195 cm 90Kg Defender/Forward may be a good back up player. Any positives ?

No

Probably.....not.

Couldn't get a gig at Carlton, was it injury or simply not good enough? 

 

2 minutes ago, Demon77 said:

Probably.....not.

Couldn't get a gig at Carlton, was it injury or simply not good enough? 

 

I didn't see much of him, but if my Carlton mates rants re ex GWS spuds are anything to go by, then i am guessing the latter

Spuddiest spud that ever spudded.  Won't be seen at AFL level again.

They kept Liam Jones and delisted this guy. I think that tells you all you need to know. 

We need a spud thread on the board so you can ask about it there. This bloke ain't up to it. 

Can't get a game at a [censored] club, would be Ben Kennedy over again.

2 hours ago, ENYAW said:

195 cm 90Kg Defender/Forward may be a good back up player. Any positives ?

Yes, he is not ours.

2 hours ago, Demon77 said:

Probably.....not.

Couldn't get a gig at Carlton, was it injury or simply not good enough? 

 

Summed it up in your last 4 words.

Worth Jaksch s**t

Liam Hulett is a better prospect and we will likely delist him

he is softer than watts

Giants used Pick 12, Carlton effectively used pick 7 to get him. 

We are clearly not the only ones who have made costly mistakes with draft picks.

Unlikely to play again id say.

7 hours ago, ENYAW said:

195 cm 90Kg Defender/Forward may be a good back up player. Any positives ?

With hand on heart ENYAW, I have not seen a worse player to get a game of AFL in the last three years. The very worst example of Silvani's GWS off-cuts plan.

1 hour ago, Return to Glory said:

With hand on heart ENYAW, I have not seen a worse player to get a game of AFL in the last three years. The very worst example of Silvani's GWS off-cuts plan.

Is it a record that a spud of the highest order went for a first round draft pick twice?

 why is it whenever a spud is delisted from another club somebody always put them  up to be drafted by us,  discount spuds delisted by crappy clubs like Carlton.

No. Think Dawes but worse

No no no......no no no.

My answer is no.

P.s  No!

Spud 

My god.... Do we need to start a thread on every delisted/retired player.. This bloke wouldn't get a kick in div 2 ammos 

Edit: make it div 3 ammos

Edited September 6, 20178 yr by JV7

No no no no no

Harsh on the Ammo's but definite NO he is soft

Makes Watts look like the most fearsome player in the league...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Let's get him. 

 

Another one of these spuds where people had apoplexy last time he was on the market because the MFC couldn't secure his services. That the Lord we couldn't get him then, We certainly don't want him now.