Trade Radio Discussion

[H_T 3,047]

Melbourne FC ‏@melbournefc 2m2 minutes ago

COMPLETED TRADE with @GWSGiants. IN: Pick 7, Tomas Bugg OUT: Picks 10, 43 and 64 Details: http://mfcde.es/BuggAndPick7

Edited October 21, 2015 by H_T

[Nasher 33,616]

10,43,64 for Bugg and 7. Hung onto the pick int he 20's as a bonus!!!!

Didn't we lose that in the original trade for 10?

I've lost track but I thought we now had 3 and 7, then not appear in the draft again til 50 odd.

[ManDee 7,145]

OK Mahoney haters, eat some pie.

[Senegor 31]

Go watch the film Draft Day and pretend Kevin Costner is playing Josh Mahoney - zero to hero!

Edited October 21, 2015 by Senegor

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

[Chris 2,892]

How about this for a deal,

Pick 50, 46, and 6 to GWS for Bugg, pick 8 and 27. GWS lose Bugg for a 103 point gain, equivalent of about pick 60 (may be a little low).

We then trade pick 8,29, and 27 to GC for Pick 3 and a player worth about pick 30. We gain Parish in the draft, which we want, and GC get an extra 673 points minus a player worth about 673 points (pick 30ish).

leaves us with few draft picks but we get the two players we want and some steak knives from GC.

Going to blow my own trumpet again, wasn't far off in the whole thing, picks changed a little and the order of the trades changed but the outcome is about the same.

TOOT TOOT.

[S.R.J 418]

[The Chazz 4,077]

Go watch the film Draft Day and pretend Kevin Costner is playing Josh Mahoney - zero to hero!

Better than watching Moneyball and finding Mark Neeld playing Billy Beane!!!

[Jaded No More 68,915]

This points system is working a treat for us

Also, in more exciting news, we just got pick 94 for Fitzy! #winning

(in all seriousness, that is not bad, since we can use that to upgrade Harmes or Vanders with that)

Edited October 21, 2015 by Jaded

[Wiseblood 24,637]

OK Mahoney haters, eat some pie.

They were always going to. So many people on here are short sighted during this period.

Melksham, Kennedy, Bugg and 2 picks inside the Top 10. Brilliant work.

Plus we can now all watch another 2 minute highlight video of Bugg's best work. Has to be the best part about the trade really...

[DemonLad5 1,642]

This points system is working a treat for us

Also, in more exciting news, we just got pick 94 for Fitzy! #winning

(in all seriousness, that is not bad, since we can use that to upgrade Harmes or Vanders with that)

Actually good, another rookie upgrade

[Chris 2,892]

Didn't we lose that in the original trade for 10?

I've lost track but I thought we now had 3 and 7, then not appear in the draft again til 50 odd.

Yep, my bad, forgot int eh excitement.

[Wiseblood 24,637]

This points system is working a treat for us

Also, in more exciting news, we just got pick 94 for Fitzy! #winning

If we use that pick to upgrade a Vandenberg or Harmes then it's #epicwinning

[hoon1 43]

Why trade 3 and 7 for 4 and 5, if we take parish at 3 then we are guaranteed to land one of curnow, weideman, francis or the SA forward who name escapes my memory. We may as well keep our picks.

Get the best mid (Parish) and a highly rated key forward to partner hogan.

*Edit Burton is the SA key forward

[Guest]

It also shows as well that with Frost and Bugg now crossing over that Voldemort's tales of Melbourne being a bucket shop organization are falling on deaf ears!

[Beetle 4,656]

Mahoney and co should just not even turn up tomorrow and leave a note on our trade desk that says "Out to lunch".

[Senegor 31]

Better than watching Moneyball and finding Mark Neeld playing Billy Beane!!!

Too soon Billy... Too Soon

[What 18,810]

We now get to ruin the dreams of Essendon (picks 4 and 5) and Carlton (pick 8)

This is too good.

[H_T 3,047]

Net result:

IN:

ND PICKS 3,7,46,50

Melksham, Kennedy, Bugg

OUT:

Started with 6,25,...Toumpas, Howe

RESULT:

Overall significant improvement in draft position including two top 10 picks. Targeted 3 x 20-24 yo players and got them.

First round as it stands:

ROUND ONE CARL 1. Carlton BL 2. Brisbane Lions MELB 3. Melbourne (received from Gold Coast in an exchange of picks) ESS 4. Essendon ESS 5. Essendon (received from St Kilda as part of the trade for Jake Carlisle) GCFC 6. Gold Coast (received from Melbourne in an exchange of picks) MELB 7. Melbourne (received from GWS as part of the trade for Tom Bugg; received by GWS from Collingwood as part of the trade for Adam Treloar) CARL 8. Carlton (received from GWS as part of the trade for Lachie Plowman, Jed Lamb, Andrew Phillips and Liam Sumner) ADEL 9. Adelaide (received from Geelong as part of the trade for Patrick Dangerfield) GWS 10. Greater Western Sydney (received from Melbourne as part of the trade for Tom Bugg; received from Gold Coast in an exchange of picks, originally from Port Adelaide as part of the trade for Charlie Dixon) WB 11. Western Bulldogs RICH 12. Richmond ADEL 13. Adelaide STK 14. St Kilda (received from the Sydney Swans as part of the Jake Carlisle-Craig Bird trade) HAW 15. Hawthorn (received from North Melbourne as part of the trade for Jed Anderson) GCFC 16. Gold Coast (received from Fremantle as part of the trade for Harley Bennell) BL 17. Brisbane Lions (received from West Coast via a trade for Jack Redden) HAW 18. Hawthorn

[Guest]

Those two guys are both wearing Dwight Howard's numbers on their shirts! Not a good omen to put that on here when talking of recruiting coups!

[Demon Disciple 12,122]

Gladly

[Red and Blue Flame 187]

Was just thinking about GWS and their drafting. They have had the cream of draft picks and so many are gone or are on the way out.

Yet there is hardly a comment in the medya about them unlike the Dees that have copped it from pillar to post.

They have lost:

Pick 1

Boyd

pick 2

O'Rourke

pick 3

Plowman

tyson

Pick 12

Jaksch

Hoskin Elliot and Buntine look like busts and I can't be bothered going trough the rest of them but plenty are looking to leave....

they've also lost the plot

[daisycutter 29,614]

10,43,64 for Bugg and 7. Hung onto the pick int he 20's as a bonus!!!!

what pick in the 20s? that went earlier

[Barney Rubble 1,576]

I want our group playing poker for me any day of the week.

Straight face, Straight bat.

What was itv2 hours ago, definitely going into the trade with 3 & 10.

Now 3 &7 and Bugg and the fat lady isn't singing yet.

[CBDees 3,167]

I hope that we are seriously looking at Jones and Terlich's contracts as it would be a shame to merely use picks 46 & 50 on rookie upgrades when there may be somebody that the FD finds more suited to our needs ( now that we have traded in some midfield depth)!