Could Melbourne have Western Bulldogs-like resurgence in 2016?

[dazzledavey36 49,113]

37 minutes ago, DeeZee said:

People keep mentioning all the Bulldog players that were out.

we had ,

Hogan

Dawes

Lumumba

Brayshaw

Petracca

Stretch

Melksham

jkh

Trengove

Neal bullen 

Spencer

Weideman

out as well , not all world beaters but a pretty handy lot

Lol.....

[DeeZee 6,811]

23 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Lol.....

You wait till Hogan, Petracca and Brayshaw start ripping it up together, you'll be laughing then lol

[Lucifers Hero 37,272]

Peter Jackson at the 2016 Season Launch:  From twitter:

Jackson: We've finished the rebuilding and restructuring of this club. There's no more excuses.

Jackson: We know from a football point of view the journey we're on. We're committed to it and it's going to be a great journey.

Its up to the players now!  As the boss says: no more excuses!

[Bombay Airconditioning 5,956]

9 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Can't see it happening to be honest.

I agree, I think we will improve but we won't make the finals. Still at least 12 months behind them.

[Bombay Airconditioning 5,956]

9 hours ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Can't see it happening to be honest.

I agree, I think we will improve but we won't make the finals. Still at least 12 months behind them.

[jnrmac 19,241]

6 hours ago, Curry & Beer said:

seriously was ONE positive thread too much to ask?

Yep. Can't sugar coat things. It is what it is as Mark Neeld would say.

We won but the performance was poor against a young inexperienced side.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

22 minutes ago, jnrmac said:

Yep. Can't sugar coat things. It is what it is as Mark Neeld would say.

We won but the performance was poor against a young inexperienced side.

it's not a thread about that game, it's about the season coming

your opinion of the game has already been stated 8000 times in other threads

[Sir Why You Little 34,746]

44 minutes ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

Peter Jackson at the 2016 Season Launch:  From twitter:

Jackson: We've finished the rebuilding and restructuring of this club. There's no more excuses.

Jackson: We know from a football point of view the journey we're on. We're committed to it and it's going to be a great journey.

Its up to the players now!  As the boss says: no more excuses!

Right on!

no more excuses....

[DeeSpencer 23,345]

The Dogs:

- Completely changed the way they played

- Won a lot of games and beat some good teams

- Lost an elimination final

I don't think we will change the way we play so drastically. There just hasn't been enough of a talent overhaul nor has their been a radical coaching change. I don't think we will win a lot of games, but who knows if every thing does go right then finals must be a chance. And if we do make finals then who says we can't win one? We'll have a lot of momentum and I think we've got some guys who are built for the big stage.

[Bombay Airconditioning 5,956]

can we please fix the quoting issue.

[beelzebub 22,271]

Actually, we have already shown we'll play quite differently. Much more fwd defensive pressure. Keeping ball in our 50, trying to cause a turnover and pounce. 

I've made mention before of effectively changing our scoreboard by roughly 4.5 goals a game ( scoring  2/3 goals more, saving a couple ) this can all come from this sort of pressure.

I see hope

[Bombay Airconditioning 5,956]

can we please fix the quoting issue.

[Bombay Airconditioning 5,956]

10 hours ago, Petraccattack said:

 

Nice in depth preview.  His ladder is interesting, has Port finishing 14th.  Would like that.  His bottom 4 is likely right.

What odds can I get on Port not finishing 14th?

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

8 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Actually, we have already shown we'll play quite differently. Much more fwd defensive pressure. Keeping ball in our 50, trying to cause a turnover and pounce. 

I've made mention before of effectively changing our scoreboard by roughly 4.5 goals a game ( scoring  2/3 goals more, saving a couple ) this can all come from this sort of pressure.

I see hope

just by virtue of the fact we are transitioning coaches inherently implies a great deal of change

whether it is positive or negative remains to be seen

[jnrmac 19,241]

35 minutes ago, Curry & Beer said:

it's not a thread about that game, it's about the season coming

your opinion of the game has already been stated 8000 times in other threads

Well no it hasn't actually. You might be exaggerating I think. Unusual for you as I usually find your posts pretty factual. And for your information I was responding to another poster so feel free to ignore my posts on the subject.

Just because you started the thread doesn't mean you 'own' the thread. Have a lovely evening.

 

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

1 minute ago, jnrmac said:

Well no it hasn't actually. You might be exaggerating I think. Unusual for you as I usually find your posts pretty factual. And for your information I was responding to another poster so feel free to ignore my posts on the subject.

Just because you started the thread doesn't mean you 'own' the thread. Have a lovely evening.

 

Yeah I wasn't suggesting 8000 times literally. I didn't count them. Sometimes people do that, for effect, it is usually pretty obvious, as it is here. Are you suggesting that 3.5 days after the match that your statements are original ones that haven't already been put out there repeatedly or.....?

[alias275 259]

We just have to play with consistent intensity and do the best we can with our skills. 

That half forward line pressure was a sight for sore eyes. We continue that along with strict game plan execution and we have the youth to repeat what the Bulldogs done. 

GWS are certainly no easy beats anymore and i do not want to be the first team to lose to the top up Dons. Worsfold is a brilliant coach and will get everything out of those players. 

