GAMEDAY

[Soidee 1,496]

To say our boys aren't trying is naive at best and malicious at worst.

You are a dill

[Bang Bang Bang 5,826]

Jimmy Toumpas has been the main positive so far. We all know how good a kick he is but he has shown a cool head and composure on the last line on more than one occasion so far. A long way to go but good signs against good opposition!

The effort is OK IMO, but the decision making from Nicholson, M.Jones, Dunn, Davey and others has been diabolical.

Edited July 13, 2013 by Sylvia Saint

[jackaub 1,402]

Is Silvia playing?He should be biullocking after the ball He looks hungover to me

Weak Trotter and watcher of the ball

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

Team is full of soft one way players

There are a handful of decent players - but the rest are soft

[Redleg 40,948]

Whoever dropped Rodan when it was going to rain, with the ball on the ground so much,take a bow.

A hard strong quick low to the ground player is dropped for a heavy track, gee.

[McQueen 17,865]

_{Nothing untoward said Fat Eddie, to Johnsons knee to Jones' head. Wet weather footy he said........Unbelievable.}

What a prik.

[Geddy Lee 582]

Whoever dropped Rodan when it was going to rain, with the ball on the ground so much,take a bow.

A hard strong quick low to the ground player is dropped for a heavy track, gee.

A Mickey Mouse operation, year in, year out.

[Bonkers 994]

For the most part the effort has been there. Some of our players being overwhelmed with the physical side of Geelongs game, too many strong bodies in midfield. Also Craig allowed the Cats to sit a player behind the ball for the most part of the first half making it very difficult to move the ball forward in these conditions. Our defense is holding up relatively well. We have one two many Talls up forward making it hard to compete at ground level & lock the ball inside forward 50 as well as compete through the midfield. As one poster noted Fitzy will most likely be subbed as he is ineffective at the moment due to the conditions.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

I'm OS at the moment and have to listen to KRock who actively support Geelong, but they are saying that we are playing too defensively and are playing from behind so we can't possibly win because there is no offensive effort in our game. Is that about it?

[Jaded No More 68,965]

You watching the game mate? Have you noticed the weak tackling and lack of run, even compared to the last couple of weeks? We look like we're playing under the weight of 186 today. Dispirited and gutless.

You are an idiot.

Seriously, we are playing the best team in the comp, in howling rain, at their ground.

Get a grip. We are down by 36 points and we are struggling. But to say we aren't trying is a pathetic comment.

[dees189227 12,394]

Listening to it on the radio they are saying that dawes has taylor and bartel on him when he goes for the ball and has no hope of getting it.

Is it still raining heavily down there?

[45HG 1,539]

55 tackles in a half of footy - heading towards a team record high tackles. Playing the best team in the comp, probably the best team of the modern era and arguably the best team of all time. We are the second worst side in the competition. We are playing in Geelong, where they have won 37 of their last 38 matches (only losing to that year's Premier by a couple of goals).

Effort is not the problem. Strength around the ball, proper use of the ball and knowledge of where to run are much bigger issues.

Cats players working players off the ball and using teammates who instinctively run to the right areas make a team look like they aren't trying. Geez - any time a better team [censored] a lower team people whinge that the players aren't trying - conveniently ignoring the glaring differences between the sides.

It's a dullards way of looking at a game (such as today's) where people essentially are saying that if the players tried harder we'd be winning.

You are a dill

You watching the game mate? Have you noticed the weak tackling and lack of run, even compared to the last couple of weeks? We look like we're playing under the weight of 186 today. Dispirited and gutless.

You mean like when we beat a terrible Bulldogs side by 3 points or when we were comfortably beaten by a side in first gear on our home ground in perfect weather for footy? You look like you're looking for cheap excuses and easy answers - they don't look like they're playing under the weight of 186, you look like you're desperately trying to attach an association that isn't there.

Lack of run? It's bloody wet weather footy against a side dominating stoppages and using numbers well - we are a crap side with crap decision makers and terrible skills.

[stuie 7,374]

You are an [censored].

Seriously, we are playing the best team in the comp, in howling rain, at their ground.

Get a grip. We are down by 36 points and we are struggling. But to say we aren't trying is a pathetic comment.

Oh ok, so we've stopped running and tackling because we're playing the best team... Good strategy.

[McQueen 17,865]

I'm OS at the moment and have to listen to KRock who actively support Geelong, but they are saying that we are playing too defensively and are playing from behind so we can't possibly win because there is no offensive effort in our game. Is that about it?

Barely a contest that we're in front of and our tackles are not sticking when the ball comes to ground. They just clear it far too easily.

[Redleg 40,948]

You are an [censored].

Seriously, we are playing the best team in the comp, in howling rain, at their ground.

Get a grip. We are down by 36 points and we are struggling. But to say we aren't trying is a pathetic comment.

Agree.

Some blokes wouldn't now a football from their arse.

[Jaded No More 68,965]

The biggest disappointment so far is that Sylvia's 150th is about as good as his 1st game. He is a wasted talent. Can't imagine that will ever change.

[The HuLK 139]

We are playing like we used too under neeld!!!

[The HuLK 139]

Get in front!!!!! FFS

[stuie 7,374]

How many times today do we have to see a Geelong player receive the ball while his Melbourne opponent, who is 5 metres behind him, all of a sudden wakes up and tries to run over to him?

If you're excusing today's effort then you must have been really happy with Neeld.

[Soidee 1,496]

This club has recruited too many B grade footballers. It is not rocket science for us supporters who have to watch this garbage year in year out.

[P-man 13,366]

If we keep holding it up and kicking to a contest we are going to continue to get brutalised. They are far superior and frankly hungrier in winning contested ball so its just going to keep coming back the other way. If we can just get some possession chains going I'll be happy.

Davey MUST get into this game. 4 disposals in a half of footy. Turn it up Aaron, you're a senior player. Start playing like one.

[Dee Fan 3,247]

Barely a contest that we're in front of and our tackles are not sticking when the ball comes to ground. They just clear it far too easily.

Thanks I stopped listening to the radio and from half way through the second quarter have been watching the stats on afl site. It's less frustrating but you don't know what is actually happening. They did at one stage say that Dunn gave a two fisted punch away and if he could do that them why didn't he mark it; Dunn seems to do that a lot and also is quite happy at times to let the ball run oob when he is by himself and can get too it. Seems as if he just doesn't have confidence in his own ability.

[whatwhat say what 22,780]

we are still woefully soft.

but the effort is there, as it has been since craig took over.

gotta sign gawn up, for such big bloke he just is so capable, and he has the best underwear on the ground.

lovely goal by byrnes.

Edited July 13, 2013 by DemonAndrew

[45HG 1,539]

Ricciuto and King agree.

"Melbourne's effort today has been first class and they're just up against an opposition that is just too good for them."

"You just want to see the players have a go and young kids come through - and they're ticking those boxes."

[Mongrel Dee 56]

Ricciuto and King agree.

"Melbourne's effort today has been first class and they're just up against an opposition that is just too good for them."

"You just want to see the players have a go and young kids come through - and they're ticking those boxes."

Dream on!