VOTES: Rd 09 vs Carlton

[Earl Hood 6,167]

6 Salem

5 Oliver

4 Lever

3 TMacc

2 Langdon

1 Jordon

[Bleed red and blue 59]

4 hours ago, deanox said:

6 Lever

5 Oliver

4 Salem

3 May

2 Langdon

1 TMac

 

Apologies to Gawn (workhorse), Fritsch (cameo) and Rivers (saved the day on many occasions), as well as Kozzie (who threatened but broke even on the dangerous Saad).

 

That's about it I reckon

[Nascent 9,345]

6. Lever

5. Salem

4. Oliver

3. Brayshaw

2. May

1. Neal-Bullen

Apologies to langdon, jj and tmac.

Rivers killing it in the backline just quietly. Doesn't get the same plaudits as his fellow draftees in Jackson and Pickett but has been equally as impressive in my opinion.

Edited May 16, 2021 by Nascent

[GM11 793]

6 Lever

5 Oliver

4 Salem

3 May

2MacDonald

1 Spargo

[Jaded No More 68,976]

3 hours ago, McQueen said:

People who don’t have Oliver in their six.

 

They’re racist against gingers that’s why. 
 

6- Clarry (red heads stick together!)

5- Lever 

4- Salem 

3- McDonald 

2- May 

1- My boy #positivelingers 

Edited May 16, 2021 by Jaded

[jnrmac 20,338]

6 Salem

5 Oliver

4 Hunt

3 Rivers

2. TMac

1 Lever

[Pennant St Dee 13,428]

6.Clarrie

5.Lever

4.Langdon

3. Salem

2. May

1.Jordon

[Greendale 350]

6. Salem

5. TMac

4. Lever

3. Oliver

2. Langdon

1. Jordon

Honourable mention to Jayden Hunt who is in career best form

[Dannyz 3,069]

Oliver

Salem

McDonald

ANB

Hunt

Rivers

HM - Jordon. 

[Billy 2,565]

6. Oliver

5. Salem

4. Jordan 

3. TMAC

2. Lever

1. ANB

[Robbie57 2,042]

13 hours ago, deanox said:

6 Lever

5 Oliver

4 Salem

3 May

2 Langdon

1 TMac

 

Apologies to Gawn (workhorse), Fritsch (cameo) and Rivers (saved the day on many occasions), as well as Kozzie (who threatened but broke even on the dangerous Saad).

 

This

[jane02 3,794]

6. Oliver

5. McDonald

4. Salem

3. Lever

2. May

1. Langdon

[reynolds46 1,310]

Oliver

Lever

Salem

McDonald

Rivers

Langdon

[Dee Dee 1,145]

6: Lever

5: Salem

4: Oliver

3: Hunt

2: McDonald

1: Spargo

[Cheesy D. Pun 1,765]

I watched the replay when I got home and have a totally different view if some players now.

While you get a far better idea of the running patterns at the game, you do miss a lot.

The two contributions I missed most were Trac and Brayshaw.

Trac was excellent and Brayshaw's good work far outweighed the bad (turnovers). If Gus can get his disposal in order, a big game is just around the corner. His read of the game is elite.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 17,135]

6. Salem

5.Oliver

4. Lever

3. McDonald

2. Hunt

1. Jordon

Surprised at Spargo getting so many votes. On the other hand, I can understand why others gave votes to ANB and Langdon 

[tiers 2,883]

Too hard to place in order. So give 3 votes to Salem and then 2 votes each to Lever, May, Oliver, McDonald, Neal-Bullen, Spargo, Hunt, Jordon, Petracca and Langdon. Total 21 votes.

How good is it when the teams performance is so even with multiple contributors.

