The 2020 Trade Period

[pitmaster 3,162]

14 hours ago, Dr.D said:

God some of you posters are carrying on like we are a top 4 team. we came 17th last year and are 8th this year with some disgusting performances in that. So a bit of a reality check. 

We need good decision makers across the park as well as more speed, a key forward to replace tom McDonald and a small defender to replace jetta. 

Marty Hore when fit

Edited August 17, 2020 by pitmaster

[spirit of norm smith 13,643]

14 hours ago, Cranky Franky said:

Crows are desperate so I reckon they will make Jack Viney a big, big offer at the end of the year.

Yes agree. They will offer a 5 year deal worth about $800k a year. Jack is now 26 so in his prime.  Crows will be desperate.  Dees have to match it imo. 

[spirit of norm smith 13,643]

On 8/13/2020 at 11:02 AM, adonski said:

5 minutes alone with May & he’ll knock the bulldog out of him 

Agree. Hunter for Joel Smith is a win win. I think Smith will ask for a trade and Kangas, Dogs or Hawks might be likely suitors.  

[Kent 2,678]

On 8/12/2020 at 1:56 PM, WERRIDEE said:

We definitely need another wingman and a small forward to help out Kossie. I don't know about a ruckman Preuss can't get a game and Bradtke is developing. I think we have enough depth in the ruck stocks.

How do we know Bradke is developing?

Anybody seen him? I would hang on to Pruess like grim death must have cover for Max

[Binmans PA 26,748]

8 hours ago, Dr.D said:

my track record speaks for itself. Were you one of the many demonlanders that wanted to drop Oliver? lol. right

You've got no track record except for whinging in every thread. 

[Grimes Times 1,278]

16 hours ago, Dr.D said:

God some of you posters are carrying on like we are a top 4 team. we came 17th last year and are 8th this year with some disgusting performances in that. So a bit of a reality check. 

We need good decision makers across the park as well as more speed, a key forward to replace tom McDonald and a small defender to replace jetta. 

Hes already on the list. Chandler.

[buck_nekkid 5,648]

What is our current draft hand in this year’s draft?  I seem to recall no first, and hawks second rounder, and about 20 4th rounders?

[layzie 30,434]

There's really no way to do any business in this trade period other than shopping around one of the value players. I know the instinct is to hang on to everyone and keep a list together but this isn't a case of packaging up Matty Warnock, Tom Bugg and Ben Kennedy for a 1st rounder. 

Make the bold calls or be happy with what we have. 

[adonski 9,497]

14 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Agree. Hunter for Joel Smith is a win win. I think Smith will ask for a trade and Kangas, Dogs or Hawks might be likely suitors.  

That’d be the greatest heist of all time. More like a first rounder & Smith

[Lucifers Hero 37,524]

A test for us is if other clubs come calling on Salem. 

He is a 'pre-Free Agent' this year.  Of late this is when clubs trade a player to get a better trade pick/deal than an AFL comp pick, if the player goes as an FA a year later eg GCS when trading May to us.

He would add 'silk' to any number of teams.

I'm in no way suggesting he would want to go or that we would let him go.  He is my favourite player.  But it would be surprising if the question isn't asked by other clubs.  A question they will ask of other players but the pre-FA year is when poaching clubs fancy their chances especially if the player is at a team high up the ladder.

Edited August 18, 2020 by Lucifer's Hero

[drdrake 3,066]

The issue all clubs face is the reduction in list sizes and salary cap.  Players might want to go but clubs just won't have the room for them.  Don't believe any reduction has been confirmed but this will happen.

Another point is the draft, 12 months development is massive for a 17 year old.  Recruiters will have no idea, a kid that dominated last season my have struggled.  If this happened the Clayton Olivers draft year there is high good chance he isn't drafted and if he was it would have been in the 3rd/4th round or rookie.  He had a massive year and we picked him up early.

Hard job for the recruiters and list managers this year.

[deelusions from afar 1,620]

23 hours ago, Grimes Times said:

Hes already on the list. Chandler.

Isn't Lockhart already playing this role?

[Grimes Times 1,278]

16 minutes ago, deelusions from afar said:

Isn't Lockhart already playing this role?

correct I was more looking at the back up

[ThreeOneSix 953]

On 8/18/2020 at 8:19 AM, spirit of norm smith said:

Yes agree. They will offer a 5 year deal worth about $800k a year. Jack is now 26 so in his prime.  Crows will be desperate.  Dees have to match it imo. 

We won’t be matching that, or even nearly that amount. If it came down to that we would wish JV the very best. But I suspect Viney will remain at the club on a far lesser amount.

Edited August 19, 2020 by ThreeOneSix

[old55 21,904]

On 8/17/2020 at 6:11 PM, Dr.D said:

God some of you posters are carrying on like we are a top 4 team. we came 17th last year and are 8th this year with some disgusting performances in that. So a bit of a reality check. 

We need good decision makers across the park as well as more speed, a key forward to replace tom McDonald and a small defender to replace jetta. 

Wait a minute - in other threads you are saying we are a top 4 team and the problem is Goodwin.

[Watts the matter 1,235]

21 minutes ago, ThreeOneSix said:

We won’t be matching that, or even nearly that amount. If it came down to that we would wish JV the very best. But I suspect Viney will remain at the club on a far lesser amount.

They won't be doing it if Crouch is leaving as it would dilute their compensation so can't see this happening. If Crouch stays the last thing you want is Viney joining the Crouch brothers in the midfield.

