GAMEDAY: Rd 21 vs Collingwood

[Deecisive 1,658]

what the hell is oscar doing out there, he is a joke as a ruckman. lever if his is not kicking to our opponents his crashing the pack taking out our own players without getting the ball out of bounds. Jones, well what can you say about nothing. turnovers are killing us again and again, when will they learn

[Jaded No More 58,682]

Just now, bing181 said:

Regardless of anything else, bottom handful are under where they need to be. Melksham (OK, coming back from injury), but Dunkley, Baker, JKH not giving enough and/or turning the ball over.

I reckon JHK has done more than Gus, Jones and Oliver today to be honest. 

Melksham clearly not ready for AFL. Gawn looks like he’s done with this rabble of a team for the season and now poor Oscar has to have his confidence destroyed further by rucking against Grundy. 

[McQueen 17,864]

I’m slow roasting a pork belly this afternoon. 

[Megatron 834]

13 minutes ago, wizardinoz said:

Jeez the filth are an ordinary team but we are just pure [censored]. Where is Track this quarter?

In the forward line. Where the ball hasn’t been. 

Dont you even think about start laying into him.

[FireInTheBennelly 4,026]

If that's the 'Melbourne' quarter, I'll take it.

[binman 38,831]

 

His kicking turnovers have nothing to do with up field turnovers. For exame hs kick to Grundy came after he had marked the ball. Had all the time in the world and still miskicked. Poor technique.

Maybe I am being a bit tough on him. But Lever is our highest paid player and he is being killed by mioeck and his kicking is a real issue.

[Cheap Seats 3,303]

Cant defend 

Cant score

Good to see we are consistent, boys deserve some credit for that

[bing181 8,200]

1 minute ago, Jaded said:

I reckon JHK has done more than Gus, Jones and Oliver today to be honest. 

Don't disagree - but for whatever reason, he's often a really poor decision maker once he gets it.

[The Stigga 884]

Just now, binman said:

 

His kicking turnovers have nothing to do with up field turnovers. For exame hs kick to Grundy came after he had marked the ball. Had all the time in the world and still miskicked. Poor technique.

Maybe I am being a bit tough on him. But Lever is our highest paid player and he is being killed by mioeck and his kicking is a real issue.

Don't disagree, he's not the only one. Oliver kicked it out on the fall from a free kick with no pressure. And he's going to be on a hell of a lot more money than Lever in a year or two.

 

[FireInTheBennelly 4,026]

11 minutes ago, olisik said:

Nathan Jones 0 tackles again. 2nd week running. Yet his quabbling about 260K

Agreed, doesn't really have a 'show me the money' look about it does it.

[3Dee 1,153]

For a brief moment I thought OMAC was going to take the backup ruck job, then it all went pear shaped. 

Goodwin should head to the Genius Bar in the offseason and trade in OMAC for an iMac and design a new gameplan for 2020 success.

[Earl Hood 5,806]

1 minute ago, binman said:

 

His kicking turnovers have nothing to do with up field turnovers. For exame hs kick to Grundy came after he had marked the ball. Had all the time in the world and still miskicked. Poor technique.

Maybe I am being a bit tough on him. But Lever is our highest paid player and he is being killed by mioeck and his kicking is a real issue.

We were set up for the switch too. He is supposed to be looking for that, instead kicked straight down  to Grundy leading to a Pies goal. 

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

4 minutes ago, binman said:

 

His kicking turnovers have nothing to do with up field turnovers. For exame hs kick to Grundy came after he had marked the ball. Had all the time in the world and still miskicked. Poor technique.

Maybe I am being a bit tough on him. But Lever is our highest paid player and he is being killed by mioeck and his kicking is a real issue.

You pick up only on his turnovers. 

I don't get it. 

Yes, he most definitely needs to tidy up his kicking at times but think about how many goals or opportunities at goal he has saved by either making a genuine killer spoil, intercept marking or out-bodying his opponent to mark. 

Lever has been very very good this game aside from a few kicking blunders. 

