Roos v Beveridge

[Sir Why You Little 34,614]

The most worrying thing for me is the number of under performing players. Senior players. To have so many inconsistent performers is killing us on the field.

Let's just see how we fare over the next three weeks. There is no reason why we can't at least be in the contest against our next three opponents. If we fail to achieve that, then questions can and should be asked and the heat will naturally come onto Roos, succession plan or not.

It is not Roos at all.

It's the goddam players. They wanted Roosy to coach them remember

Well how bout they respond and actually hurt for some team success.

It is amazing these players are able to play this way for so long on large coin...

Easy Street.

Edited May 18, 2015 by H_T
Foul mouth language

[Coq au vin 754]

It is not Roos at all.

It's the goddam players. They wanted Roosy to coach them remember

Well how bout they respond and actually hurt for some team success.

It is amazing these players are able to play this way for so long on large coin...

Easy Street.

They've been smashed physically and mentally over the last three weeks. It will take the rest of the season to get over this aberrant draw and its negative effects on their psyche. Imagine if we'd played Brisbane, St Kilda and Carlton! We might have won two or all three games. Then the confidence rises and the skills and excitement level and intensity all rise. I blame the AFL.

[stuie 7,374]

It's not the results that have us restless, it's the lack of spirit and footy basics. Two things we thought would be fixed by now under Roos.

[Sir Why You Little 34,614]

They've been smashed physically and mentally over the last three weeks. It will take the rest of the season to get over this aberrant draw and its negative effects on their psyche. Imagine if we'd played Brisbane, St Kilda and Carlton! We might have won two or all three games. Then the confidence rises and the skills and excitement level and intensity all rise. I blame the AFL.

It is a brutal game and all clubs have young players

You either play it right or go do something else.

[stuie 7,374]

They've been smashed physically and mentally over the last three weeks. It will take the rest of the season to get over this aberrant draw and its negative effects on their psyche. Imagine if we'd played Brisbane, St Kilda and Carlton! We might have won two or all three games. Then the confidence rises and the skills and excitement level and intensity all rise. I blame the AFL.

Excuses excuses... They're playing against similar aged players in the same level of competition, why should there be sympathy?

[jnrmac 19,088]

Was this antiRoos sentiment going around following the Gold Coast or Richmond wins?

Or has it only sprung up after we play the three best teams in the league?

If you read the OP its about how a rookie coach and his team created a plan to counteract possibly the best team in the comp, Freo. Yep we were playing the bset 3 teams in the comp and what did we do?

There is no way the hawks were going to let us play 'our' game plan and it was clear after the 1st quarter we were under fire. At the risk of repeating the OP we have been beaten on the 11 previous occasions in the same style - thrashings. With the same players killing us.

I ask you again what did we do? I think the answer is SFA. If you have a better one let us all know.

[jackaub 1,402]

Yes jrmac it is a very disturbing trend

Maybe this lot are uncoachable now

[Forest Demon 4,681]

The most worrying thing for me is the number of under performing players. Senior players. To have so many inconsistent performers is killing us on the field.

Let's just see how we fare over the next three weeks. There is no reason why we can't at least be in the contest against our next three opponents. If we fail to achieve that, then questions can and should be asked and the heat will naturally come onto Roos, succession plan or not.

This is it for me also. The form of Jones, Tyson, Dawes, Vince, Howe, Jamar, Lumumba, Watts and a few others has ranged from ordinary to disastrous. Add to that injuries to Viney, Jetta, Frost and Kent and it is no wonder we copped a 100 point shellacking from Hawthorn, and actually amazing Sydney and Freo were not similar scorelines.

I too am willing to see how we fare from now up until the break, and there can't be any more even 5+ goal losses, let alone 10 goal or 100 point beltings.

Edited May 18, 2015 by Forest Demon

[Binmans PA 26,263]

Really happy for Luke. He's a lovely bloke. I've still got his MFC player suit from when he used to play for the Dees. I hope his team has an off week this coming round though.

I've long wanted an MFC coach to be unconventional and tactically progressive. Clarkson was brilliant at this when he first started coaching and Luke seems to have a similar eye for the unconventional.

Another ex-Melbourne person doing well at another club. It's frustrating, isn't it? You only have to look at Hawthorn's coaching staff. It's an old MFC boys reunion.

I think from Roos' perspective, given it was always going to be a three year deal and nothing else, is there any point in implementing any particularly new strategies if you're not going to be there to oversee them in four years time? I hope though, as 'Sir Paul Roos' says, Roos is simply laying the foundations that Goodwin can then run with once PR hands over the mantle.

