2 hours ago, Wiseblood said:

Which means what? You seem to be trying to insinuate something off one piece of play. 

He seemed to be a little disheartened for the whole game although played okay which is just his ability but in your one piece of play it really showed.

The thing with Brayshaw is that he can't play anywhere else bar midfield.

Angus Brayshaw will come into the side soon enough and it won't be after a concussion or an another injury , it will be because he is ready to come in  fresh and.... injury free ! Got a gig late in the season after missing many games because of concussion and off the HBF and held his own. He is a young gun no doubt about that.

Looking forward to seeing him back very soon. Maybe as soon as the NM game.

 

Hopefully this week's team will make that impossible

I've made the decision to stop  complaining about selection. 

In my opinion, the concussions have set him back a fair way. It seems as if he’s starting to get back to his best form, though. He is a gun, but still has to prove himself, like everybody else, and earn his spot. He probably looks [censored] off, because he’s running around at Casey this week, when he thinks he’s done enough to warrant selection. Hopefully, it’ll just make him hungrier - I think we’ll see him back for the MFC before long.

2 hours ago, KingDingAling said:

The thing with Brayshaw is that he can't play anywhere else bar midfield.

Really? What a lot of rubbish.

Granted, he's not likely to play ruck or a key position, but with about 10 years potentially left in his career you don't think he could develop into a rebounding hbf or a high half fwd? I certainly think barring injury he could.

But I'm sure we'd all like him to succeed in the midfield.

Perhaps he had to complete a game post his surgery to be eligible for selection?

there is a lot of guesswork about his non-selection.  Maybe someone should ask the question.  I’m sure brayshaw knows why.

He has shown what he is capable of, and will get back there.  He gets paid as an AFL player even if he sits in the stands and watches.  Who the hell would be despondent with that?

On 30/03/2018 at 7:14 PM, KingDingAling said:

The thing with Brayshaw is that he can't play anywhere else bar midfield.

He played of the half back last year and did so successfully. I think he’s a far better prospect in that position than Wagner.

On 3/30/2018 at 6:06 PM, jumbo returns said:

I think he needs to get a good run at it

He does jr. 

But he needs to 'kick the door in'  prior to.  He hasn't played a game for points, just yet.

 

I would wait until after the 1st game in the VFL, and see how he goes under some heat first.

5 minutes ago, DV8 said:

He does jr. 

But he needs to 'kick the door in'  prior to.  He hasn't played a game for points, just yet.

 

I would wait until after the 1st game in the VFL, and see how he goes under some heat first.

Fair enough

On 30/03/2018 at 9:30 PM, buck_nekkid said:

Perhaps he had to complete a game post his surgery to be eligible for selection?

there is a lot of guesswork about his non-selection.  Maybe someone should ask the question.  I’m sure brayshaw knows why.

He has shown what he is capable of, and will get back there.  He gets paid as an AFL player even if he sits in the stands and watches.  Who the hell would be despondent with that?

After multiple concussions and then wisdom teeth out, having one week out and then a run in the twos makes sense.

Would be good to see him get half a dozen games in the ones, as part of centre rotation, and see what he can do.

He deserves an injury free season, so we can see what he can deliver.

 

9 hours ago, Dee Dee said:

He played of the half back last year and did so successfully. I think he’s a far better prospect in that position than Wagner.

If he was good at it he would be still there. He wasn't good enough at it to keep his position. Brayshaw is an out and out midfielder, and is actually a quite capable one. He does need to make some adjustments - in order to limit his potential for head knocks - but if he can do that (and it looks as though he is making inroads there), then there is a position for him in the midfield. He would be better than Salem (who is unwilling to actually go in and get the footy and prefers to sit stationary off of the pack). Brayshaw shouldn't be disappointed that he is at VFL, but should use it as an opportunity to work on his game because that third midfield spot is up for the taking (Tyson isn't good enough - lacks awareness and is a poor kick), and Salem is unwilling to go in and get the football. Until Viney gets back its there for the taking. I hope Brayshaw steps up because he is capable, he is the guy who would do well in that spot and clearly wants it.

It was a tiring game last night and North have had longer to get over their last game. We will bring in fresh legs and probably Brayshaw will get his chance again and be among the ins.

A real positive for us is that we now have depth and can bring in fresh players without destroying the basic makeup of the team. 

Edited April 1, 20187 yr by Redleg

His best ever game was his return game against St Kilda last year where his marking was a highlight.

At the very least he could come in and play as a forward, he wouldn't be any worse than Bugg.

4 minutes ago, Redleg said:

It was a tiring game last night and North have had longer to get over their last game. We will bring in fresh legs and probably Brayshaw will get his chance again and be among the ins.

