Who's our best chance to win the Rising Star in 2016?

[Demonland 73,844]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-03-30/who-is-your-clubs-best-rising-star-chance

 

Quote

 

Best chance: Clayton Oliver
The powerfully built midfielder became the first player to earn a Rising Star nomination this season after a tremendous first-up display against Greater Western Sydney. So highly do the Demons rate Oliver's clearance ability that he was thrown straight into the middle and he instantly set the tone around stoppages with his 'see ball, get ball' mentality. Oliver, pick No.4 in last year's NAB AFL Draft, had 22 disposals (15 contested), as well as seven clearances. He fits the Demons' desire for 'competitors' and is clearly in Melbourne's best 22 based on his early season performances.

Other contenders: Christian Petracca (yet to debut), James Harmes (nine matches), Oscar McDonald (one game), Sam Weideman (yet to debut).

Past winners: Jesse Hogan (2015), Jared Rivers (2004) - Ben Guthrie 

 

 

[Pates 9,686]

I still think if Petracca is given a clean run for when he debuts he could romp it home. But boy Clarry more than put up his hand!

[Redlegs Too 106]

Can it be a draw at the end? That would be good. 

[Gator 18,012]

If Petracca plays the last 16 games he wins. 

[Ted Lasso 19,566]

I am quite torn, Oliver was brilliant on the weekend and considering he only played what 60% of the game? 

but Petracca is a next level talent, Hogan-like.

I don't think either will win because i don't think either have the fitness to play more than 15 -17 games this year, but both could be good enough to do it just off that as well.

[stuie 7,374]

It's just a total vote at the end of the year isn't it (rather than a round by round thing)?

With Oliver getting the nod first up and possibly fading as the year goes on simply due to his age, you could see Petracca smashing the second half of the season and being fresh in the minds of the voters.

 

[93dee 104]

James Harmes could be a big smokey! Well i'm hoping so... I chucked 10 dollars on him at $151 before the season started

[Redjacket 760]

Without having seen Petracca play a minute of football I'd have to go with Oliver at this stage.

This may change later in the year.

[H_T 3,049]

Petracca has got to improve his fitness first and foremost, gain selection, then get into form. 

Oliver looked well and truly at home against a gun up and coming midfield. With more game time, he'll thrive. 

ATM it's Oliver by a landslide for mine.

[Deeoldfart 8,164]

I voted Clarry, because I've seen what he can do, and I think he has potential 'elite' written all over him.

But I will say this:  if Tracc  ends up ahead of him (barring any mishaps to Clarry), then we will have a potential match-winner of the highest order on our hands, and the future of our great Club looks brighter than it has for 50+ years.

[TeamPlayedFine39 8,525]

I would say our best chance would be Oliver, but a lot of that depends on when Petracca debuts.

I'm expecting at least one of them to be a top five finish, but not expecting a win this year.  I enjoy the Rising Star award and process and see it as a bit of fun and extra level of interest.  My early money would be on Weitering; he's been nothing short of amazing this year.

[Adam The God 30,644]

On 30/03/2016 at 2:32 PM, Peter Griffen said:

I am quite torn, Oliver was brilliant on the weekend and considering he only played what 60% of the game? 

but Petracca is a next level talent, Hogan-like.

I don't think either will win because i don't think either have the fitness to play more than 15 -17 games this year, but both could be good enough to do it just off that as well.

I'll admit I haven't seen Petracca in the flesh yet, but if he's at the level of Oliver, that's exciting enough for me. Clarry is the most exciting player in a Melbourne jumper since Hogan.  But I can really get excited by Clarry, because I know he'll stick around. Until Jesse signs that long term deal, Clarry is the most exciting Melbourne player out there.

Cannot wait to see Petracca play given all the hype surrounding him. I have been disappointed before by hyped Melbourne youngsters in the past though.

Edited April 19, 2016 by AdamFarr

[Redleg 42,043]

On 3/30/2016 at 2:15 PM, ProDee said:

If Petracca plays the last 16 games he wins. 

Agree.

[Skuit 10,031]

That Wagner boy goes alright . . .

[Devil is in the Detail 883]

2 minutes ago, Skuit said:

That Wagner boy goes alright . . .

I think he is too old.

[DeeSpencer 26,480]

I don't think any of them have reached the level that Hogan and Cripps did last year but Weitering, Schache, Mills, Oliver and Parish are all playing amazing football for first year kids. Not sure a top 5 as a group have come in and looked so good. Caleb Daniel might be the best of the 2nd year kids. 

Weitering, Parish and Mills are where I think the winner will come from. Top quality juniors who are really ready for AFL and entrenched in their teams best 22. Being the fat country kid who didn't think he was good enough for AFL 12 months ago will catch up with Clarry I think. But I'd be surprised if he wasn't getting votes at the end of the year. 

Similarly for Petracca, he could do very well in 16 games, he has the talent, but he didn't have a full preseason or a big endurance base to start with and he looks like the type of player who will be very hot and cold in his early games. He isn't going to just play his role like a Weitering or Mills from half back. He's going to take the game on and back himself. 

[Miracle 89]

I just put some money on Petracca at 20 to 1. Think it's great value. 

[Ted Lasso 19,566]

at this stage i'd say Parish is probably just ahead of Oliver and Caleb daniel

[Mega Malt 9]

Everyone thinks Clayton Oliver is gonna win the rising star 2016, but I think Christain Petracca gonna win it.

Edited April 27, 2016 by Mega Malt

[Return to Glory 8,477]

3 minutes ago, Mega Malt said:

Everyone thinks Clayton Oliver is gonna win the rising star 2016, but I think Christain Petrecca gonna win it.

Weitering. Best key position draftee I've seen in a very long time.

[Deestroy All 14,266]

2 minutes ago, Return to Glory said:

Weitering. Best key position draftee I've seen in a very long time.

2015 was months ago.

[Return to Glory 8,477]

4 minutes ago, Deestroy All said:

2015 was months ago.

I probably should have included the word defender. Clanger.

Edited April 25, 2016 by Return to Glory

[Deeoldfart 8,164]

It wouldn't surprise me if J. Hunt, gets a nomination at some stage later in the season (as he gets more comfortable at the level).  I have a feeling that our recruiters may have plucked another definite 'keeper' from nowhere with this kid.  I like the little I have seen, a lot!

[TGR 1,367]

A lot of cocky MFC supporters with a bit of cash.  Petracca has shortened dramatically in the rising star odds.  Second favourite atm, without playing a game.

 

 

 

Diamond Jim Mark II?

[DeeZee 7,463]

It's too early to tell but we will know in about eight weeks time.

As good as I think Oliver is, and he is a gun, my feeling is that Petracca will take the competition by storm.