[What 18,810]

It's not the results that have us restless, it's the lack of spirit and footy basics. Two things we thought would be fixed by now under Roos.

Exactly

We have 3 chances to show some spirit and some fight against the 3 best teams in the comp and we failed miserably on all 3 occasions

The club has no fabric

[Ted Lasso 16,874]

Really happy for Luke. He's a lovely bloke. I've still got his MFC player suit from when he used to play for the Dees. I hope his team has an off week this coming round though.

I've long wanted an MFC coach to be unconventional and tactically progressive. Clarkson was brilliant at this when he first started coaching and Luke seems to have a similar eye for the unconventional.

Another ex-Melbourne person doing well at another club. It's frustrating, isn't it? You only have to look at Hawthorn's coaching staff. It's an old MFC boys reunion.

I think from Roos' perspective, given it was always going to be a three year deal and nothing else, is there any point in implementing any particularly new strategies if you're not going to be there to oversee them in four years time? I hope though, as 'Sir Paul Roos' says, Roos is simply laying the foundations that Goodwin can then run with once PR hands over the mantle.

I reckon this is what is happening, Roos will make the tough calls, hopefully get rid of the blokes who aren't serious and take some hits knowing he isn't going to be sacked regardless, and hopefully hand over to Goodwin a list that can go somewhere,

i think our best is pretty good, but we really have to stop these lapses

[chookrat 3,777]

Roos is doing what McCartney did for the dogs, teaching them about defence and contested ball, beveridge took over a really well built foundation, Roos took over a train wreck

i also think a lot of our ball movement issues are to do with blokes up the field not running hard enough to create options, and our ruckman and talls besides Jesse not being good enough to take a contested grab around the ground

Goodwin will bring a more attacking flair to our game, he already has but he'll take over a team that knows how to defend, how to play finals footy and has some serious development into our young guys

Good post.

Rios isn't that interested in game day tactics as he wants each player to play their role and be accountable. Mae are on the right trajectory, it is simply a matter of us starting so far back, and needing to get the fundamentals in place before dealing with game day tactics.

[WhyAlwaysMe 237]

They've been smashed physically and mentally over the last three weeks. It will take the rest of the season to get over this aberrant draw and its negative effects on their psyche. Imagine if we'd played Brisbane, St Kilda and Carlton! We might have won two or all three games. Then the confidence rises and the skills and excitement level and intensity all rise. I blame the AFL.

won 1 of those last year, maybe we will beat Carlton again, my excitement levels are about to blow

[xarronn 380]

It is an interesting that both clubs who tanked the hardest over a period of time are the 2 clubs playing with no spirit.

There is an emptiness to the MFC. The players had a crack for 2 minutes on saturday then up went the white flag.

First of all let me be clear I am not having a go at SWYL, but I've wanted to post on this tanking theory for some time.

I've always believed this theory about us tanking and the impact on the club culture was bogus and simply an opportunity to retrospectively fit a cause to an effect and ironically Roos has been the greatest proponent of this theory from his 'On the Couch' days.

If my memory serves me well, it all started with Maclean making his statement in 2012 and then Roosy took up the running with his claim that it created the culture which afflicted the club in 2012.

The facts are 2009 was the year of the so-called tanking. However in 2010 we inflicted Roos' greatest loss after which he declared Melbourne "the team of the next decade". So one year after the tanking he declares us the team of the future. Until the Geelong debacle in 2011 no-one claimed there was an institutional problem at the club. So suddenly when the team couldn't win in 2012 it was caused by tanking - BS!

As I said at the beginning, I have been really disappointed that Roos has never been picked up on these facts.

Similarly the guff in the media about no one ever having heard of a player asking to be dropped, (in reference to Watts). It happened 4 weeks ago when Goodes asked to be dropped to the Swans reserves.

[xarronn 380]

They've been smashed physically and mentally over the last three weeks. It will take the rest of the season to get over this aberrant draw and its negative effects on their psyche. Imagine if we'd played Brisbane, St Kilda and Carlton! We might have won two or all three games. Then the confidence rises and the skills and excitement level and intensity all rise. I blame the AFL.

Incredibly it could have been even worse. Both Gold Coast and Richmond were expected to be at least top six teams this year. We could well have been 0 - 7 with a percentage in the 50's.

A worse start than last year would have been diabolical. It could still become that. All it will take is a couple more critical injuries.

[What 18,810]

Incredibly it could have been even worse. Both Gold Coast and Richmond were expected to be at least top six teams this year. We could well have been 0 - 7 with a percentage in the 50's.

