GOODBYE MR. CHIP FRAWLEY

[KingDingAling 3,737]

Frawley is a good defender, as he shown today.

He can defend. But he cannot do much else.

Average footballer, below average decision maker.

[Left Field 313]

James was, I thought, really poor today.

Don't mean to sound reactionary, but if he goes, I'm sure we can parlay the compensation pick into another mid fielder. Preferably one who can compete, hold their feet and hit targets.

[Adam The God 29,292]

Clearly our best today. He didn't look like being beaten one-on-one either. He also offered great drive off half back and his kicking was excellent, especially his long kicking. The way he was revving the boys up at the start, tells me he's staying.

[Adam The God 29,292]

Frawley is a good defender, as he shown today.

He can defend. But he cannot do much else.

Average footballer, below average decision maker.

Rubbish. He provided fantastic run off half back. Roos and the FD clearly gave him a licence to run today and it paid off. We looked so much better for it early on. It was the last line of defence that looked shaky today. We really made some poor decisions back there. It didn't help that Bail was pinged for deliberate, taking the ball over the goal line, whilst being tackled. It made our defenders second guess themselves for the rest of the afternoon.

[dazzledavey36 52,692]

Im gonna actually stick up for Frawley now. It was his fault in the Bontempelli goa. He had 4 Melbourne guys behind him watching him get the ball. There was ABSOLUTELY NO talk to him to say his hot. No one even pushed over to try and sheppard him.

Rohan bail needs a foot up the ass out of all that. Got brushed aside by a skinny 18 year old in an attempt to tackle!

[Beetle 4,523]

Where's the 'report' button gone? You guys are pathetic.

Fine...the post had been edited so as not to offend people like yourself.

It was harsh and crude...but thats how I was feeling immediately after todays game.

Now feel free to edit the quote in your post if you so wish..

[Melb16 478]

People having a go at Frawley's game today obviously have bias given his contract status.

Absolutely smashed his opponent and provided run. Made some poor decisions but the whole team's mindset was poor. Garland was much worse.

Some comments on him have been pathetic. Likely from the same people who talk up loyalty. Spare me.

[Demon Premonition 135]

Definitely in the best today, showed why many clubs are currently chasing his services. (Surely the simple fact the multiple clubs are rumoured to be lining up to get his signature indicates that he must have ability - one of the few who pick themselves in a top 8 team!

[rjay 24,574]

Lucas gave him 3 votes today as clearly best player on the ground.

[Adam The God 29,292]

Lucas gave him 3 votes today as clearly best player on the ground.

I thought Boyd killed us, particularly in the first half, but Frawley was certainly our best and deservedly in the top 2 players on the ground.

[Jaded No More 67,600]

Frawley was very good today.

Anyone who says they want him gone are simply doing so to lessen their disappointment if he leaves.

[beelzebub 23,184]

Frawley was very good today.

Anyone who says they want him gone are simply doing so to lessen their disappointment if he leaves.

I dont thin thats as cut and dried as you suggest. He for all his good work today committed some horrendous clunkers of decisions. He ought to be way above those. So where's his head ? I ahve to ask

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

Frawley was very good today.

Anyone who says they want him gone are simply doing so to lessen their disappointment if he leaves.

Well I can tell you right now that I won't be one bit disappointed if Frawley leaves.

You and a few others keep saying that, which is clearly ridiculous as we'll be receiving high band compensation if he leaves.

That's the reason myself and others don't care, it's got nothing to do with 'prepping myself for disappointment'.

[picket fence 16,631]

Gee so many varied opinions, I also thought he was poor today , When the game was there to be won his direct opponent kicked two telling goals on him. I reckon he had three kicked on him today. Made some shocking decision errors. I really am not fussed if he stays or goes to be honest. I think we win regardless!

[Uncle Fester 2,843]

Some comments on him have been pathetic.

I'm in the stay, go, whatever camp with Chip, but I don't see why people want to border on the obscene when it comes to trashing him.

