James Magner

[Guest]

James is not teling us anything we did not already know.

The club WAS a complete mess.

I remember the feeling of despair at halftime Round 1 2012.

The MCC Reserve was booing the side off the ground.

I had not ever experienced that before. Only an hour before we had all farewelled Jim

I think you are getting your round 1's mixed up WYL. 2013 was the year they got booed off (and rightfully so). We were still in the match at half time during round 1 in 2012.

[Sir Why You Little 36,990]

I think your memory is letting you down a bit there.. we trailed by 4 points at half time

not at all.

[Machsy 2,858]

Connelly take on Magner and Gysberts.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/cut-and-bruised-after-a-long-fall-from-grace-20131030-2whce.html

Ah... Rohan Connolly..!

I immediately assumed it was Chris Connolly.

Oops.

Anyway, re: Magner, I always considered him a player there primarily to make the VFL team competitive, to aid development.

Any AFL matches would be a bonus for him.

I'm just surprised the coaches hadn't clearly explained that to him.

[deeko 952]

I think it paints a picture of what we already knew that the club was very very ordinary at managing it's players. I was never a Magner fan but he definitely desserved to be in the squad in the guts. At least he would have smashed some packs having a crack.

I don't care if players whinge, it shows there human. Not all of them can be as cool and relaxed as a Jimmy Bartel or Tex Walker, lots are complete hot heads and it would be hard not to show emotion getting angry and frustrated when things don't go there way, especially in this case when Magner didn't know why it wasn't.

Let's not forget, they are at this level as most have an amazing amount of confidence in themselves and back themselves everytime, this is what makes them great. I love seeing them show there human side and with the constant ridicule they get for it we are left wondering why when players get interview they come up with the standard crap like:

• We are just working on our game plan
• I'm just try to do my part for the team
• I'm just playing my role.
• etc

Bring back the great days before all players were made to take "media training" and everyone ran there mouth and showed there true emotions blasting team mates and opposition players!

[Cards13 9,117]

Shows your true character..

Didn't stop Jack watts who absolutey gets crucified from us supporters..

No it doesn't at all. Ridiculous.

Edited November 1, 2013 by Cards13

[GM11 776]

I don't think Craig would have been influenced by Neeld in regard to player value.

I think Jack Fitzpatrick is an example of that.

The fact that Neeld, then Craig & now Roos appear to have the same opinion of JM is more telling.

A journo intent on factual reporting would probably have considered that.

[jumbo returns 6,740]

Blame Neeld because you're a slow, VFL player?

Good work!

[Sir Why You Little 36,990]

I think you are getting your round 1's mixed up WYL. 2013 was the year they got booed off (and rightfully so). We were still in the match at half time during round 1 in 2012.

I know which game i am talking about...Neeld's first one. The MCC was very unimpressed at half time.

Yes we were 4 points down, but we were playing like rubbish.

12 months later exactly it was worse.

[Whispering_Jack 29,814]

I know which game i am talking about...Neeld's first one. The MCC was very unimpressed at half time.

Yes we were 4 points down, but we were playing like rubbish.

12 months later exactly it was worse.

Colin's right. You were confused. We might not have been playing all that well but there were some real flashes of good play in the first half and we even snatched the lead before half time with a nice goal from Jack Trengove before a late goal to Merrett put us behind again. I don't recall any booing at the time not even from the members.

Whether you liked Neeld, Schwab, McLardy and the bootstudder of the time, please let's not distort or reinvent history.

As for the Jimmy Magner article today, whilst I thought he deserved a better go especialIy late in the season, I think there's more inconsistency in its telling than in the accusations against the coaches.

[Grimseyisgod 378]

you've really got to feel for the guy.

that's it.. you could see how hard he worked

[Sir Why You Little 36,990]

Colin's right. You were confused. We might not have been playing all that well but there were some real flashes of good play in the first half and we even snatched the lead before half time with a nice goal from Jack Trengove before a late goal to Merrett put us behind again. I don't recall any booing at the time not even from the members.

Whether you liked Neeld, Schwab, McLardy and the bootstudder of the time, please let's not distort or reinvent history.