A worse start than last year would have been diabolical. It could still become that. All it will take is a couple more critical injuries.

its a miracle we have won any games when you consider that Vince, Lumumba, Jones, Dunn, Tyson, Howe, Watts and Dawes are all well down on their best form and in the case of the last 2 , totally useless.

Add the injuries to key players and 2-5 is a good result.

[WhyAlwaysMe 237]

The most worrying thing for me is the number of under performing players. Senior players. To have so many inconsistent performers is killing us on the field.

Let's just see how we fare over the next three weeks. There is no reason why we can't at least be in the contest against our next three opponents. If we fail to achieve that, then questions can and should be asked and the heat will naturally come onto Roos, succession plan or not.

no it won't, we are the only team where poor losses are acceptable, on top of that Roos is untouchable

[RalphiusMaximus 5,993]

The big difference is that the Doggies have been recruiting quality mids for years while we have been stockpiling fairly average talls and have wasted a huge number of picks on mids who never made it. They can afford to play a game that relies on winning a contested ball in the midfield, while when we do that we get smashed. Repairing the damage to our midfield has been Roos' goal from the start, and it's still going on. What we've seen over the last few weeks is that we are still well behind the good teams when it comes to our midfield stocks.

[Curry & Beer 5,444]

The most worrying thing for me is the number of under performing players. Senior players. To have so many inconsistent performers is killing us on the field.

Let's just see how we fare over the next three weeks. There is no reason why we can't at least be in the contest against our next three opponents. If we fail to achieve that, then questions can and should be asked and the heat will naturally come onto Roos, succession plan or not.

This is the bit that's worrying me also. How many players on our list would you say are having a WORSE year then they did last year? Excluding new players, 0bviously, would it be fair to say that Tommy Mac is the ONLY player who has stepped up from last year? Most damaging is of course the midfield, Jamar, NJones, Tyson, Cross and Vince have ALL gone backwards. What in the name of God could possibly explain this and I would love to know Roosy's take on it. Not good at all.

[WhyAlwaysMe 237]

its a miracle we have won any games when you consider that Vince, Lumumba, Jones, Dunn, Tyson, Howe, Watts and Dawes are all well down on their best form and in the case of the last 2 , totally useless.

Add the injuries to key players and 2-5 is a good result.

we lost by 105 to the worst Hawks side in a decade, crushed by quarter time last 3 at the G (2 at the hands of non Vic teams).

so many happy the way we are going ( where else but the MFC)

Miracle Pleeeeease.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

The big difference is that the Doggies have been recruiting quality mids for years while we have been stockpiling fairly average talls and have wasted a huge number of picks on mids who never made it. They can afford to play a game that relies on winning a contested ball in the midfield, while when we do that we get smashed. Repairing the damage to our midfield has been Roos' goal from the start, and it's still going on. What we've seen over the last few weeks is that we are still well behind the good teams when it comes to our midfield stocks.

And that's the crux of it for me. I think we have enough quality up forward to match it with most teams, but, we don't get it to them with nearly enough quality. We also don't get it down there often enough either. Our backline has shown it can match it with most as well. But our midfield can't compete and therefore the rest of the team can't compete either.

A fix to our midfield was always going to take time, although it's disappointing to see us lose by so much regardless of who the opponent is.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

Even though I think jnrmac's initial post was very good and well reasoned, I hate this thread.

We are extremely fortunate to have Paul Roos at this club. He is an excellent coach.

In fact, he's even more than that.

[Wiseblood 24,636]

Even though I think jnrmac's initial post was very good and well reasoned, I hate this thread.

We are extremely fortunate to have Paul Roos at this club. He is an excellent coach.

In fact, he's even more than that.

Couldn't agree more Ron.

I understand the frustration from some supporters, particularly after a promising start to the year, but I am 100% behind Roos and his belief that we will be in such a better place come the end of 2016.

[Ron Burgundy 8,584]

we lost by 105 to the worst Hawks side in a decade, crushed by quarter time last 3 at the G (2 at the hands of non Vic teams).

so many happy the way we are going ( where else but the MFC)

Miracle Pleeeeease.

At the hands of non Victorian teams?

Yep, Freo and Sydney are ordinary. Who would've thought we could've fallen so far.

[WhyAlwaysMe 237]

Even though I think jnrmac's initial post was very good and well reasoned, I hate this thread.

We are extremely fortunate to have Paul Roos at this club. He is an excellent coach.

In fact, he's even more than that.

he may very well be an excellent coach, but his results are rock bottom, we are lower than i imagined possible.