Interview with MFC President Kate Roffey: Deeluded Podcast

[FarNorthernD 5,861]

22 hours ago, binman said:

Is it time for a woman to coach our AFLW team?

The women’s comp has proved to be a massive learning curve for everyone involved. Mick Stinnear, I believe, has a winning record in all of the 5 seasons he has coached. It could also be argued that he was the AFLW coach of the year last year given the draw we were given. From the outside looking in he seems to command great respect from his players

Aside from the optics of having a female coach are there any other reasons you’d like to change coaches? 

 

[daisycutter 29,743]

1 hour ago, Grr-owl said:

There's a podcast app these days...

for win10?

 

[Yossarian 1,820]

1 hour ago, daisycutter said:

for win10?

 

You can listen on Spotify.

If you don't have Spotify, I recommend getting Spotify.

[Grr-owl 1,253]

Cheers for the interesting interview, Kiran and Nita. Was struck by the lack of specifics in the answers, but I suppose that's the way it has to be. Can't be letting us into the nitty-gritty. 

But in one case I thought the lack of detail was revealing. I drew the conclusion that we are nowhere when it comes to finding a home base....

  

[daisycutter 29,743]

8 minutes ago, Grr-owl said:

Cheers for the interesting interview, Kiran and Nita. Was struck by the lack of specifics in the answers, but I suppose that's the way it has to be. Can't be letting us into the nitty-gritty. 

But in one case I thought the lack of detail was revealing. I drew the conclusion that we are nowhere when it comes to finding a home base....

  

except that she did say that we should be hearing on the government's decision "soon"

i know "soon" is rather indeterminate but it's certainly not years. i took it to mean this year

[deeTRACted 406]

35 minutes ago, daisycutter said:

i know "soon" is rather indeterminate but it's certainly not years. i took it to mean this year

Could be in connection to the State Budget?

[Gorgoroth 13,023]

2 hours ago, deeTRACted said:

Could be in connection to the State Budget?

Yeah Budget drops were when they announced the 400million upgrades to Kadina park. Think this year will prob make it 37 billion upgrades for the cats.

[old dee 23,872]

3 hours ago, daisycutter said:

except that she did say that we should be hearing on the government's decision "soon"

i know "soon" is rather indeterminate but it's certainly not years. i took it to mean this year

I thought it was this year back at an AGM in 2019 dc. It’s now firmly in the i will believe it when I see it box. 

[Mel Bourne 4,534]

Why is the podcast called “Deeluded”. Isn’t that a tad...negative?

[Cards13 9,117]

4 hours ago, daisycutter said:

except that she did say that we should be hearing on the government's decision "soon"

i know "soon" is rather indeterminate but it's certainly not years. i took it to mean this year

PJ and Bartlett both said “soon” as well DC, I’m not holding my breath on it, it still feels years away. 
 

What ever happened to the Sts Seaford base, can we take that over? 

[Dr. Gonzo 24,305]

On 5/19/2021 at 2:56 PM, Grr-owl said:

Cheers for the interesting interview, Kiran and Nita. Was struck by the lack of specifics in the answers, but I suppose that's the way it has to be. Can't be letting us into the nitty-gritty. 

But in one case I thought the lack of detail was revealing. I drew the conclusion that we are nowhere when it comes to finding a home base....

  

Agreed, from her answers it seemed as though they haven't even settled on a location yet! If Pert wants to hit the targets set by the board in regards to this they'd want to get a crack on.

[AzzKikA 2,371]

Can't find it on Spotify is it supposed to be under the demonland podcast list?

[AzzKikA 2,371]

8 minutes ago, AzzKikA said:

Can't find it on Spotify is it supposed to be under the demonland podcast list?

Nevermind found it.

[BDA 22,891]

Sounds like the MGC precinct home base project is going nowhere fast. I hope we have contingency plans.

[Demonstone 22,820]

1 hour ago, AzzKikA said:

Nevermind found it.

You found Nirvana's second album?

[binman 43,813]

39 minutes ago, demonstone said:

You found Nirvana's second album?

Mint condition. Virgin vinyl.

Edited May 20, 2021 by binman

[AzzKikA 2,371]

48 minutes ago, demonstone said:

You found Nirvana's second album?

Dad joke alert

[Demonstone 22,820]

You do realise that "never mind" is two words?

[BAMF 4,387]

On 5/17/2021 at 4:31 PM, Grr-owl said:

Might be a bit obvious. I think Demon supporters hope that the changeover was bloodless, but are certain it was significant. Can Kate assure us that it is not a sign of instability?

Did you listen to the Real Footy podcast this week? They mentioned that it was anything less than bloody. Apparently most wanted him gone. 

The early wins cemented it as Bartlett had been gunning for Goodwin big time.

[tincan 171]

Really enjoy the podcast guys, particularly the guests interviews each week.

When listening to Roffey discuss the new home base, I definitely felt a change in sentiment compared to Bartlett's, and even Pert's interviews.

Roffey seemed a lot less confident that we would get a home base in the MCG vicinity, her comment was along the lines of "whatever the answer is from the Government, we just need that answer soon". Whereas Pert and Bartlett have been a lot stronger with their comments, in effect saying that we won't accept a home base anywhere other than the MCG precinct.

