6. Petracca

5. Langdon

4. Viney

3. Oliver

2. Smith

1. Brown

Can’t believe the fella pulling pose after pose during the 4th hasn’t got a vote yet. 🤪

2 hours ago, bananas said:

6. Petracca

5. Langdon

4. Viney

3. Oliver

2. Smith

1. Brown

I would go along with that except one would have to include Brayshaw for his guts and determination playing an unorthodox role for him so I would slot him in in place of Smith who was credible...

6. Trac

5. Langdon

4. Brown

3. Oliver

2. Viney

1. Smith

7 hours ago, picket fence said:

Just got home after dropping my Daughter of! She and I agreed on these votes

6 Tracc

Daylight

5 Langdon

4 Oliver

3 Smith

2 Gus

1 BBB

Apologies Viney, Spargo, Jacko and May!! Nibbler pretty solid as well! T Mac in Backline pretty good as well!

yep… but daylight wasn’t seen all night.  ;-) 

6. Trac

5. Brown

4. Langdon

3. Oliver

2. Smith

1. ANB

6 Tracc

5 Langdon

4 Viney

3 Brayshaw

2 ANB

1 Gawn

 

Brayshaw played out of his regular position and covered for Salem so well.

I mark BBB and May too hard probably 

6.Petracca

5. Brown

4. Langdon

3. Viney

2. Oliver

1. ANB

Note: Had real difficulty from 4 down. Spargo is also vote worthy

PS: Having now read the votes given by others it seems that we all had problems after Petracca. 

I gave Brown 5 because he kept us in touch when needed

Edited March 16, 20224 yr by Diamond_Jim

6 Petracca

5 Viney

4 Oliver 

3 Brayshaw

2 Brown

1. Langdon

6. Petracca

5. Oliver

4. Neal-Bullen  

3. Brayshaw

2. Langdon

1. Brown

It was the best game I've seen Smith* play, but am surprised to see how many people gave him votes. I would have a few others not in my votes (Gawn, May, Jackson) ahead of him, too.

*Best game I've seen Bailey Smith play, too.  

6: Petracca 

5. Brown 

4. Langdon 

3. Oliver

2. Viney 

1. Brayshaw

6 Petracca

5 Oliver

4 Langdon

3 Brayshaw

2 Brown

1 Viney

apologies to Jackson, just couldn't squeeze him in.

Petracca -  Without him muscling the game in the third quarter, we lose. Outstanding!

Oliver.  Business as usual

Langdon. I can't recall another player who goes from deep defence to deep forward so often and so quickly.

BBB .  What a pick up ( and cheap). I already have money on him for the Coleman.

Brayshaw. As good as in the Grannie .

Max. Could have fitted a few in here but Max is a gut busting inspirational leader.

IMO one of the most impressive aspects of our win last night, was that it was such an even team performance.  I reckon you could throw a blanket over 10 or so players after Tracc, who was a clear standout   My stab at it, as follows:

6.  Petracca

5.  Langdon

4.  May

3.  Oliver

2.  Smith

1. Viney 

My votes 5 down to 1, could easily have included the unlucky Brayshaw, Brown, Spargo, Jackson and Neal-Bullen.

6. Christian Petracca 

5. Ben Brown 

4. Clayton Oliver 

3. Jack Viney 

2. Ed Langdon 

1. James Jordon

6 - Petracca
5 - Oliver
4 - ANB
3 - Brown
2 - Langdon
1 - Brayshaw

After tracca it was very hard

spargo did not waste a ball

bowey similar 

ANB. At times hunt, Landon for 3 quarters James jordon very solid. Baker I thought he was unsure then he composed himself and had a couple of really good bits 

 

friitta all night dangerous as was BBB 

Kossy was a bit quiet overall

tmac solid as a rock when at the back and smith had a solid game

wr are as equal as any side. Go dees

6 - Tracc

5 - Clayton 

4 - BBB

3 - Gus

2 - JV

1 -Ed

apologies - May, ANB, TMac, Joel Smith, Spargs.

3 hours ago, 640MD said:

After tracca it was very hard

spargo did not waste a ball

bowey similar 

ANB. At times hunt, Landon for 3 quarters James jordon very solid. Baker I thought he was unsure then he composed himself and had a couple of really good bits 

 

friitta all night dangerous as was BBB 

Kossy was a bit quiet overall

tmac solid as a rock when at the back and smith had a solid game

wr are as equal as any side. Go dees

baker?

55 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

baker?

Well, he didn't make any mistakes !!!

56 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

baker?

I'm guessing 640MD meant Bedford.

6. Petracca

5. Langdon

4. Oliver

3. Brown

2. Brayshaw

1. Smith

Could have easily given a vote to Spargo, Viney, Gawn or Jackson. 

I was at the MCG. I must watch the replay to see what I missed with Spargo's game. Given the comments here, he must have done a lot more than I can recall seeing.

1 hour ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

I'm guessing 640MD meant Bedford.

Yes you are correct 

No surprise but Trac is out front in the early polls -

Progressive 

18. Christian Petracca 
10. Ben Brown
9. Clayton Oliver
8. Ed Langdon 
6. Jack Viney
5. Alex Neal-Bullen 
3 Joel Smith 
2. Luke Jackson 
1. Angus Brayshaw James Jordon