My wish is to be 2 and 0, somewhat top of the ladder and facing the Roos with momentum. 

[BarnDee 287]

dont see why not  

[Coq au vin 754]

10 hours ago, DeeZee said:

There are definate reasons for optimism this season.

Pre season indicates that the players are getting used to the game plan and playing with more purpose and confidence.

Goodwin has added a more attacking element, and our recruiting has added a few more players who should put pressure on for spots.

Hogan, Gawn and Viney are ready to explode, and Oliver looks a genuine star in the making.

Petracca is the trump card....and Jones reckons he is the most powerful young player he has seen on the track .

I think we will be thereabouts, either just in or just out of the eight, but we need a good start with wins against GWS and the Bombers in the first two rounds to get us off to a good start.

 

It's definite not definate.

[Je Roos Salem 661]

2 hours ago, Lucifer's Hero said:

Peter Jackson at the 2016 Season Launch:  From twitter:

Jackson: We've finished the rebuilding and restructuring of this club. There's no more excuses.

Jackson: We know from a football point of view the journey we're on. We're committed to it and it's going to be a great journey.

Its up to the players now!  As the boss says: no more excuses!

At least that's consistent with what he said last year, that 2016 is the year for finals.

The question is not so much if we are good enough but if there's room for us in the 8 given how stable some of the teams at the top are. It'd be fair to say the Cats will go back into the 8, Collingwood are a fair chance too. Also not napping against teams like Carlton, Essendon and St.Kilda (who we play twice at Etihad) would help us be a chance. It'd suck to see us hovering around 11th-14th all season again, that's for sure. We need to get off to a good start to get fans through the gate

[Samael 560]

11 hours ago, Petraccattack said:

 

Nice in depth preview.  His ladder is interesting, has Port finishing 14th.  Would like that.  His bottom 4 is likely right.

Not best pleased with this. To my mind it means we have played a reasonably representative team that will finish 14th and a team of pups. Neither of them we dispatched with anything like a 10th or better team should have. I believe we will finish 10th (cant finish 9th because Richmond). Gawn and our improved mid field is the key. If we can sustain the beard factor we will do well. I for one think that Oliver, if he can control himself will be another factor. Difficult to cover Jones, Viney, Oliver and Michie. They are the imperative to success that and Hogan finishing.  Okay I threw Viv in there as troll bait but his 20 minutes on Sunday did not harm his promotion  prospects.  Some good things to look forward to IMO. Repeat IMO. 

[Samael 560]

11 hours ago, Petraccattack said:

 

Nice in depth preview.  His ladder is interesting, has Port finishing 14th.  Would like that.  His bottom 4 is likely right.

Not best pleased with this. To my mind it means we have played a reasonably representative team that will finish 14th and a team of pups. Neither of them we dispatched with anything like a 10th or better team should have. I believe we will finish 10th (cant finish 9th because Richmond). Gawn and our improved mid field is the key. If we can sustain the beard factor we will do well. I for one think that Oliver, if he can control himself will be another factor. Difficult to cover Jones, Viney, Oliver and Michie. They are the imperative to success that and Hogan finishing.  Okay I threw Viv in there as troll bait but his 20 minutes on Sunday did not harm his promotion  prospects.  Some good things to look forward to IMO. Repeat IMO. 

[Samael 560]

12 hours ago, Petraccattack said:

People keep mentioning all the Bulldog players that were out.

we had ,

Hogan (got to get it to him. First 3 1/4 would have been largely irrelevant)

Dawes  (Comminsure buy )

Lumumba (Comminsure buy) 

Brayshaw (not convinced)

Petracca (has played No games at this level. None, Nahda, nil zilch. I worry that he is going to be another J Watts "the messiah")

Stretch (Still only mediocre at best)

Melksham (dead to me)

jkh (over rated because of 3 goals in another NAB Game 2 years ago)

Trengove (? Would love to see him in full flight. Casey is probably the venue)

Neal bullen (Meh) 

Spencer (injured, not left out.)

Weideman (Not one AFL game yet. Doubt he is as ready this season)

out as well , not all world beaters but a pretty handy lot

Quite honestly match these blokes up in our voting last year. How many were in our top 15? 

However whilst I am not supporting you I also think all you can do is play the team against you. It would be interesting to understand what the FD thinks of theh performance. Did our blokes live up to expectation? In the end I just cant get excited by the NAB Challenge other than its FOOTY!

 

 

[thevil1 421]

^^ I stopped reading at Brayshaw not convinced! Lol 

Port & Cats prospects overrated by some IMO, I don't think either are really that good & won't make finals. IMO.

I think we can sneak into the 8 but likely be around 9th/10th this season with a fairly young core and a couple of finals in 2017. A run like the doggies last or better yet an '87 & better again baby bombers year would be an absolute dream come true though! A lot needs to go right for us though. 

Edited March 9, 2016 by thevil1

[thevil1 421]

^^ I stopped reading at Brayshaw unconvinced! Lol 

Port & Cats prospects overrated by some IMO, I don't think either are really that good & won't make finals. IMO.

I think we can sneak into the 8 but likely be around 9th/10th this season with a fairly young core and a couple of finals in 2017. A run like the doggies last or better yet an '87 & better again baby bombers year would be an absolute dream come true though! A lot needs to go right for us though.