Votes please 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1 ...

6 N Jones, who is just about our only AFL level player.

5 Viney, who's as good a young kid as you could hope for

4 Terlich, who gave us some run and layed a few great tackles

3 M Jones, who is already one of our better mids

2 McDonald, who has the makings of a brilliant CHB if he can just get his Joel MacDonald-like errors out of his game

1 Bail, who showed effort and courage in the face of great adversity. Hopefully he can continue his career without damaging his post-AFL life.

6. N. Jones

5. Sylvia

4. Terlich

3. Viney

2. M.Jones

1. Bail

6 - N. Jones

5 - M. Jones

4 - Tapscott

3 - Sylvia

2 - Clark

1 - Terlich

Edited April 13, 201312 yr by Sylvia Saint

6-Jones N

5- Sylvia

4- Jones M

3- Viney

2- MeTerlicha

1- Clark

6. N.Jones

5. Sylvia

4. M.Jones

3. Grimes

2. Terlich

1. McDonald/Trengove

Honourable mention to Mitch Clark who kicked three goals from limited oppotunitys.

Nobody could sneak Garland or Frawley in, despite leaking about 13 goals between them

Terlich? Had a whole collection of really awful clangers.

For mine, I'd slot Tom McDonald into the list instead of Terlich. Really battled hard all day, won a lot of contests and gave a lot of run, and kept being let down by lack of support.

6. M.Jones

5.N.Jones

4. Terlich

3. Trengove

2.Sylvia

1. Tapscott

6-N. Jones

5 - M. Jones

4 - Sylvia

3 - Terlich

2- Trengove

1 - McDonald

Honourable mentions - Mitch Clark, Evans & Tapscott.

I can't believe my eyes.

Terlich?!!??!

Made our bottom 6, for mine.

Turned it over almost every single time he had the ball! He appeared to have no idea what he was doing, often taking off in a beeline before not knowing where he was going.

Wow.

Anyway:

6 - N. Jones

5 - Sylvia

4 - McDonald

3 - Grimes

2 - Clark

1 - Viney

6: Jones N.

5: Jones the other

4: Sylvia

3: Terlich

2: Grimes

1: McDonald

Considering how poor we have been at getting the ball, at least Terlich went and got the bloody thing.

I agree about Tom McDonald. He looks amazing at times but was flogged one-on-one today. His aerial defence needs work

6. N. Jones.

5. M Jones

4. C. Sylvia

3. L. Tapscott

2. D. Terlich

1. J. Trengove

6 N Jones

5 Sylvia

4 Clark

3 M Jones

2 Viney

1 Grimes

Terlich was a goer and holds his place Tapscott may have got a vote but for the three clangers in a row in the third right in front of me. Cheers to Davey and Howe for a couple of highlights that got me off my seat!

6. N Jones

5. Sylvia

4. M Jones

3. Terlich

2. Grimes

1. McDonald

N Jones

M Jones

Sylvia

Clark

Bail

Terlich - Good ball use.

I thought Grimes chopped it up alot today, rather indecisive. Trengove still looks slow - was outrun by Cox at one point.

Terlich - Good ball use.

We definitely were not watching the same game.

6 Sylvia

5 T Mac

4 Clarke

3 N jones

2 M jones

1 Bail

Edited April 13, 201312 yr by cowboy_from_hell

6. N Jones

5. Sylvia

4. M Jones

3. Viney

2. Trengove [loved his mark]

1. Clark [from limited opportunities]

We definitely were not watching the same game.

He had a couple of clangers which stood out but in general his ball use and run was much better than what we've been getting from down back, not that it would be too hard.

Nobody could sneak Garland or Frawley in, despite leaking about 13 goals between them

Play them in our forward line and hope they leak some our way for a change

6 - Clark
5 - M Jones
4 - Howe
3 - TMac
2 - Bail
1 - Evans

Nathan Jones - 28 disposals; 1 effective. Not for me.

Ed: 1st? qtr, Grimes leaves his man in centre of ground to man up; calls/points to his man to be covered....N Jones nearest player on his own....didn't/wouldn't/couldn't cover...man got the ball...QED

Edited April 13, 201312 yr by Mono

6 NJones

5 MJones

4 Terlich

3 TMac

2 Clark

1 Bail

6. N Jones

5. Sylvia

4. M. Jones

3. Terlich

2. Viney

1. Clark

Close: Howe, McDonald, Bail

6 - N. Jones

5 - Viney

4 - M. Jones

3 - Sylvia

2 - T Mac

1 - Terlich