Max is only going about as far as his mum's cafe. Loch it in

36 minutes ago, mo64 said:

Jack Watts......

Oh yeah... the forgotten man!

I want to win a flag AND keep max and jack

15 minutes ago, demondame said:

I want to win a flag AND keep max and jack

Agreed - but only if that increases our chances of winning a flag.

Jack clearly has one or two traits that tip him toward the marginal deficit side of value in Goodwin's eyes. And since the St Kilda game, we have learned that Max has one or two elements to his rucking that bring him back to the pack in the league.

My suggestion here allows for all recruitment and list scenarios, some of which may exclude Jack and/or Max, and may increase the chances of us nabbing a flag: I want to win a flag AND keep max and jack

At the end of the day; a flag is our objective and that is all that matters.
 

2 hours ago, DSP said:

If they trade Max we better be getting one hell of a deal. And I dont mean Lever.

I think if we trade Max it's only because we know their (the AFL in all their wisdom) not only going to do away with the bounce but also get rid of throwing the ball up altogether. At the start of every quarter the ball will be placed in the middle of the center square and both teams will nominate 4 players who have to sprint in to pick the ball up off the ground, they'll also implement the last touch out of bounds rule. At stoppages the umpires will be very quick to call holding the ball, and if they can't decide, each team can nominate 1 player each and they'll arm wrestle to determine who gets the ball. 

Please create a weird trade fantasy page if you want to talk about trading Max, because even putting it in the rumour file is a massive stretch. (not having a go at you DSP, not sure who started this carp)  

There isn't much point worrying about Hogan leaving. 1. If he did we would get a good deal. 2. If he wanted to leave he'd be no use to us anyway. 3. If he wants to stay he is obviously committed and wants to play.

Hogan isn't the type of player to play for us if he doesn't want to. So there is no point even worrying.

I am more interested in what the go is with the Jack Watts and Christian Salem rumors, and if there is anything to them. There has been talk on here, and in the media about Watts and Salem being up for trade.

Honestly, this thread is showing too many people have more time on their hands than brains.

6 hours ago, Akum said:

At this time of the year, it's all trying to stir the possum to get attention. It's like a ritual.

And everybody remembers the one in ten they might fluke right, while nobody remembers the many stupid guesses they got wrong.

I don't guess thanks, i make up

I'd consider it pretty disrespectful to Jesse and the MFC if there's any truth about the WA clubs asking the question regards Hogan again - particularly after the year he's had. 

What a way to put further weight on his emotions.

Barrett probably got his intel from Brad Hardie if the muppet didn't make it up himself.

I have heard Griffen might be a chance of joining us 

1 hour ago, dimmy said:

Honestly, this thread is showing too many people have more time on their hands than brains.

You sound like my missus.

9 minutes ago, Demons11 said:

I have heard Griffen might be a chance of joining us 

Another move that would make little sense to me.  We have no need of a bloke who is at the tail end of his career and injured all the time.

44 minutes ago, Wiseblood said:

Another move that would make little sense to me.  We have no need of a bloke who is at the tail end of his career and injured all the time.

Not to mention that Griffen (assuming it's Ryan)  wouldn't want anything to do with the guy who coached the Dogs at the time he left them for GWS.

Edited September 25, 20177 yr by Akum

45 minutes ago, Demons11 said:

I have heard Griffen might be a chance of joining us 

His natural progression is from GWS NEAFL to Carlton.

I'd imagine that he's on big coin and GWS are trying to offload him for next to nothing. I'd still pass.

On 21/09/2017 at 10:35 PM, beelzebub said:

 

Hang on a sec. Which Griffen? Freo's or GWS's?

Not that it makes much difference

Edited September 25, 20177 yr by Roger Mellie
Not a response to Bzbub

Aren't we talking about Stewie Griffin?

5 minutes ago, demonstone said:

Aren't we talking about Stewie Griffin?

Ah good we can use his time machine

15 minutes ago, deebug said:

Ah good we can use his time machine

Now if the time machine could bring us the Ryan Griffen of 2013 ...

Edited September 25, 20177 yr by Akum
Poor understanding of time machines

30 minutes ago, Roger Mellie said:

Hang on a sec. Which Griffen? Freo's or GWS's?

Not that it makes much difference

GWS

Turns 32 midway thru 2018

You'd want to effectively give up nada for him and have GW$ cover the majority of his salary in their cap, which would probably defeat the purpose of them offloading him 

Maybe it's as a coach? No way as a player way too passed it.

Ryan Griffen lol. Who comes up with this stuff? 

9 minutes ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

Ryan Griffen lol. Who comes up with this stuff? 

Mrs Griffen

As if Griffin would join the club his former coach Mcartney is at, don't they hate each other?