Colin Sylvia

[Grapeviney 9,799]

Apparntly the rumour is not true.

Move along..

Yep, it's been more than a couple of hours since this surfaced and there's nothing in the main media, so I've removed all posts referring to it.

Bernie can stay.

[Little Richard 6,265]

Apparntly the rumour is not true.

Move along..

Poor form if someone has just fabricated that.

[monoccular 17,573]

Ahhhh. Imagine if he could have an uninterrupted full preseason? :-))

Edited June 23, 2015 by monoccular

[rjay 25,086]

Ahhhh. Imagine if he could have an uninterrupted full preseason? :-))

Bernie's pre season was totally disrupted, hasn't hurt him.

The difference is Bernie had the talent to make it as a top level AFL player, Col didn't...

[Cards13 9,117]

He always struggles in traffic old Col.

[chook fowler 19,533]

Can't really see the point in continuing to bring up Colin on this forum.

Let it be, whatever it is.

Everyone knows he was a wasted talent so nothing more needs to be said.

[BAMF 4,385]

Next year will be his best year.

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,909]

Bernie is the player we all hoped Slyvia would become, but never did. One of the best trade results to ever transpire.

Garlett for pick 4 million gives it a run for its money.

[DemonFrog 1,356]

Colin who?

[deeflog 679]

Bernie's pre season was totally disrupted, hasn't hurt him.

The difference is Bernie had the talent to make it as a top level AFL player, Col didn't...

col had the talent, he didn't have the application required to get the best out of himself

[rjay 25,086]

col had the talent, he didn't have the application required to get the best out of himself

Nup, blinded by the perceived talent 'deflog'.

I think he got close to the best from himself, he might have eked out a little bit more with better application but not a lot.

[Devil is in the Detail 883]

Next year will be his best year.

He needs just one good preseason.

[deeflog 679]

Nup, blinded by the perceived talent 'deflog'.

I think he got close to the best from himself, he might have eked out a little bit more with better application but not a lot.

we will just agree to disagree, because I see it differently than you

[Damo 3,374]

Im glad that it is just a rumour.

Like Trav and Liam, Col was interesting to watch. Ill always go with "His breakout season was stuffed because he got his jaw broken pre-season".

Im not asking for holes in my mantra to be pointed out, BTW.

[pitmaster 3,578]

Bernie is the player we all hoped Slyvia would become, but never did. One of the best trade results to ever transpire.

Was mentioned on Footy Classified as one of the absolute great trades in one of those 'the less said the better' moments.

[Grimes Times 1,278]

While the deal in the end was Vince for Sylvia we infact gave up pick 23 for Vince.

The Crows picked Matt Crouch with pick 23 who from 6 games this year is ave 18 disposals.

Compare that to Brayshaws 15.

Vince is what we needed at the time but we did give up a 10-12 year A-B grade midfielder for him.

[barneymfc 152]

col was as good as he was,looked like a player ,we expected more,but he never had the ability, just the looks of a good player he was a NQR.By the way dont bag trav johnson he was absultley a champ for us

[Demon Disciple 12,273]

While the deal in the end was Vince for Sylvia we infact gave up pick 23 for Vince.

The Crows picked Matt Crouch with pick 23 who from 6 games this year is ave 18 disposals.

Compare that to Brayshaws 15.

Vince is what we needed at the time but we did give up a 10-12 year A-B grade midfielder for him.

I see where you're coming from GT, but if we were to have kept the pick, would have we drafted Crouch with it?

[IvanBartul13 2,564]

I see where you're coming from GT, but if we were to have kept the pick, would have we drafted Crouch with it?

Almost certainly would have taken Lewis Taylor. Would be nice to have Daniel McStay but I don't think it's possible to argue with any effect that trading for Vince was anything other than a masterstroke/best practice.

Edited June 24, 2015 by goodoil

[dazzledavey36 55,318]

I see where you're coming from GT, but if we were to have kept the pick, would have we drafted Crouch with it?

We would have taken Lewis Taylor. Fact is that if Salem been taken before our pick we would have taken Taylor hands down.

While Taylor will be a gun we needed Bernie Vince impact straight away. Put it this way we wouldn't have won on the weekend without Vince. At the time we needed midfield class and experience and thas what Bernie bring.

This alone tells you that Jason Taylor has an eye for serious talent. The fact that he rated him a top 10 pick and he lasted till 28 shows that either Salem or Taylor would have been a good pick,

Im calling it also but I think Jason Taylor will be the next Stephen Wells.

[Little Richard 6,265]

While the deal in the end was Vince for Sylvia we infact gave up pick 23 for Vince.

The Crows picked Matt Crouch with pick 23 who from 6 games this year is ave 18 disposals.

Compare that to Brayshaws 15.

Vince is what we needed at the time but we did give up a 10-12 year A-B grade midfielder for him.

That's a bit contrived and if you go down that path, we did not give up a 10-12 year A-B grade midfielder for him.

We gave up pick 23, which could have been anyone and anything. I'm personally very happy with Vince, who is exactly the kind of player we needed - mature and hungry for the contest.

[stuie 7,374]

While the deal in the end was Vince for Sylvia we infact gave up pick 23 for Vince.

The Crows picked Matt Crouch with pick 23 who from 6 games this year is ave 18 disposals.

Compare that to Brayshaws 15.

Vince is what we needed at the time but we did give up a 10-12 year A-B grade midfielder for him.

You've been a Dees supporter too long with "logic" like that mate.

[Queanbeyan Demon 6,865]

col was as good as he was,looked like a player ,we expected more,but he never had the ability, just the looks of a good player he was a NQR.By the way dont bag trav johnson he was absultley a champ for us

Going into stand up comedy I see barneymfc.

[jumbo returns 6,741]

what happened?

[Pates 9,660]

While the deal in the end was Vince for Sylvia we infact gave up pick 23 for Vince.

The Crows picked Matt Crouch with pick 23 who from 6 games this year is ave 18 disposals.

Compare that to Brayshaws 15.

Vince is what we needed at the time but we did give up a 10-12 year A-B grade midfielder for him.

A lot more risk with picking up a kid as opposed to Vince. We'd have to let him develop, we have to pick to right kid (no guarantee we'd pick Crouch), plus he wasn't what we needed at the time. We needed someone to be able to walk into the team with experience to give Jones another seasoned body around him.

The value of having Vince as someone to help with the development of Brayshaw, Petracca, Viney, ANB, Stretch etc is something you also have to consider.

I simply look at it as Sylvia for Vince, Crows got something good, we got something good, and Freo got a lemon.