A real positive for us is that we now have depth and can bring in fresh players without destroying the basic makeup of the team. 

If he did get a run (not sure he will) I'm wondering whether Goodwin would consider assigning him an out an out run with role?

If you're short of a run and a little down on confidence it's not the worst thing to have to do...imo

 

5 minutes ago, Return to Glory said:

If he did get a run (not sure he will) I'm wondering whether Goodwin would consider assigning him an out an out run with role?

If you're short of a run and a little down on confidence it's not the worst thing to have to do...imo

 

I think Gus is a see ball get ball player and not a tagger, not that he couldn't do the job if asked.   

4 minutes ago, Redleg said:

I think Gus is a see ball get ball player and not a tagger, not that he couldn't do the job if asked.   

You may well be right Redleg. I worry for Gus. I'm not entirely sure why but I connect his concussion situation with Jack Trengove's injury issues. They're not the same, I know, but it niggles away, perhaps irrationally so.

Edited April 1, 20187 yr by Return to Glory

He will surely get his chance next week. He can play half forward, half back or through the middle, and there are a handful of players in those positions he could come in for and replace.

On 3/30/2018 at 3:14 PM, Lucifer's Hero said:

He is out of contract this year so if the club rates him they need to either give him games consistently or sign him up on a new contract.  Otherwise, there will be a few suitors out there talking to his manager.

We have re-contracted all the players who can be considered his peers so he is the only one still on the shelf.

I really rate him, he is much more than depth and would hate for him to look elsewhere.

Didn't take long for other clubs to come sniffing -

"Angus Brayshaw’s non-selection for the first three rounds of the season has also led to seven rival clubs showing various levels of interest in the out-of-contract ball-winner, whose brothers — Hamish and Andrew — live in Perth and play for West Coast and Fremantle respectively....The Dockers are believed to be one of these clubs keeping a close eye on the concussion-plagued Brayshaw.

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/fremantle-poised-to-make-bigmoney-moves-for-jeremy-mcgovern-and-jesse-hogan-with-an-eye-on-angus-brayshaw/news-story/e1b90ef950ed62a9db2ee841a96000c4

The writer does add that "... there is no suggestion Brayshaw wants out but...the lure of consistent opportunities could prove to be a decisive factor in weighing up his future".

It was good to see Gus play a really good first up game yesterday.  Let's hope the coaches keep playing him to give him some consistency, which he hasn't had for several years for a variety of reasons.

 

Note - I have ignored the speculation about Hogan in that article.  It is a repeat of the same stuff year after year and Freo will continue to ask.

Edited April 16, 20187 yr by Lucifer's Hero

If we can get a first round pick for Brayshaw I couldn’t sign the paperwork fast enough 

Just don’t rate him

Edited April 16, 20187 yr by DemonAndrew

8 minutes ago, DemonAndrew said:

If we can get a first round pick for him I couldn’t sign the paperwork fast enough 

Just don’t rate him

This is news to me.

8 minutes ago, DemonAndrew said:

If we can get a first round pick for him I couldn’t sign the paperwork fast enough 

Just don’t rate him

This is news to me.

15 minutes ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

Didn't take long for other clubs to come sniffing -

"Angus Brayshaw’s non-selection for the first three rounds of the season has also led to seven rival clubs showing various levels of interest in the out-of-contract ball-winner, whose brothers — Hamish and Andrew — live in Perth and play for West Coast and Fremantle respectively....The Dockers are believed to be one of these clubs keeping a close eye on the concussion-plagued Brayshaw.

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/fremantle-poised-to-make-bigmoney-moves-for-jeremy-mcgovern-and-jesse-hogan-with-an-eye-on-angus-brayshaw/news-story/e1b90ef950ed62a9db2ee841a96000c4

The writer does add that "... there is no suggestion Brayshaw wants out but...the lure of consistent opportunities could prove to be a decisive factor in weighing up his future".

It was good to see Gus play a really good first up game yesterday.  Let's hope the coaches keep playing him to give him some consistency, which he hasn't had for several years for a variety of reasons.

 

Note - I have ignored the speculation about Hogan in that article.  It is a repeat of the same stuff year after year and Freo will continue to ask.

I thought he was average at best. He started the game really well then faded out badly and was slow and poor with his disposal as he often is. If he doesn't show some drastic improvement this season, I would be more than happy to hear what other clubs would be willing to part with.

It is quite damning that with Tyson and Viney out that he still couldn't find his way into our midfield rotation. If he is not an inside midfielder, what is he?

Brayshaw not Hogan, obviously 

Pretty sure that Hogan will be a free agent at the end of 2019, which is a bit scary