Edited August 10, 2019 by stevethemanjordan

[Deesprate 1,185]

3 minutes ago, Jaded said:

I reckon JHK has done more than Gus, Jones and Oliver today to be honest. 

Melksham clearly not ready for AFL. Gawn looks like he’s done with this rabble of a team for the season and now poor Oscar has to have his confidence destroyed further by rucking against Grundy. 

You obviously missed where he turned the ball over and cost us a goal. JKH no future at all

[chookrat 3,778]

27 minutes ago, olisik said:

Can’t beleive we payed 2 first rounders for Lever. Is constantly in no mans land.

I feel alot more comfortable with Hore rather than Lever as our third tall.  This said you don't play someone like Lever in the VFL for more than a week or two and will be better for the run. 

[The Stigga 884]

Just now, FireInTheBelly said:

Agreed, doesn't really have a 'show me the money' look about it does it.

Could be having a semi-retirement up at Surfers Paradise for a few years...

 

 

[beelzebub 22,269]

Quite a fascinating  reverse of fortunes

1st qtr. We actually  looked half way decen as we controlled the ball...couldn't  kick for [censored] but hey. Still ...looked much better.  But interestingly still a single paced qtr.

2nd qtr Filth worked out how to break our wall...just up the tempo and work rate and our dubious fragile skills all fall apart.  Filth vary the tempo a little finding theirway through and we start fluffing and fumbling like schoolkids again.

Very few of our lot have good vision. Talj about putting your mates under the gun !!

Need to make some moves now. .or over red rover.

[praha 10,314]

On the plus side Omac actually looked decent up forward...in the first quarter. 

[John Crow Batty 8,285]

8 minutes ago, olisik said:

0 tackles for Jones in the last 2 matches. Not going to win when our captain is producing [censored] like that. Completely in self preservation mode.

0 pressure whatsoever, whoever is on Jones knows he isn’t at risk of being caught.

And only 2 tackles from the last five games.

[dimmy 1,140]

3 minutes ago, Deecisive said:

what the hell is oscar doing out there, he is a joke as a ruckman. lever if his is not kicking to our opponents his crashing the pack taking out our own players without getting the ball out of bounds. Jones, well what can you say about nothing. turnovers are killing us again and again, when will they learn

Bit harsh on Oscar. He has been serviceable. TRac  disappeared that quarter  because Hibberd Viney and Lever are stuffing up "the connectivity"

In fact Oscar has been competitive in Fwd line. Provides a bigger target. He will be handy as backup swingman.

Lever seems only good when he ia by himself , not a strong 1 on 1 . Hibberd has lost pace and confidence. JKH, Wagner both compeitive and committed.

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

1 minute ago, Deesprate said:

You obviously missed where he turned the ball over and cost us a goal. JKH no future at all

Yeh. About as good as Gus's handball to that invisible guy we have playing... 

[The Stigga 884]

1 minute ago, Deesprate said:

You obviously missed where he turned the ball over and cost us a goal. JKH no future at all

Unfortunately the first thing I thought when he kicked it.

[Demon Dynasty 15,770]

4 minutes ago, —coach— said:

And our forward line is brimming with talent atm is it?

We would be as close to par with the current Pies forward line as you are ever likely to see in this team's generation coach and they blew us away in 20 minutes of bog ordinary footy.

If you wish to delude yourself that everything will be fine because a year date will change on a calender that is your prerogative.

Oscar into the ruck and HF?  What  possible benefit / message is that sending the rest of the playing group?

I know what i would be thinking.

Maybe we should rename ourselves the Melbourne Excuses?  How about the DumbAzzes?  The Rabbles?

[frankie_d 1,410]

7 minutes ago, Jaded said:

I reckon JHK has done more than Gus, Jones and Oliver today to be honest. 

Melksham clearly not ready for AFL. Gawn looks like he’s done with this rabble of a team for the season and now poor Oscar has to have his confidence destroyed further by rucking against Grundy. 

I wonder if max has a hand/wrist injury

[olisik 4,060]

Never seen a player get so many life lines like OMac. Could take your pick at any VFL player and they would perform better. It’s utterly bizarre