[58er 5,732]

On 8/18/2020 at 10:25 AM, Grimes Times said:

Hes already on the list. Chandler.

Sorry Lockhart first Chandler got depth 2nd!

[Binmans PA 26,748]

3 hours ago, Pollyanna said:

Wait a minute - in other threads you are saying we are a top 4 team and the problem is Goodwin.

The Doc needs a tranquilliser. He doesn't know whether he's coming or going. Any excuse to have a go at the club.

[layzie 30,434]

Some real watered down stuff there..

[Demons11 6,413]

On 8/17/2020 at 11:00 PM, MF-C said:

Need to get rid of Tmac while he has some value 

Jacko and Weed are only going to get better and I trust our recruiters to go after who we need 

If we can Trade Tmac for a crafty forward or even some picks then so be it 

I think he needs to move on and we do too

 

T Mac and a pick  for Papley

[ding 5,126]

5 hours ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

A test for us is if other clubs come calling on Salem. 

He is a 'pre-Free Agent' this year.  Of late this is when clubs trade a player to get a better trade pick/deal than an AFL comp pick, if the player goes as an FA a year later eg GCS when trading May to us.

He would add 'silk' to any number of teams.

I'm in no way suggesting he would want to go or that we would let him go.  He is my favourite player.  But it would be surprising if the question isn't asked by other clubs.  A question they will ask of other players but the pre-FA year is when poaching clubs fancy their chances especially if the player is at a team high up the ladder.

Interesting that he is your favorite player Luci. I have found myself expecting more from Salem each year and i reckon he has not come on as most of us wanted or hoped.

Leaving aside the trade that got him to us which only complicates matters, i honestly believe he hasn't delivered what i personally hoped he would when we first bought him in. I was genuinely hoping he would be a backline version of Adem Yze. Not just because of the left foot, but the speed and skill that OOZE bought to the team. Unfortunately Christian has lost quite a bit of his initial speed, and takes some of the shortest steps in the league. Im not saying he is cowardly. Quite the opposite as he is as hard as a cats head, but after his repeated hammy injuries his gait is as short as anyone in the AFL, so he looks fast due to his cadence, but the short stride he takes means he is nowhere near as fast as he looks. Add to that the dinky little kicks he is famous for and i am a bit disappointed that he has not reached the heights i thought he could. I was hoping for a line-breaker. He is far from that.

Salem has never (IMO only) been considered as a massive loss when injured despite his obvious skill. 

If someone who followed him more closely had info that could change my mind i would be happy to see it, but my immediate impression is that he isnt one of our "indispensable" players.

[old55 21,904]

I would be up for trading Preuss, particularly if we think Bradtke will make it and keep him.

Geelong might be interested and we might like one of their excess small forwards.  Here's a post from BigFooty on the subject from a Geelong supporter, I really don't know enough about the bolded players mentioned as possibles to make an evaluation:

We have a lot of small forwards/pinch hit mid types even with Ablett retiring - Miers Parfitt Fogarty Dahlhaus Atkins Close Narkle Simpson Evans Taheny Tarca and Parsons is a lot of guys fighting for 3 or 4 spots. The first 3 on that list are highly rated and I doubt we will let them go Dahlhaus wanted to come home he won't leave but any of the rest are gettable but I don't know how much interest Melbourne would have in them.

[Grr-owl 1,086]

18 minutes ago, ding said:

Interesting that he is your favorite player Luci. I have found myself expecting more from Salem each year and i reckon he has not come on as most of us wanted or hoped.

Leaving aside the trade that got him to us which only complicates matters, i honestly believe he hasn't delivered what i personally hoped he would when we first bought him in. I was genuinely hoping he would be a backline version of Adem Yze. Not just because of the left foot, but the speed and skill that OOZE bought to the team. Unfortunately Christian has lost quite a bit of his initial speed, and takes some of the shortest steps in the league. Im not saying he is cowardly. Quite the opposite as he is as hard as a cats head, but after his repeated hammy injuries his gait is as short as anyone in the AFL, so he looks fast due to his cadence, but the short stride he takes means he is nowhere near as fast as he looks. Add to that the dinky little kicks he is famous for and i am a bit disappointed that he has not reached the heights i thought he could. I was hoping for a line-breaker. He is far from that.

Salem has never (IMO only) been considered as a massive loss when injured despite his obvious skill. 

If someone who followed him more closely had info that could change my mind i would be happy to see it, but my immediate impression is that he isnt one of our "indispensable" players.

Is better suited to delivering the ball inside 50. We need a Zac Williams or Adam Saad at HB to facilitate that...

[Dr.D 1,771]

55 minutes ago, Demons11 said:

T Mac and a pick  for Papley

Are you serious? Papley is worth 2 first rounders. Why would Sydney want Tom McDonald who has been in and out of a side and overtaken by a 18 year old ruckman?  

To be serious, it'd be our 2nd rounder, next years first and Tom McDonald for Papley. 

You are why trades get done. That trade would get laughed out the door at

[Accepting Mediocrity 1,418]

19 minutes ago, ding said:

If someone who followed him more closely had info that could change my mind i would be happy to see it, but my immediate impression is that he isnt one of our "indispensable" players.

I'm a Salem fan. Admittedly, he hasn't (and probably won't) reach the elite status that we hoped, but he remains one of our better players and we don't really have anyone else on the list capable of playing his role. For mine, he's indispensable (until we get more players with his skill set at least).

I've seen far too many butchers at MFC to advocate for trading one of the best kicks in the team.