Jones - great second quarter

Viney - unsighted when needed

Salem - was always composed

Watts - hugely disappointing again

Petracca - believed his publicity 

Lewis - provided great direction 

Tyson - most overrated footballer 

Oliver - prolific but wasteful

Hibbert - was outstanding again

Kent - waste of space

Frost - iffy but important 

Hannan - our only forward

Pedersen - no heroics today

Vince - had no influence 

T.McDonald - versatile but limited

Weideman - probably wasn't playing

O.McDonald  - never inspired confidence 

Hunt - obviously still suffering

Bugg - regularly wasted chance

Garlett - just a spectator 

Jetta - reliable and effective

Wagner - was he playing?

 

Umps -blind as always

Kent - fat and lazy

Big Head Syndrome

Not tough enough

Bugg/Frost/OMac/Weed/Wagner/File/Kent = not premiership players

MFC - Too many passengers.

Midfield - taught a lesson

North - Outplayed us today

 

....and need to get this off my chest

Nicholls - You bald ....Kent/Hunt

Hard for forwards to play well when the mids over handball then slam it on the boot after north flooded back.

Love a ruckmen.

• Bit hard on Pedersen- against AA Ruckman
• Tyson : Better today
• Hannan : Best game/ Competitive
• OMac/Frosty: Learning . Some great efforts by both.
• TMac : Has enormous responsibilities
• Watts : Needs to impose more but efficient when ball in hand
• Jetta : Just as well we have got him
• Midfield : Forwards need better delivery
• Forwards:Somtimes you make your own luck
• Defenders: "Lace outs" are hard to stop
• Onballers: Hard day at office
• "Ruckmen": He is BIG!!!/and can play/Max is better

Hannan- I was impressed 

Watts ------has no passion.

Ump 15-------------best on ground

We stuffed around with the ball in the first quarter, then went more direct in the second, only to revert back to the same bull[censored] in the third.

Dumb football and dumb coaching all round. Starting McDonald forward was a big mistake, just because it worked last week doesn't mean it always will.

Pedo i thought did a fantastic job, so a bit harsh on him Joeboy. A pity he only had a couple more that gave their all for the entire match.

 

Kent was pathetic, he doesn't get enough of it to be a mid, yet cannot apply defensive pressure in the forward half. He is a man of no position. Bring in Harmes for him next week.

Weideman is nowhere near the quality of an AFL player yet (still needs to develop a tonne, and find a spine), stick him at Casey for the rest of the year, as he lacks both the required skill and appetite AFL requires.

OMAC has no good games, he either has bad one's or ok one's. He gave away 4 free kicks today (all of which were there) and 6 clangers, so he is either clueless or just a stupid footballer. You don't build backlines around these types of player's. With the likes of TMAC, OMAC and Frost as our KPD's, we probably have one of the worst defences in the league. Lever can't get here quick enough.

Jeffy through in one of his classic 'bad' performances today. He has more better days than bad days, but his bad days really are bad.

Watts, Salem, Petracca, Wagner (he's never going to be an AFL quality player - so why bother), Vince and Hunt were all below par.

Hard to win when more than half your team put in less than average performances. Dees caught drinking their own bathwater again.

 

GOODWIN - Out Coached Again

2 minutes ago, MrMoose said:

GOODWIN - Out Coached Again

He also needs to work on motivating the team. If they continue not to listen, make changes.

1 hour ago, Demon Disciple said:

We stuffed around with the ball in the first quarter, then went more direct in the second, only to revert back to the same bull[censored] in the third.

Dumb football and dumb coaching all round. Starting McDonald forward was a big mistake, just because it worked last week doesn't mean it always will.

Pedo i thought did a fantastic job, so a bit harsh on him Joeboy. A pity he only had a couple more that gave their all for the entire match.

 

Kent was pathetic, he doesn't get enough of it to be a mid, yet cannot apply defensive pressure in the forward half. He is a man of no position. Bring in Harmes for him next week.

