Ben.

Cannot be serious.

In: Brown

Out: Flip a coin

This should be the shortest thread ever. We won by 67 points. 
 

No change.

Ben Brown is a top 10 most important player, he comes straight back in.

1 minute ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

Cannot be serious.

Thought both TMac and Weid were good and we won by 11 goals.

Ben can win back his spot just like everyone else.

Weid out, Brown in.
 

No  question. There was a moment during the last quarter where he was in spitting distance of a giant who had the ball. Weid just stood there for a couple of seconds before you actually saw the cog turn in his brain that he should try to impact the ball carrier. 
McDonald would have smothered without even thinking, and that’s why he stays in the side.  

Weed did a pretty good job, though still dropped too many that he got to, but BBBB surely is a given.

Otherwise absolutely no change (barring injury)

Edited April 16, 20224 yr by monoccular

Round 6 maybe? 🤔

1 minute ago, Lord Nev said:

Thought both TMac and Weid were good and we won by 11 goals.

Ben can win back his spot just like everyone else.

I don’t recall him ever losing it based on his form. 
His three finals last year speak volumes (and the rest of his career).
His inclusion immediately makes us a better side. 
If either of Tmac’s or Weid’s performance tonight was good enough to keep Brown out I must be watching a different game. 

Brown will come back in just as Petty did this week.

 

Weed competed well tonight but he is in no way as dangerous as Ben Brown. 

1 minute ago, Bombay Airconditioning said:

I don’t recall him ever losing it based on his form. 
His three finals last year speak volumes (and the rest of his career).
His inclusion immediately makes us a better side. 
If either of Tmac’s or Weid’s performance tonight was good enough to keep Brown out I must be watching a different game. 

Brown will come back in just as Petty did this week.

He very well might, and I won't be sad if he does.

Just my opinion that after a win like that I wouldn't be making any 'automatic' changes.

15 minutes ago, Clint Bizkit said:

Ben Brown is a top 10 most important player, he comes straight back in.

Yep and I dont give  Flying Trapeze if Weeds or T. Mac goes out!! BBB a much better player ..on so many levels

Field our strongest team we must. Benny for a stiff Sammy.

In, BBB. 

Out, I really don't know. Probably Weed.

We might need to keep an eye on Lever's fitness.

IN: Sideshow Bob

OUT: Weed

Toss of the coin between Weed and Plugger Mac but the latter is SO CLOSE to 200 games and is no better / worse than the former at this stage

Brown in and Weid out.

 

14 minutes ago, Demons11 said:

Weed competed well tonight but he is in no way as dangerous as Ben Brown. 

Exactly.  Huge match up problem for tiges.

Goodwin has showed sentiment doesn't count. Brown is a class above weid and will be picked.

Brown for Weiderman

Lever spent last 9 mins on bench at emd and was hobbling a bit on that ankle, reckon he's a danger... Tomo is good cover with Smith in line also

Brown in. 

Trac looked to be labouring tonight. I think those whispers are true. 

Lever didn't look right by the end.

Tomlinson, Dunstan. 

It doesn't really matter. We'll keep winning whoever is in or out. 

 

27 minutes ago, Monocology said:

Field our strongest team we must. Benny for a stiff Sammy.

Is that a euphemism?

It'll be Ben Brown for T Mac. 

Pin this post. 

Tmac hasn't fired a shot for too long now and Weed deserves another crack after tonight.