Rumour only file ...

[Damo 3,464]

Jye Caldwell?

 

[CHF 2,825]

1 minute ago, Patches O’houlihan said:

Phillips? 

I think so. But I am hearing that it might just be a strange one from left field.

Personally I have trouble thinking it might happen but I will put it out there for reaction.

TMac paying 150K pa plus pick 18 for Phillips. 
 

 

[Mickey 4,777]

Just now, CHF said:

I think so. But I am hearing that it might just be a strange one from left field.

Personally I have trouble thinking it might happen but I will put it out there for reaction.

TMac paying 150K pa plus pick 18 for Phillips. 
 

 

[Pennant St Dee 13,429]

Would we trade 18 or 19 for Pies 2021 first rounder?

Considering Nick Daicos anticipated to go Top 5 next season 

[deelusions from afar 1,893]

Just now, CHF said:

I think so. But I am hearing that it might just be a strange one from left field.

Personally I have trouble thinking it might happen but I will put it out there for reaction.

TMac paying 150K pa plus pick 18 for Phillips. 
 

 

Doesn't make sense to me - Collingwood push out Treloar and Phillips due to salary cap issues and take in TMac (and pick 18) and pay 500-600k for him the next 2 years?

For us, it clears our salary cap... but that's only needed if we're bringing someone in.  Not sure if Phillips is a big enough fish to justify it?  

Having said that, I think we need a winger badly - don't have faith that Baker is the answer so maybe this is the price?

[Beetle 4,739]

[Mickey 4,777]

1 minute ago, Pennant St Dee said:

Would we trade 18 or 19 for Pies 2021 first rounder?

Considering Nick Daicos anticipated to go Top 5 next season 

Would have to be that and a bit more. Reckon they will drop big time next year

[Lord Nev 13,512]

1 minute ago, Beetle said:

[AaronDaveyChipsAndGravey 390]

Just now, Pennant St Dee said:

Would we trade 18 or 19 for Pies 2021 first rounder?

Considering Nick Daicos anticipated to go Top 5 next season 

not a chance. why would we trade our future first for those 2 picks, to only send them back to the pies for their future 1st round. 

[CHF 2,825]

2 minutes ago, Mickey said:

My reaction as well.

may be we are clearing the decks for next season.

 

[Mickey 4,777]

1 minute ago, deelusions from afar said:

Doesn't make sense to me - Collingwood push out Treloar and Phillips due to salary cap issues and take in TMac (and pick 18) and pay 500-600k for him the next 2 years?

For us, it clears our salary cap... but that's only needed if we're bringing someone in.  Not sure if Phillips is a big enough fish to justify it?  

Having said that, I think we need a winger badly - don't have faith that Baker is the answer so maybe this is the price?

Yeah, I don't like it. Phillips has been out if their team, he's not worth a first and a player, even if one is a salary dump

[adonski 13,235]

2 minutes ago, Beetle said:

Saved for future use 

[Pennant St Dee 13,429]

2 minutes ago, AaronDaveyChipsAndGravey said:

not a chance. why would we trade our future first for those 2 picks, to only send them back to the pies for their future 1st round. 

Because we keep one of them and I anticipate Pies will slide next season that's why.

Gets us back into next years forst round and I'm backing us to finish above the Pies in 2021

Edited November 12, 2020 by Pennant St Dee

[Nascent 9,345]

5 minutes ago, CHF said:

I think so. But I am hearing that it might just be a strange one from left field.

Personally I have trouble thinking it might happen but I will put it out there for reaction.

TMac paying 150K pa plus pick 18 for Phillips. 
 

 

Change that to Treloar and I'd be happier. 18 I think is too much for Phillips giving they're trying to get rid of him. Guess Tmac balances that out to a degree.

[Mickey 4,777]

Just now, CHF said:

My reaction as well.

may be we are clearing the decks for next season.

 

Maybe, but I'd be disappointed if that's what it ended up being.

GWS have shown clubs they can match RFAs. Unless next year is for a UFA, we'll be in trouble

[Gorgoroth 13,213]

Last ditch Treloar pitch?

[Kent 2,920]

26 minutes ago, Hellish Inferno said:

Wow if true we can't stink it up next year

this mob can and we all know it

[AaronDaveyChipsAndGravey 390]

Just now, Pennant St Dee said:

Because we keep one of them and I anticipate Pies will slide next season that's why

We're basically helping out Collingwood with their NGA whilst betting ourselves against a team that still finished top 6 this year. Doesnt seem like a very high reward. Pies wouldnt agree either.

[dazzledavey36 56,269]

13 minutes ago, CHF said:

I think so. But I am hearing that it might just be a strange one from left field.

Personally I have trouble thinking it might happen but I will put it out there for reaction.

TMac paying 150K pa plus pick 18 for Phillips. 
 

 

Phillips has been ruled out by Mahoney..

[Caligula's cohort 1,014]

It looks like we aren't landing a back up ruckman with 30 minutes to go in the trade period. We'll most likely pick up a delisted free agent. Could Sam (sauce) Jacobs be a chance with us next year? He was interviewed last week and mentioned he still has a year or two left in the tank.  

[Adam The God 30,706]

Would love Treloar. Just sayin'...

[deelusions from afar 1,893]

2 minutes ago, Caligula's cohort said:

It looks like we aren't landing a back up ruckman with 30 minutes to go in the trade period. We'll most likely pick up a delisted free agent. Could Sam (sauce) Jacobs be a chance with us next year? He was interviewed last week and mentioned he still has a year or two left in the tank.  

Mahoney said they won't go for a backup ruck with Tmac staying on the list.

 

Think trade for a player must be a chance as why did they do the deal with the lions otherwise?

[Its Time for Another 4,306]

A mate with no contacts so just his idea that Jackson hasn't signed to extend his contract while Kossie & Rivers have so he thinks he's probably out the door end of next season in which case we'll get a first rounder or two for him. Plus rumours about Oliver wanting out won't go away so maybe 2 first rounders for him as well next year. 

[Roger Mellie 4,205]

1 minute ago, It's Time said:

A mate with no contacts so just his idea that Jackson hasn't signed to extend his contract while Kossie & Rivers have so he thinks he's probably out the door end of next season in which case we'll get a first rounder or two for him. Plus rumours about Oliver wanting out won't go away so maybe 2 first rounders for him as well next year. 

Killjoy

 

[Demons11 7,135]

1 minute ago, It's Time said:

A mate with no contacts so just his idea that Jackson hasn't signed to extend his contract while Kossie & Rivers have so he thinks he's probably out the door end of next season in which case we'll get a first rounder or two for him. Plus rumours about Oliver wanting out won't go away so maybe 2 first rounders for him as well next year. 

Jackson will sign