As for the Jimmy Magner article today, whilst I thought he deserved a better go especialIy late in the season, I think there's more inconsistency in its telling than in the accusations against the coaches.

Excuse me.....I was sitting in the MCC Reserve Round 1 2012 against the Bears

Magner's first game.

I know which game it was because i was shocked at the anger....12 months later it was fury.

[DemonFrog 1,354]

[Sir Why You Little 36,990]

That is Harsh Frog......But i like it!!!

[DemonFrog 1,354]

That is Harsh Frog......But i like it!!!

I was trying to help out the young guy and this says it all LOL

[Thehardtackler 785]

Drafting Daniel Cross really meant the end for Magner. Cross brings hardness and skill to our lineup whereas Magner really was all about brute force.

[Tony Tea 2,806]

Excuse me.....I was sitting in the MCC Reserve Round 1 2012 against the Bears

Magner's first game.

I know which game it was because i was shocked at the anger....12 months later it was fury.

I was in the MCC too but I don't remember any booing, although I do remember several angry fans.

[Sir Why You Little 36,990]

I was in the MCC too but I don't remember any booing, although I do remember several angry fans.

There was a lot of noise and anger around me on Level 2....we were right above the race..

People could see what was going to happen...the team structure was a shambles and never improved.

[Tony Tea 2,806]

People could see what was going to happen...the team structure was a shambles and never improved.

I certainly agree with that.

[Sir Why You Little 36,990]

I certainly agree with that.

It was the first time i had heard the MCC get really peeved off and that included all of the 70's & 80's

Old guys in suits were giving it to the players as they walked up the race.

I was half ready for it in 2013, but not an hour after clapping Jimmy off

[demonoid 317]

Excuse me.....I was sitting in the MCC Reserve Round 1 2012 against the Bears

Magner's first game.

I know which game it was because i was shocked at the anger....12 months later it was fury.

i was there and yes there was booing. I think we all felt that we would come out breathing fire for jimmy but didn't and looked flat. Many a folk was [censored]

[dees189227 12,373]

DELISTED midfielder James Magner has painted a picture of dysfunction and confusion at Melbourne as he attempts to understand his departure from the club.

"Having had such a disappointing year, I am sad to probably be leaving the AFL environment, but I am not so disappointed to leave the Melbourne footy club.

Bit contradicted dont you think. He complains he doesnt know why he was axed but then says he isnt disappointed to leave.

"Put it this way, before the AFL I have never played as a forward in my entire life.

"I was playing good footy in the midfield, I came second in Melbourne's 3km time trial, I was leading the clearances, and I was a little dumbfounded to be moved forward considering I had never played there."

Its called trying you in a different position. But you obviously didnt want to learn.

let me tell you James why you arent in our midfield plans.

1. Roos obvioulsy never rated you

2. You were a rookie and after 2 years they are the first to go

3. We recruited players called Tyson, Vince and Cross. Throw them in our midfield along side Jones, Viney, Trengove and Toumpas and you cant get a spot.

[bing181 9,196]

Whether you liked Neeld, Schwab, McLardy and the bootstudder of the time, please let's not distort or reinvent history.

This is Demonland WJ.

[Sir Why You Little 36,990]

i was there and yes there was booing. I think we all felt that we would come out breathing fire for jimmy but didn't and looked flat. Many a folk was [censored]

That was the vibe on Level 2, you are right...The breathing fire for Jimmy was non existant.

[Slartibartfast 17,206]

Jimmy wants an answer. Logic suggest it stares him in the face..

Jimmy...why are most players cut ?

I was never a fan but if what he says is true he has every reason to be confused and disappointed. If the club could not explain to him why he was not getting a game and why he was delisted it is shocking player management.

If he was told and is bitching then he's a dope. I find it easy to believe that Neeld failed to communicate but I'm surprised that Neil Craig and Roos could not articulate the position fully and accurately.

[Still Waiting 94]

If you can't/don't perform, then go to St Kilda, Brisbane or somewhere else that is now equally the ducks guts in non performance!

What a sooky sooky la la.