Weideman is nowhere near the quality of an AFL player yet (still needs to develop a tonne, and find a spine), stick him at Casey for the rest of the year, as he lacks both the required skill and appetite AFL requires.

OMAC has no good games, he either has bad one's or ok one's. He gave away 4 free kicks today (all of which were there) and 6 clangers, so he is either clueless or just a stupid footballer. You don't build backlines around these types of player's. With the likes of TMAC, OMAC and Frost as our KPD's, we probably have one of the worst defences in the league. Lever can't get here quick enough.

Jeffy through in one of his classic 'bad' performances today. He has more better days than bad days, but his bad days really are bad.

Watts, Salem, Petracca, Wagner (he's never going to be an AFL quality player - so why bother), Vince and Hunt were all below par.

Hard to win when more than half your team put in less than average performances. Dees caught drinking their own bathwater again.

 

Hunt was in Melbournes Best.. not sure which game you watched..

Jones - butchered ir

Viney - tried

Salem - fumbled

Watts - a [censored] again

Petracca - Hall of Lame 

Lewis - I'm expecting more 

Tyson - treading water 

Oliver - not his best

Hibbert - needs help

Kent - apt username

Frost - flawed but important 

Hannan - did his job

Pedersen - couldn't expect more

Vince - frigging hell mate 

T.McDonald - a forward;s a-hole

Weideman - 7 more kilos

O.McDonald  - slow motion 

Hunt - decide his position

Bugg - depth

Garlett - first dirty day 

Jetta - not his fault

Wagner - not there yet

2 hours ago, Queanbeyan Demon said:

Bugg/Frost/OMac/Weed/Wagner/File/Kent = not premiership players

Watts not either

Bugg inaccurate inaccurate inaccurate

 

12 hours ago, Queanbeyan Demon said:

Bugg/Frost/OMac/Weed/Wagner/File/Kent = not premiership players

Frost could get a gig in a premiership side. Have a look at all of the premiership players running around in Hawthorn jumpers right now.

Edited May 21, 20178 yr by DominatrixTyson

On 21/05/2017 at 7:36 PM, Demon Disciple said:

He also needs to work on motivating the team. If they continue not to listen, make changes.

Motivation needs to come from within.  A team that needs motivation week in week out; has a huge problem.

 

 

On 5/21/2017 at 6:33 PM, joeboy said:

Tyson - most overrated footballer

You must have a handful of negatives about Tyson that you just slot in every week, regardless of his performance.

On 21/05/2017 at 9:30 PM, ProDee said:

 

Watts - a [censored] again

 

Yawn

On 5/21/2017 at 6:33 PM, joeboy said:

 

Tyson - most overrated footballer 

 

 

What does Tyson have to do for you to give him some credit? granted struggled early on but in recent weeks has started to find his legs again and getting into some space. if the chief concern is still disposal efficiency then you need to have a closer look - 4th in total disposals, 5th in average disposals and while his efficiency is down, Hunt has 40 less touches at 2% better efficiency. he's doing the job Goody and the coaches are asking of him, yes we'd all like a bit more out of him, but he's a massive reason we bat so deep in the midfield.

On 2017-5-21 at 6:33 PM, joeboy said:

Jones - great second quarter

Viney - unsighted when needed

Salem - was always composed

Watts - hugely disappointing again

Petracca - believed his publicity 

Lewis - provided great direction 

Tyson - most overrated footballer 

Oliver - prolific but wasteful

Hibbert - was outstanding again

Kent - waste of space

Frost - iffy but important 

Hannan - our only forward

Pedersen - no heroics today

Vince - had no influence 

T.McDonald - versatile but limited

Weideman - probably wasn't playing

O.McDonald  - never inspired confidence 

Hunt - obviously still suffering

Bugg - regularly wasted chance

Garlett - just a spectator 

Jetta - reliable and effective

Wagner - was he playing?

 

agree with your notations: 

Frankly it is laughable that a  Team can come out and thrash Adelaide yet play so poorly again against Nth Melbourne. 

At the start of the year I held out for more hope than this at week 9