If you listen to the reports coming through on the radio. Buckley is set to know his future after the game this Saturday. I see it happening like this.

Scenario 1- A decision is made to sack him and it gets leaked out to the players and they are shattered and turn out a performance along the lines of Melbourne's infamous 186 pt loss to Geelong.. Doubtfully that bad but say we beat them by 10 goals!

2- Melbourne come out as fired up as we did against Port adelaide and Stkilda and then go on with it and crush those flogs and force Eddie's hand!

3- Melbourne lose and the 4 horse men reclaim the earth..

I'm hoping the first scenario occurs!

Edited August 22, 20177 yr by Grapeviney

Sc you want us to lose?

Love the idea of scenario 1 but I can't see a board like theirs and a president like Eddie doing things like that.

no way Buckley is gone

Eddie is inextricably linked to him. Everyone else around them is going. That's the way Eddie rolls

1 minute ago, jnrmac said:

no way Buckley is gone

Eddie is inextricably linked to him. Everyone else around them is going. That's the way Eddie rolls

That's where Scenario 2 comes into play!!

2 year deal coming up for Bucks.  no doubt

if he was going to be sacked, he would have seen the writing on the wall.  he seems very calm

good news all round for us

Saturday's result will have nothing to do with their decision.

buckley and mcchins to stay entwined. 2 year deal sounds most sensible

probably the wrong decision given record, only time will tell

53 minutes ago, jnrmac said:

no way Buckley is gone

Eddie is inextricably linked to him. Everyone else around them is going. That's the way Eddie rolls

Agree 'jnr'...funny that the media are now talking about whether it's about Buckley being a success or Collingwood a success.

When the argument really comes down to proving Eddie right and his ego won't let go.

It's going to be interesting to see who if anyone stands up to him. I think Pert may have and failed.

Edited August 22, 20177 yr by rjay

A draw would still guarantee our finals spot while also sending Collingwood into mental breakdown with indecision.

1 hour ago, daisycutter said:

Saturday's result will have nothing to do with their decision.

buckley and mcchins to stay entwined. 2 year deal sounds most sensible

probably the wrong decision given record, only time will tell

Whilst their seems screaming logic to this , I'm not so convinced. There comes a time....so the words go. There's only SO much any club can stomach.

I wonder how much irony will come to be appreciated about Sat's game from a Pie perspective ?  i.e  It's US playing on into Sept glory, whilst they aren't even also rans, they are the  crud that makes up the rubble we stand upon. That will gnaw at them intensely.

 

Should Sat go to current plans and I sit among ex Pies  whilst watching them squirm as we have them on toast I might just be able to garner a sense of what their inner sanctum are experiencing.

What a great day looms

16 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

 

What a great day looms

let's [censored] hope so, bub

 Buckley and Eddie are so delusional they think they're close to top 4 and a premiership so Buckley gets another 3 years

I really really want him to stay so he drives them further into the ground. I wonder who the next aging injury prone over 30 player he will recruit this year?

2 hours ago, Little Goffy said:

A draw would still guarantee our finals spot while also sending Collingwood into mental breakdown with indecision.

Heart can't take another dramatic finish. Seems to be happening regularly. Prefer we are streets ahead at 3 quarter time.

I'm tipping they keep Buckley and replace the assistant's, similar to what Richmond did last year.

I hope they lose badly to us but he's kept on as coach anyway.
I quite like Buckley - he speaks well & is pretty forthright. Good to listen to
I like even more the trajectory that Collingwood have been on during his tenure and I would like to see him continue that fine work

 

3 hours ago, rjay said:

Agree 'jnr'...funny that the media are now talking about whether it's about Buckley being a success or Collingwood a success.

When the argument really comes down to proving Eddie right and his ego won't let go.

It's going to be interesting to see who if anyone stands up to him. I think Pert may have and failed.

Buckley has finished lower each year he has coached I think. And he took over a GF team.

So its clear he hasn't performed.

Eddie will lose so much face if Bucks goes so it won't happen however there will be other sacrificial lambs. 

Pretty unusual and narrow minded to have a coach's position being in any way tied to last game of season.

I think Buckley's position is safe and i also listen and have respect with what he says. Thought with most positions on coaching, they have usually either handed over, or the event happens with several games to go, to "bed in the incoming".

I never get why other clubs supporters want him gone, blows my mind. Easiest 4 or even 8 points you can get

I laugh if Bucks if offered 2 years, he rejects it and takes on the Suns gig.

9 minutes ago, david_neitz_is_my_dad said:

I never get why other clubs supporters want him gone, blows my mind. Easiest 4 or even 8 points you can get

I actually think he's an okay coach. Their fall down the ladder probably should have been swifter bevause now they've just been lingering mid table for a few years. Imo they haven't really rebuilt yet.

1 hour ago, Clint Bizkit said:

I'm tipping they keep Buckley and replace the assistant's, similar to what Richmond did last year.

Hardwick was already contracted.  To dispense with his services would have seriously hurt Richmond's ledger so they went the way they did. Seems to have worked ( for them ).

Different at WobblyWorld. So they don't have to go this way at all. They could well get a new fresh start...and build a dept around whoever..

I dont really care as long as the filth stay down where they belong

There is nothing more certain than them retaining Buckley; win, lose or draw.

Heads will roll all around him, but not his.

Like straight after the game? As the club song rings out? Eddie up in the stands Roman Colosseum style with a thumbs up or down on FIGJAM's fate? I need to set my VCR.