10 hours ago, old dee said:

Yes Daw, if not why is he on the list.

He is the back up ruckman if both Max and LJ are out.

2 minutes ago, Redleg said:

He is the back up ruckman if both Max and LJ are out.

Get BBB about and rotate Max and LJ at FF they can’t do worse bring Daw in to help in ruck 

12 minutes ago, Pates said:

Another theory I have regarding his form is what is being asked of him? Is he being asked to play like TMac or Brown? Is he being given different sets of instructions? Are the coaches trying to simplify it to “affect X amount of contests and aim for a getting 2-3 looks at goals for one a game”. Maybe I’m grasping at straws but I just wonder if there’s a way we can get through to him that we aren’t trying. 

Part of being a “big boy” is setting your own standards - Weid should be telling himself min 1 goal per qtr and do anything to achieve that - I suspect that’s as simple as it needs to be 

but like our back six have a target of no more than 15 points per qtr conceded 

1 hour ago, Redleg said:

He is the back up ruckman if both Max and LJ are out.

He has played some good games as a Key forward which is something we sorely need at present . For that matter LJ is not exactly setting the world on fire at present. It might be time to give him a rest for DAW.

Edited June 7, 20223 yr by old dee

I believe Sam is lack confidence at the moment , perhaps the club and of himself has put too much pressure on himself. I would give him ( at Casey ) a lot more rucking time ( 70 % thereabouts ) and the rest of the time he could play in the forward or back pocket. If after 4 to 6 games does not improve then we say goodbye. Daw with less ruck duties he can play forward. Versatility is the key to success especially when T.Mac will be out for a long time and B.Brown not firing.

I would play him CHB at Casey and see how he goes!

2 hours ago, picket fence said:

I would play him CHB at Casey and see how he goes!

I have a strong feeling I know pf. 

On 6/7/2022 at 10:13 PM, Stu said:

Matt Taberner is an interesting comparison. Is 28 and is averaging 2.3 goals this season, much better than any of his previous years. 
 

He also showed glimpses of quality at times and similarly frustrated Freo supports by his lack of consistency. 

taberner has always had the talent, theres never been any doubts there. all the frustration from freo fans has been about his availability from injury. he's only played 47 wafl games and you can imagine 35 of those being in his first two years and then about two a year probably on the comeback from injury each time

On 6/8/2022 at 8:10 AM, Redleg said:

He is the back up ruckman if both Max and LJ are out.

he's never playing for us. you know how soccer teams have a third choice keeper. usually an old bloke just to help with training that's majak. big body for gawn to throw himself at during the week. he's like a walking speccy bag

9 minutes ago, Turner said:

he's never playing for us. you know how soccer teams have a third choice keeper. usually an old bloke just to help with training that's majak. big body for gawn to throw himself at during the week. he's like a walking speccy bag

Might be harsh but that's the perfect comparison really.

Hopefully gets his chance at some point. 

19 hours ago, COOLX said:

I believe Sam is lack confidence at the moment , perhaps the club and of himself has put too much pressure on himself. I would give him ( at Casey ) a lot more rucking time ( 70 % thereabouts ) and the rest of the time he could play in the forward or back pocket. If after 4 to 6 games does not improve then we say goodbye. Daw with less ruck duties he can play forward. Versatility is the key to success especially when T.Mac will be out for a long time and B.Brown not firing.

Is this because he practices every week against the trash talking Steven May..? 
would kill any player's confidence..?

On 5/31/2022 at 5:06 PM, Lord Nev said:

He's a backup key forward/ruck.

He's played 6 games this year as such, averaging 1.5 goals, 3.2 marks and 1.2 tackles a game.

For reference, our primary key forward Ben Brown averages 1.9 goals, 3.4 marks and 0.5 tackles per game this year.

I mean, I get it's the internet and people like to make outlandish comments, but the overreaction about Weideman is silly.

That is a simple comparison between the Weed and BBB. It really indicates that both are not up to the great - yet experientially reasonable - hopes that the fans and the football department have for each of them.

Sometimes they break-out for some games to the team's benefit, mostly they break-up at the individual (and team) performance levels across the majority of games for which they were chosen, in the roles that we all expected and hoped that they could fulfil. 

