1 hour ago, Win4theAges said:

Maynard out way out of his depth.

Thought he worked his way into the game really well.

2 minutes ago, CBDees said:

Melksham got two goals and you want to drop him??Not sure what that is about? ?

Will get suspended.

For me it would be...

Melk - susp

Peders and Frost out...

Hannan, Stretch and ? in

Tommy Mac back, Watts to relieve in ruck (gets more involved with a run in the ruck), small forward line better than the mish mash we had today.

Brayshaw in

7 minutes ago, At the break of Gawn said:

Apparently he's likely to be suspended

Why?   What did some of us miss? Was watching in a pub without sound

Edited August 5, 20178 yr by Satyriconhome

To disappointed to write and decent comments at this juncture, where has our intensity around the ball gone!!!!!

Those calling watts out I understand, but he was better than pedo who offered nothing, and he got better. Get him in as relief ruck, he needs to be around the ball.

Badly needed run, reckon we missed Hannan. What's going on with Hunt?

Out: Melbourne

in: Casey

4 minutes ago, watchtheeyes said:

Those calling watts out I understand, but he was better than pedo who offered nothing, and he got better. Get him in as relief ruck, he needs to be around the ball.

Badly needed run, reckon we missed Hannan. What's going on with Hunt?

He's stopped running and Petracca has stopped kicking. 

Frost, Watts, Hunt all poor. They weren't alone either

Hunt gets a pass as he has been ok recently. But who do we bring in? No talls to speak of

I don't remember a kick from Nathan jones that didn't go straight to a giants player. Was just really dumb footy by us today

No point making massive changes, just shuffling deck chairs. We need continuity and more height up forward so Weeds I suspect will come in for Watts, who seems set for a VFL run. Pedo may go otherwise. Brayshaw for Melksham is probably the only straight swap I can think of.

Why bring Stretch in? 

Wats has to go.

He has reverted to his pre 2016 self.  And that means we are playing  a man down each week.

So disappointing to see how bad hes been.

Hannan, Brayshaw and JKH to come in. Watts, Pederson and Harmes out. I doubt we will see Pedo again and If Goidwin is fair dinkum he will send Watts a message, delivered at the end of his boot.

Edited August 5, 20178 yr by chook fowler

42 minutes ago, Satyriconhome said:

Why?   What did some of us miss? Was watching in a pub without sound

Head high contact with a bump 

53 minutes ago, rjay said:

For me it would be...

Melk - susp

Peders and Frost out...

Hannan, Stretch and ? in

Tommy Mac back, Watts to relieve in ruck (gets more involved with a run in the ruck), small forward line better than the mish mash we had today.

Thought the same thing about dropping Frost and putting TMac back. 

Would consider picking Weid.

I didn't get to see the game as I was watching Casey play but if the MFC need to bring in a KPP, going off his last month and especially today's game, Keilty might be a sneak for a debut.

I know I'm biased, but he was unbelievable today, played both forward and back and dominated both positions. Was easily the best game he has ever played. 

Pedo out Weeds in Melksham out susp Brayshaw in

44 minutes ago, wizardinoz said:

Why bring Stretch in? 

Because he can kick and handball.

23 minutes ago, Drunkn167 said:

I didn't get to see the game as I was watching Casey play but if the MFC need to bring in a KPP, going off his last month and especially today's game, Keilty might be a sneak for a debut.

I know I'm biased, but he was unbelievable today, played both forward and back and dominated both positions. Was easily the best game he has ever played. 

Can't hurt to give the kid a game, he may be just what we need.

1 hour ago, Deemented Are Go! said:

Out: Melbourne

in: Casey

Casey is full of players that when they played in the firsts, most here were happy to see the back of.

29 minutes ago, bing181 said:

Casey is full of players that when they played in the firsts, most here were happy to see the back of.

Um, it was a gag, fella. Just thought their win today was pretty awesome! 

What an amazing effort by Salem. Came back on after breaking his fibula! According to a couple of posters at least!

Out Watts

In Ben Kennedy

Kennedy would be the hungriest bastard on our list and will fight tooth and nail.. Would at the worst give effort and Probly enjoy kicking goals!