[Mister Ed 317]

6. Tom McDonald
5. Clayton Oliver
4. Christian Petracca
3. Christian Salem
2. Ed Langdon
1. Steven May

 

[Demonland 74,289]

Clayton Oliver leads the two Christians -

Progressive

83. Clayton Oliver
66. Christian Salem
64. Christian Petracca
60. Max Gawn
57. Jake Lever
44. Tom McDonald
43. Ed Langdon
31. Steven May
26. Kysiah Pickett
17. Bayley Fritsch Luke Jackson
12. Jayden Hunt
10. Jack Viney
9. James Harmes
8. James Jordon
7. Michael Hibberd  
3. Angus Brayshaw Charlie Spargo
1. Alex Neal-Bullen Adam Tomlinson

 

[Roger Mellie 4,205]

^

Definitely not enough love for Trent Rivers in 2021

[dieter 3,325]

6: Oliver

5: Lever

4: Salem

3: langdon: 

2: Gawn

1: Spargo.

 

[JJJ 1,348]

1 hour ago, Demonland said:

Clayton Oliver leads the two Christians -

Progressive

83. Clayton Oliver
66. Christian Salem
64. Christian Petracca
60. Max Gawn
57. Jake Lever
44. Tom McDonald
43. Ed Langdon
31. Steven May
26. Kysiah Pickett
17. Bayley Fritsch Luke Jackson
12. Jayden Hunt
10. Jack Viney
9. James Harmes
8. James Jordon
7. Michael Hibberd  
3. Angus Brayshaw Charlie Spargo
1. Alex Neal-Bullen Adam Tomlinson

 

I think that order is pretty good.

Although I doubt the coaches would have Gawn that high. We as supporters love him but tend to give him votes even when he probably doesn’t deserve it. I think he’s carrying a niggle that stops him from asserting some physical presence at times.

Was watching Jordan pretty closely and I found myself reflecting on Scotty Thompson when he played for us. Not to say that JJ has the ceiling of Scotty, but I feel very safe when he’s lurking around a clearance that he won’t let the ball exit too easily and hurt us. Much like Scotty used to do in his MFC days and Jnr McDonald after that.

[Demonland 74,289]

4 minutes ago, JJJ said:

I think that order is pretty good.

Although I doubt the coaches would have Gawn that high. We as supporters love him but tend to give him votes even when he probably doesn’t deserve it. I think he’s carrying a niggle that stops him from asserting some physical presence at times.

Was watching Jordan pretty closely and I found myself reflecting on Scotty Thompson when he played for us. Not to say that JJ has the ceiling of Scotty, but I feel very safe when he’s lurking around a clearance that he won’t let the ball exit too easily and hurt us. Much like Scotty used to do in his MFC days and Jnr McDonald after that.

As of Round 8.

Leaderboard - AFL Coaches Association’s AFL Champion Player Award

Votes	Player	Club
42	Hugh McCluggage	BL
38	David Mundy	FRE
34	Max Gawn	MELB
34	Touk Miller	GCFC
34	Ollie Wines	PORT
33	Jack Macrae	WB
32	Marcus Bontempelli	WB
32	Clayton Oliver	MELB
32	Christian Salem	MELB
31	Samuel Walsh	CARL
29	Zach Merrett	ESS
28	Christian Petracca	MELB

[JJJ 1,348]

Just now, Demonland said:

As of Round 8.

Leaderboard

Votes	Player	Club
42	Hugh McCluggage	BL
38	David Mundy	FRE
34	Max Gawn	MELB
34	Touk Miller	GCFC
34	Ollie Wines	PORT
33	Jack Macrae	WB
32	Marcus Bontempelli	WB
32	Clayton Oliver	MELB
32	Christian Salem	MELB
31	Samuel Walsh	CARL
29	Zach Merrett	ESS
28	Christian Petracca	MELB

I meant just our coaches. I don’t think he’s impacted the games as much as a couple of other Dees.

But your point is well made. 

[IvanBartul13 2,564]

1 hour ago, Roger Mellie said:

^

Definitely not enough love for Trent Rivers in 2021

That's not necessarily the case, just its a systemic weakness of the fixed 6-5-4-3-2-1 system that you can play well and not receive votes in good team performances and conversely receive votes for mediocre - or worse - games in lesser team performances.  Obviously also when multiple players play equally well, you have the issue that there is a massive difference between five votes and one vote when in reality there isn't such a difference in output.   Obviousy the best solution is we all score every player each week out of 10, but that obviously presents its own issues and likely isn't manageable.  But in terms of Rivers, he plays well but is probably our 12th, on average, best player each week.  In this system, thats of no value unfortunately.