It truly is time to select two others, preferably young, budding and switched-on forward enthusiasts who see the advantages of leading for the ball, finding space and presenting to the team's advantage at every opportunity. There are several who might fill such a profile. There are others who have been played largely  'out-of-position' so far in their footballing careers at the MFC. 

Another chance for Sam this week. They preferred Mitch Brown over Sam in the last fortnight which reflects where Sam was at.  He’s got at least the next month (4 games) to show us what we all desperately want to see. Attack on the contest.  Take the mark.  Or bring it to ground.  Constant movement and demanding the footy.  Good accurate kicking.  Remove the niceness.  Feeling like he belongs.  Tough first up v Andrews or Adams so he’ll need to be agile and lead up to the footy. Hope we see a reflection of the 2018 finals Sam. 

Sam played a great game tonight. Many may look at the stats and think he didn't kick enough goals or take enough marks. But his ruck work and taps to advantage were fantastic. He was rarely out marked and often brought the ball to ground. Further, he blocked for team mates to allow them to mark the ball and he checked many leads once he realised others were in a better position to present. He also ran both ways, showing up many times in screen when another player marked the ball. 

If you feel he hasn't shown mongrel and desire in the past, he certainly showed that tonight. 

Edited June 23, 20222 yr by Stu

shame he didn't nail that set shot

he was gassed at the end but his efforts in the ruck were superb

I thought Weed was ok. Solid team performance, did his role, wasn’t outmarked too much and was serviceable. 
 

Maybe we just have to give this kid a different role other than FF, he has good skills and is good mark and kick, he’ll I even saw him lay tackle.

11 minutes ago, whatwhat say what said:

shame he didn't nail that set shot

he was gassed at the end but his efforts in the ruck were superb

It would have been a nice exclamation mark for his game tonight. Either way, play like that for the next few weeks and he'll keep his spot.

He played the 'big man' game Goodwin asked for a few weeks ago.

Reckon Goodwin and Weideman would both be happy with that.

He was very good.  And this is his natural position.  He played well in this role when Jackson was out against Hawthorn, but then got dropped when Jackson returned.  

I remember around 2010/2011, Geelong played Tomahawk more and more in the ruck to get his hands on the pill.

While it’s not a long term solution with us as Dogga and Max have first and relief ruck possies tied up, Weed could very well take up Dogga’s role should he go back to Perth if tonight is a guide. 

The best word I’d use to describe him tonight is conviction. When he went for the ball, it seemed like he actually wanted it. His disposal was top notch too.

7 hours ago, CYB said:

I thought Weed was ok. Solid team performance, did his role, wasn’t outmarked too much and was serviceable. 
 

Maybe we just have to give this kid a different role other than FF, he has good skills and is good mark and kick, he’ll I even saw him lay tackle.

I thought the same, serviceable and played a role. Happy with that

Extremely happy with the way Sam competed last night. Work rate high and intent to be physical. This is the level required and if he brings that ever week I'm happy, marks and goals will come.

1 hour ago, Colin B. Flaubert said:

I remember around 2010/2011, Geelong played Tomahawk more and more in the ruck to get his hands on the pill.

While it’s not a long term solution with us as Dogga and Max have first and relief ruck possies tied up, Weed could very well take up Dogga’s role should he go back to Perth if tonight is a guide. 

The best word I’d use to describe him tonight is conviction. When he went for the ball, it seemed like he actually wanted it. His disposal was top notch too.

Gawn/LJ ruck combo with sprinkles of Weid to get him involved imo. 40/40/20 perhaps.

We continue covering our bases for the future.

 

 

Edited June 23, 20222 yr by John Demonic

15 minutes ago, John Demonic said:

Gawn/LJ ruck combo with sprinkles of Weid to get him involved imo. 40/40/20 perhaps. 

 

 

Sprinkles of Weed is the wrong phraseology to describe the frequency of Weed being used as a ruck.

The correct expression is ‘tokes of’. 😄

Played his role, needs to take his chances when he gets them.

3 hours ago, Swooper1987 said:

He was very good.  And this is his natural position.  He played well in this role when Jackson was out against Hawthorn, but then got dropped when Jackson returned.  

Agreed give him some tasks and licence to harm ANY WHERE on the ground.