There was a comment a page or so ago about him being a cum bucket. If I was a mod here that would be the last post that person ever made on D'land.

[nutbean 8,838]

Well I can tell you right now that I won't be one bit disappointed if Frawley leaves.

You and a few others keep saying that, which is clearly ridiculous as we'll be receiving high band compensation if he leaves.

That's the reason myself and others don't care, it's got nothing to do with 'prepping myself for disappointment'.

We get that you will be happy to see him go.

We also see that your critique of his effort today shows your knowledge of football and

You again show that you can't objectively view a players performance through your obvious bias.

He made some clangers as did others. I think you'll find that most unbiased commentators will put him in our best half dozen today. And rightly so.

[What 18,810]

Bontempelli should give Frawley half of his goal of the year prize

What a pathetic effort , had 2 chances to clear the ball and was completely useless and basically handed them the goal

If we get a top 5 pick for Frawley we will be overcompensated thats for sure

[jackaub 1,402]

Frawley is a good defender, as he shown today.

He can defend. But he cannot do much else.

Average footballer, below average decision maker.

Dumber than his uncle and it shows in his decision making

WHY ANY BODY CARES IF HE GOES IS BEYOND ME those who want him to stay can have him

[Tatu 416]

Clearly our best today. He didn't look like being beaten one-on-one either. He also offered great drive off half back and his kicking was excellent, especially his long kicking. The way he was revving the boys up at the start, tells me he's staying.

he was good today, seemed to have his spark back.... Im not sure he is staying though? But If he did stay, id play him of the half back line and keep Dunn at full back..

[Deevout 490]

How many unrestricted free agents that have said: I will leave my decision if I stay or go till seasons end.Tthen re-signed with that club?

None that I can think off.

I am 99% sure he is gone at seasons end, same as all the others who have played this "waiting game"

I hope he stays. We have become a FA feeder club in recent times for obvious reasons. Now it's time for it to stop. We are on the improve and good loyal players like Dunn are showing the way.

If he goes I hope we get decent compensation or I will be [censored].

End of rant.

[nutbean 8,838]

How many unrestricted free agents that have said: I will leave my decision if I stay or go till seasons end.Tthen re-signed with that club?

None that I can think off.

I am 99% sure he is gone at seasons end, same as all the others who have played this "waiting game"

I hope he stays. We have become a FA feeder club in recent times for obvious reasons. Now it's time for it to stop. We are on the improve and good loyal players like Dunn are showing the way.

If he goes I hope we get decent compensation or I will be [censored].

End of rant.

Don't disagree with any of this, but unlike others you are not allowing what we as supporters feel very uncomfortable about regarding his contract, with how he is actually playing.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

I've been in the keep him camp until today I thought some of his lapses cost us the game and when the ball went through his legs it was embarrassing. Terlich got clean bowled too, how can that happen to AFL footballers.

[Tatu 416]

Seems most of the negative comments are based around one moment... He dominated Jones today, pretty much handed him the sub vest and his drive from the back line was almost back to his best... Not many key position defenders, destroy there opponent while pulling in midfielder stats..

Clearly opinions here are skewed because he hasn't extended his contract... I get it.. Its the old push him away, so it doesn't hurt when he leaves... He will be missed, regardless of any opinion here...

[Machsy 2,858]

Dumber than his uncle and it shows in his decision making

WHY ANY BODY CARES IF HE GOES IS BEYOND ME those who want him to stay can have him

Can we? Thanks!

[Melb16 478]

Seems most of the negative comments are based around one moment... He dominated Jones today, pretty much handed him the sub vest and his drive from the back line was almost back to his best... Not many key position defenders, destroy there opponent while pulling in midfielder stats..

Clearly opinions here are skewed because he hasn't extended his contract... I get it.. Its the old push him away, so it doesn't hurt when he leaves... He will be missed, regardless of any opinion here...

Perfectly put. Despite your feeling on the contract situation, if you cant view his game objectively you just look silly.