A bit frustrating that the dialogue appears to be changing after Pert and Bartlett have led us to believe we wouldn't be moving far.

 

 

[Mel Bourne 4,534]

On 5/19/2021 at 6:59 PM, Mel Bourne said:

Why is the podcast called “Deeluded”. Isn’t that a tad...negative?

Okee doke, seems I’m alone here. Really not a great name though, especially given the thousands of options. 

[binman 43,813]

On 5/18/2021 at 8:19 PM, FarNorthernD said:

The women’s comp has proved to be a massive learning curve for everyone involved. Mick Stinnear, I believe, has a winning record in all of the 5 seasons he has coached. It could also be argued that he was the AFLW coach of the year last year given the draw we were given. From the outside looking in he seems to command great respect from his players

Aside from the optics of having a female coach are there any other reasons you’d like to change coaches? 

 

It is not about optics. Though one person's optics is another person' leadership.

Obviously he had the talent and was appointed on merit, but the only reason Mick Stinear was in a position to land the dees AFLW seniour coach job is that there was a coaching pathway for him, the opportunity to gain experience and infrastructure to support his development as coach.  He captain-coached St Kilda City from 2012 to 2013, then coached Oakleigh Chargers for three years before being appointed the inaugural coach of our women's team.

I don't know Mick, but i reckon it is safe to assume he has aspirations to coach at AFL level. The AFLW job has provided him a pathway to say an assistant coach role, and perhaps ultimately a senior AFL coaching job.  

It goes without saying that it is important that the pathways Mick Stinear benefited from also exist for women. And currently they don't.

And it goes without saying that both women and men's football will be much better for having women in coaching and development roles at all levels, from junior football, country footy, ammos etc. etc - and of course the AFLW and AFL. 

Why? For the same reason the AFL works so hard to get kids to chose aussie rules over other sports, which in large part to increase the talent pool and by doing so increase the standard of the players playing at the elite level (and of course grow the game and supporter base).

By building the infrastructure and systems and developing pathways for women to coach at AFLW and AFL level you increase the pool of talented coaches and therefore the over all talent level of coaching.

And more women stay involved in the game because there is a pathway.

Think of someone like Daisy. I have no doubt she would be a brilliant coach. She is whip smart, has incredible understanding of the game and is a brilliant communicator. As it stands what is the pathway for Daisy to a senior AFLW coaching role - or senior AFL coach for that matter? It is crazy that we might lose her to the game for wont of a pathway. Or Paxy for instance. 

I don't know how many women are assistant coaches in the AFLW. Not many i would think, and likely not one in AFL (Peta Searle was a development coach for the saints 2014-17, making her the AFL’s first full-time female assistant coach - and as far as i know the only one then or since).

Peta Searle is the only women senior AFLW coach after Bec Goddard resigned after two years and a flag at the Crows.

Surely no-one could argue that we need more women involved in coaching, particularly in the AFLW?

The demons and dogs were leaders in driving women's football to the establishment of the AFLW,  with our annual matches that started way back in 2013.

Appointing a woman to coach our AFLW team would be be natural extension of that leadership and particularly apt given we have the the first female president in our 165 year history. 

And by the by there is no way Mick Stinear could be considered the coach of the year last year. Not making the grand final was a fail, pure and simple. His game plan, that worked great in the home and away season, broke down under the Crow's heat.

And to be honest he has escaped scrutiny. Given the talent we have had and the head start we had on the rest of the competition, to not have won a flag in five seasons is also a fail (noting of course 2020 was abandoned and we had made the GF).   

Here are two interesting, relevant articles to the topic of pathways and women coaching in football:

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2020/nov/10/lisa-alexander-afl-netball-coach-job-experience

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-11-25/hawthorn-names-all-female-vflw-coaching-panel/12920762

 

 

Edited May 21, 2021 by binman

[Smokey 4,389]

Really good interview - great work Deeluded 

I'm very impressed with Kate. She seems humble and very down to earth, but also strikes me as a very powerful presence with a clear set of credentials on display that bodes well for her success in the role. 

Happy days 

Edited May 21, 2021 by Smokey

[tincan 171]

58 minutes ago, Mel Bourne said:

Okee doke, seems I’m alone here. Really not a great name though, especially given the thousands of options. 

Hasn't been a lot to be positive about as a Melbourne supporter...

[poita 3,902]

1 hour ago, binman said:

It goes without saying that it is important that the pathways Mick Stinear benefited from also exist for women. And currently they don't.

At the risk of derailing this thread further, I am involved with a junior team and only a small portion of the girls teams are currently coached by women. There are plenty of opportunities for women to be involved in coaching roles at our club, either as head coaches or assistants, but they are not volunteering for those roles. There are plenty of women involved in other roles (team managers, trainers, sales, etc), and we get great support at matches, but coaching roles don't seem to appeal.

I'm a big supporter of women's football, and it would be great to get greater female representation in our AFLW program, but I think we need to accept that some jobs simply don't appeal to some people as much as they do to others. You mentioned Daisy Pearce as an option. We would certainly want to keep Daisy at the club, but why would someone with two young children and a career want to take on a coaching role as well? I'm no great fan of Mick Stinear, but I'm certainly not forcing him out of a job just to get a less capable woman in the role because it looks good to outsiders.